The Chaplin Machine Slapstick, Fordism and the Communist Avant-Garde (Review)

Pamir Dietrich, Ayşe
The book is comprised of four main sections in addition to an excerpt from Charles Chaplin’s speech in the film The Great Dictator (1940)[1], an introduction at the beginning, and a conclusion along with acknowledgements, notes and an index at the end. The introduction, titled Americanism and Fordism – and Chaplinism discusses the immediate aftermath of the revolutionary wave of enthusiasm among the leaders of the Soviet Union to develop oppressive and anti-worker methods to increase productivity in the new Socialist state in accordance with the principles of American industrial theorist and engineer Frederich Winslow Taylor’s and Henry Ford. It discusses the interplay between industrial organization, comic entertainment and socialist politics in the aesthetics of the avant-garde; and gives a different perspective on Chaplin through the eyes of the avant-garde, as well as a thorough examination of American comedy in the late 1910s and early 1920s. The first section of the book, Constructing the Chaplin Machine, talks about Chaplinism and the inhumanity of Chaplin as a consequence of universalism. By being branded anti-human, Chaplin is treated as a machine and a super human (sur-human) which serves as a paradigm for the avant-garde. In this chapter the reception of Chaplin by the Soviet and Weimar avant-garde is also discussed. The second section titled Red Clowns to the Rescue discusses Taylorism, the appearance of biomechanics - a fusion of Taylorism and Chaplinism and Taylorized - acting in the Soviet Union and the Red Clowns, the circus elements of biomechanics, Eccentrism and the Factory of the Eccentric Actor (FEX), the new Soviet comedy, and the new stupidity which portrays the Western perception of Bolshevism and stupidities of bureaucracy and the NEP. The third section titled No Rococo Palace for Buster Keaton: Architectures of Americanism talks about Keaton’s film One Week that was a satirical response to the Ford Motor Company documentary Home Made (1919) about prefabricated housing. Buster Keaton’s distorted building shapes even had its influence on the towers for the Comintern in the 1920s. The film itself is not only slapstick, but also combines architecture, technology and motorization. Similarly, Soviet industry, Americanist archetypical skyscraper motifs, Reklamarchitektur, the display of construction, the characteristics of billboards and posters as a mass-produced indicator of the political aesthetics of the NEP, and 1920s modernist architecture (Derzhprom etc.) wereused in many Soviet films as the object of satire or utopian dreaming. The final section, The Rhythm of Socialist Construction: Soviet Sound Film and the Creation of an Industrial Economy, discusses the planned economy, the foundations of a modern industrial state described in the First Five Year Plan (1928-32), the assistance of American companies in Soviet industrial expansion (DniproGES etc.), the earlier Soviet sound films using sound, images, music and the technology of sound recordings (Esfir Shub’s in Komsomol Patron of Electrification etc.), the national vs. international context of the Soviet sound films (Vsevolod Pudovkin’s Deserter etc.), and animated films depicting the situation after collectivization in the Soviet countryside (Nikolai Khodataev’s The Little Music Box etc. ). In the conclusion, the eccentric period of the Soviet cinema where the combination of historical accounts of workers’ struggles and the devices from slapstick, the musicals which influenced the Soviet productions Jolly Fellows, Circus, Volga-Volga, Eccentric Manifesto and the Chaplinesque approach of Circus, and the end of Chaplinism in Soviet Circuses around the late 1970s are all discussed. In his book, Owen Hatheley has provided a masterly presentation depicting the parody which existed under a communist regime; and showed how Soviet film, art and arhitecture could not avoid the influence of capitalist Americanism (Fordism, Taylorism) and Chaplin’s slapstick style of comedy. It is a pioneering work in the field of early film studies and politics.
International Journal of Russian Studies


Subversion of the empire and colonial spatial narratives in Joseph Conrad's heart of darkness and almayer's folly
Vargün, Ahmet Can; Yıldız Bağçe, Hülya; Department of English Literature (2019)
This thesis analyses narrative spaces of Joseph Conrad’s Heart of Darkness (1899) and Almayer’s Folly (1895) to better situate him within the discussions of whether his works strengthen the colonial discourse or disturb it. In the light of the postcolonial spatiality Sara Upstone, Bill Ashcroft, and John Noyes develop, which discuss colonization spatially via the concepts of rewriting, negation, and forcing newness, this thesis argues that Joseph Conrad problematizes colonial spatial absolutism. Colonial di...
The death of the author in the streetscape of Ankara: A Barthesian intervention into critical toponymy
Düzgün, Doğuş; Alpan, Başak Zeynep; Department of Political Science and Public Administration (2020-9)
In this thesis I use the post-structuralist textual theory of Roland Barthes that is known as ‘the death of the author’ in order to explain the politics of street names. Barthes argued that in the literary texts author cannot fix the meaning as it is the readers who produce the meaning. In a similar way, I argue that the streetscape is a polysemous text in which the meaning is produced by readers (everyday users) rather than authors (the political elites that officially determine the street names). Implicat...
The outsiders as reflected in the novels of Albert Camus, John Wain and Yusuf Atilgan
Bay, Hatice; Coşkunoğlu Bear, Ayten; Department of English Literature (2008)
This thesis studies the alienated characters of Albert Camus’s The Outsider, John Wain’s Hurry On Down and Yusuf Atılgan’s Aylak Adam, respectively. It argues that each of the protagonists of these novels experiences alienation. That is, Camus’s character is an alienated man because he has the characteristics of an absurd man; Wain’s character is an estranged man due to his social discontentment and Atılgan’s C. is an outsider owing to his psychological problems. The works are analyzed with philosophical, s...
The Importance of the Meno on the transition from the early to the middle Platonic dialogues
Seferoğlu, Tonguç; Bağçe, Samet; Department of Philosophy (2012)
The purpose of the present study is to signify the explanatory value of the Meno on the coherence as well as the disparateness of the Plato’s early and middle dialogues. Indeed, the Meno exposes the transition on the content and form of these dialogues. The first part of the dialogue resembles the Socrates’ way of investigation, the so-called Elenchus, whereas Plato presents his own philosophical project in the second part of the dialogue. Three fundamental elements of Plato’s middle dialogues explicitly ar...
The end: the apocalyptic in in-yer-face drama
Bal, Mustafa; Sönmez, Margaret Jeanne M.; Department of English Literature (2009)
This thesis presents a close analysis of one of the ageless discourses of human life – apocalypse, or the End – within the highly controversial In-Yer-Face drama of the 1990s British stage. The study particularly argues that there is a strong apocalyptic sense in the plays of the decade, and it discovers that the apocalyptic representation within these plays varies. Five plays by three prominent playwrights of the decade are used to illustrate and expand the focus. After a detailed examination of the apocal...
Citation Formats
A. Pamir Dietrich, “The Chaplin Machine Slapstick, Fordism and the Communist Avant-Garde (Review),” International Journal of Russian Studies, vol. 6, no. 6/1 2017, pp. 99–100, 2017, Accessed: 00, 2023. [Online]. Available: