A multi-criteria penalty function approach for evaluating a priori model parameter estimates

2015-06-01
Yılmaz, Koray Kamil
Wagener, Thorsten
A priori parameterization approaches that improve our ability to provide reliable hydrologic predictions in ungauged and poorly gauged basins, as well as in basins undergoing change are currently receiving considerable attention. However, such methods are typically based on local-scale process understanding and simplifying assumptions and an increasing body of evidence suggests that hydrologic models that utilize parameters estimated via such approaches may not always perform well. This paper proposes a Maximum Likelihood multi-criteria penalty function strategy for evaluating a priori parameter estimation approaches. We demonstrate the method by examining the extent to which a priori parameter estimates specified for the Hydrology Laboratory's Research Distributed Hydrologic Model (via a set of pedotransfer functions) are consistent with the optimal model parameters required to simulate the dynamic input-output response of the Blue River basin. Our results indicated that whereas simulations using the a priori parameter estimates give consistently positive flow bias, unconstrained optimization to the response data results in parameter values that are very different from the a priori parameter set. Moreover, although unconstrained optimization performed best (as measured by the calibration criteria), poor hydrograph simulation performance was evident when evaluated in terms of multiple performance statistics not used in the calibration. On the other hand, the multi-criteria compromise solutions provided improved input-output performance in terms of measures not used in calibration, with generally more consistent behavior across calibration and evaluation years, while maintaining physically realistic a priori values for most of the model parameter estimates; adjustments were found to be necessary for only a few key model parameters.
JOURNAL OF HYDROLOGY

Suggestions

Probabilistic modeling of plane failure in rock slopes
DUZGUN, HSB; Yücemen, Mehmet Semih; Karpuz, Celal (2003-07-09)
The basic aim of this study is to formulate a probabilistic method by which sources of uncertainties can be taken into account and systematically analyzed in dealing with the rock slope stability problem. For this purpose, the advanced first-order second-moment (AFOSM) method and the Monte Carlo simulation (MCS) procedure are used to model the plane failure problem in rock slopes. The modeling of plane failure by the AFOSM and the MCS methods requires the understanding of the basic mechanism of plane failur...
A new approach to multivariate adaptive regression splines by using Tikhonov regularization and continuous optimization
TAYLAN, PAKİZE; Weber, Gerhard Wilhelm; Ozkurt, Fatma Yerlikaya (2010-12-01)
This paper introduces a model-based approach to the important data mining tool Multivariate adaptive regression splines (MARS), which has originally been organized in a more model-free way. Indeed, MARS denotes a modern methodology from statistical learning which is important in both classification and regression, with an increasing number of applications in many areas of science, economy and technology. It is very useful for high-dimensional problems and shows a great promise for fitting nonlinear multivar...
Modeling and implementation of local volatility surfaces in Bayesian framework
Animoku, Abdulwahab; Uğur, Ömür; Yolcu-Okur, Yeliz (2018-06-01)
In this study, we focus on the reconstruction of volatility surfaces via a Bayesian framework. Apart from classical methods, such as, parametric and non-parametric models, we study the Bayesian analysis of the (stochastically) parametrized volatility structure in Dupire local volatility model. We systematically develop and implement novel mathematical tools for handling the classical methods of constructing local volatility surfaces. The most critical limitation of the classical methods is obtaining negativ...
A Case study for calculating and reporting the uncertainty budget of 1 and 2 dimensional combined hydraulic model
Gül, Uğraş Sidar; Altan Sakarya, Ayşe Burcu; Department of Civil Engineering (2019)
This study aims to suggest a framework to quantify and report the uncertainty budget of a 1 & 2 dimensional hydraulic model of five possible error sources by using ISO GUM method. The river engineers take into account several considerations when they design the riverbeds; one of the main considerations is the flood protection aspect of the riverbed, to asses that a hydraulic model is usually prepared. However, results generated from the hydraulic models are not exempt from errors. The ISO GUM method provide...
A Kalman filter-based approach to reduce the effects of geometric errors and the measurement noise in the inverse ECG problem
Aydin, Umit; Serinağaoğlu Doğrusöz, Yeşim (Springer Science and Business Media LLC, 2011-09-01)
In this article, we aimed to reduce the effects of geometric errors and measurement noise on the inverse problem of Electrocardiography (ECG) solutions. We used the Kalman filter to solve the inverse problem in terms of epicardial potential distributions. The geometric errors were introduced into the problem via wrong determination of the size and location of the heart in simulations. An error model, which is called the enhanced error model (EEM), was modified to be used in inverse problem of ECG to compens...
Citation Formats
K. K. Yılmaz and T. Wagener, “A multi-criteria penalty function approach for evaluating a priori model parameter estimates,” JOURNAL OF HYDROLOGY, pp. 165–177, 2015, Accessed: 00, 2020. [Online]. Available: https://hdl.handle.net/11511/35955.