Kant's combat against empirical idealism

Date

2025-1

Author

Tuncel, Kutlu

Metadata

Show full item record

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.

Item Usage Stats

51
views

33
downloads

Cite This

This thesis is intended to scrutinize Kant‘s empirical realism along with his rejection of empirical idealism in the Critique of Pure Reason. The central idea of the thesis is that Kant‘s empirical realism is robust or genuine and this is essential to his divorce from Humean skeptical empiricism, Cartesian skeptical idealism, and Berkeleian phenomenalism, all of which are forms of empirical idealism. In this context, I first deal with Kant‘s transcendental idealism and the ―Transcendental Aesthetic‖ via the epistemological two aspect view. Second, I reconstruct the ―Transcendental Deduction‖ and particularly focus on apperception, constitution of objecthood, and figurative synthesis. Here, I argue that Kant is anti Humean, in that he shows a priori concepts are necessary for experience. Third, I examine the ―Refutation of Idealism,‖ suggesting that Kant ruptures from Cartesian epistemology and its representationalism. So, although the Kantian appearances are mind dependent in the epistemological sense, they are mind independent in the ontological sense. To elaborate further, on the reading I suggest, Kant holds the view that empirical objects are public and immediately cognized; in contrast, Cartesian epistemology claims that the cognition of empirical objects is mediate and private, viz., cognized via and derived from mental content. Finally, I advocate that Kant‘s idealism is not like Berkeleian phenomenalism and provide several reasons for this. Thus, I suggest that reading Kant‘s account as phenomenalism is misleading.

Subject Keywords

Empirical idealism, Empirical realism, Kant, Phenomenalism/Phenomenalist reading, Transcendental idealism

URI

https://hdl.handle.net/11511/113364

Collections

Graduate School of Social Sciences, Thesis