Resemblance : a logico-philosophical analysis

Taşdelen, İskender
Indiscernibility, interchangeability and resemblance relations may be named as weak-identity relations or identity-like relations. Indeed,identical objects can be thought to satisfy all these three relations. According to realist view, these relations are defined on the basis of properties of objects. While indiscernibility is a context-independent relation, since indiscernibility is defined in terms of all properties of objects, interchangeability and resemblance relations are defined in terms of some significant properties of objects and thus they should be regarded as context-dependent. We should consider the following points while comparing rivalling theories of resemblance: 1. The theory explaining resemblance relations between objects should cover as many domains as possible. Instead of simply admitting that objects of a given type may resemble each other, the theory should explain how these relations are possible. 2. Objects do not just resemble or they do not; resemblance is a relation that admits degrees. Thus the theory providing a finer analysis of close and weak resemblances should be preferred. In comparison to resemblance nominalism, realist theory of resemblance is strongerwith respect to both points. The criticism that realist view may not explain degrees of resemblance can be rejoined by removing the indeterminacy as to the nature of this notion.Among knowledge representation systems, property and attribute systems provide a simple but strong models for analytic ontology. Weak identity relations can easily be defined in these systems and the results following from these definitions can be seen to conform to our intuitions about weak identity relations.


The Nagorno Karabakh conflict and its impact on the relations between Azerbaijan and Turkey
Efe, Almula; Tanrısever, Oktay Fırat; Department of Eurasian Studies (2012)
This thesis seeks to examine the relations between Azerbaijan and Turkey in terms of the role that the Nagorno Karabakh conflict plays in this relationship. The Nagorno Karabakh conflict, which is one of the long-lasting ethno-territorial conflicts in the region, continues to be the major issue-area for Azerbaijan’s foreign policy. In this respect, Azerbaijan’s relations with Turkey, as well as NATO, the United States and Russia could be understood better through an academic study of the Nagorno Karabakh co...
The Iranian nuclear isssue : assessment of Turkey's role
İlhan, Özkan; Kibaroğlu, Ayşegül; Department of International Relations (2011)
This thesis assesses the role of Turkey in the diplomatic process towards resolution of the Iranian nuclear issue within the context of its improving bilateral relations with Iran and analyzes the motives behind increasing Turkish involvement in this issue. Firstly, this thesis will present a historical overview of Iran‟s nuclear program and the dispute arising from this program. Secondly, the attitudes of the major stakeholders who have been dealing with this issue since the inception will be put under spo...
Öner Tangör, Neyyire Nilgün; Yalman, Galip; Department of Area Studies (2021-4)
The Cyprus Problem was predominantly studied as a protracted conflict of clashing nationalisms and the TRNC-Turkey relation was depicted as a “dependency relation” that developed between a core and a periphery. This thesis suggests an alternative reading for both issues and analyses their relationship from a critical political economy perspective based on a realist epistemology by using the “dialectical method of inquiry”. It considers the Cyprus problem not only as an intercommunal conflict but more pertin...
Small state playing the asymmetric game: continuity and change in Albanian foreign policy
Açar, Dilaver Arıkan; Türkeş, Mustafa; Department of International Relations (2008)
This thesis examines Albanian foreign policy from a small state point of view.The main argument is that Albania as a weak small state developed close relations with the regional and great powers and align with them in order to compensate its weakness. An historical analysis of the Albanian foreign policy line since its establishment portrays a continuity in this trend except the short isolationist period. The study has three main objectives, firstly, it aims to provide an analysis of the small state foreign...
Negotiation techniques in turkish foreign policy: wto doha round negotiation process and its implications for turkey’s relations with its neighbors
Sönmez, Hacı Mehmet; Bağcı, Hüseyin; Department of International Relations (2010)
This thesis analyzes World Trade Organization Doha Round negotiation process and its implications for Turkey’s relations with its neighbors. The thesis mainly focuses on two pillars of negotiating package, namely agricultural and non-agricultural products (NAMA) negotiations. Both segments of negotiations have different dimensions due to Turkey’s regional and multilateral obligations. As a developing country, Turkey’s position in agriculture is more in line with other developing countries; in NAMA however i...
Citation Formats
İ. Taşdelen, “Resemblance : a logico-philosophical analysis ,” Ph.D. - Doctoral Program, Middle East Technical University, 2005.