Israel and Palestine face2face

Download

index.pdf

Date

2009

Author

Çetin, İdil

Metadata

Show full item record

Item Usage Stats

131
views

55
downloads

Face2Face is a photographic project realized by JR, an undercover photographer and Marco, a technology consultant, in 2007 in the Middle East context. It consisted of taking the portraits of Israeli and Palestinian people who were doing the same job, printing them in huge formats and putting them on various unavoidable places in Israeli and Palestinian cities. The project was based on the idea that Israeli and Palestinian people were so much similar to each other, as if they were ‘twin brothers raised in different families’ but that they were not aware of that. Therefore, the artists decided to provide them with images of the other side which would make people be surprised, laugh, stop for a while and think about the other side once again. The artists hoped that such a reworking of the ideas about the other side would hopefully motivate people to enter into dialogue with each other, which would eventually end up in peaceful co-existence. This thesis sets this photographic project as its starting point. It focuses upon its conceptualization of dialogue, which is based on the idea of seeing the other from a new perspective, and compares it with Mikhail Bakhtin’s concept of dialogue and Emmanuel Levinas’s concept of face-to-face, which are based on the idea of disrupting the self. It then criticizes the project for its neglect of various dimensions which shape Israeli and Palestinian identities, such as diaspora, nostalgia and home and of the heavy burden of the past on these two communities’ present. As a result, the thesis focuses upon the concept of collective memory at length and then discusses photography at the service of collective memory. Another section is devoted to the analysis of Israeli and Palestinian collective memories. The photographic project Face2Face is discussed all throughout the thesis in terms of its failure to spot the crucial dimensions in Israeli-Palestinian context, no matter how well intended it was.

Subject Keywords

Sociology.

URI

http://etd.lib.metu.edu.tr/upload/12610825/index.pdf
https://hdl.handle.net/11511/18784

Collections

Graduate School of Social Sciences, Thesis

Suggestions

OpenMETU
Core

An architectural study on miniature parks and miniature models : Miniaturk Osmanoğlu, Esin; Bursa, Nihal; Department of Architecture (2005) This thesis is an architectural study surveying on miniature parks and miniature models exhibited in them and particularly focuses on Miniaturk - the first miniature park of Turkey- located in Istanbul. It is established as an environment containing a group of miniature models of buildings and landscapes, which display the variety, and richness of the cultural tradition of the previous and contemporary Anatolian civilizations, and especially Ottoman grandeur. In this study, it is argued that Miniaturk stand...
The mallification of urban life in Ankara: the case of Ankamall Akçaoğlu, Aksu; Ayata, Sencer; Department of Sociology (2008) This study investigates the emergence of a shopping mall based urban life in Ankara. As the city is under the siege with the mushrooming growth of shopping malls, the urban life gains a new attribute. The economical, social, and cultural institutions and activities of the city are collected under the roof of the mall, and distinctions out of the shopping mall are formed and reproduced around the consumption activities of the mall. Based on a qualitative research which was conducted in ANKAmall, this study i...
The making of a 'city of culture' : restructuring Antalya Varlı-Görk, Reyhan; Nalbantoğlu, Hasan Ünal; Department of Sociology (2010) This study tries to identify agencies’ strategies in the ‘urban restructuring’ of Antalya into a ‘city of culture’ by examining the underlying relation between urban cultural policies and global capitalism. Pursuing the relational thinking of the Marxist urban political economy paradigm, the theoretical frames for the concepts of ‘restructuring’ and ‘city of culture’ were investigated using multi-dimensional approaches of existing scholarly literature. Since the concept ‘city of culture’ involves growth ori...
The ethos of architects towards an analysis of architectural practice in Turkey Fehim Kennedy, Nilgün; Nalbantoğlu, Hasan Ünal; Department of Sociology (2005) A certain architectural "ethos" come into being as a result of the specific training which architects receive as producers of space, of their dual status as artists and professionals, of the conditions in which they live and the social status of their profession. This ethos is a product of the architects' collective habitus. The attitudes of architects regarding their position in the building industry, their role in society and their self-image (or its lack of) as artists determine the transformation within...
Civil society in Iran Özdemir Samur, Zelal; Ergun Özbolat, Ayça; Department of Sociology (2008) This thesis aims to understand how civil society developed and evolved in the modern history of Iran and how it operates in the current day through the eyes of the actors of this realm. The fieldwork of the study was conducted in Tehran in 2006. This study, while questioning the liberal understanding of civil society, endeavours to contemplate a consistent framework in which the Iranian civil society activities could be located. The Iranian case proved the existence of a vivid civil society despite a repres...

Citation Formats

İ. Çetin, “Israel and Palestine face2face,” M.S. - Master of Science, Middle East Technical University, 2009.