What Is It Like To Become a Rat? Animal Phenomenology through Uexkull and Deleuze & Guattari

Date

2017-01-01

Author

Shores, Corry Michael

Metadata

Show full item record

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.

Item Usage Stats

155
views

0
downloads

We respond to a phenomenological challenge set forth in Thomas Nagel's "What Is It Like To Be a Bat?," namely, to seek a method for obtaining a phenomenological description of non-human animal experience faithful to an animal's first-person subjective perspective. First, we examine "translational" strategies employing empathy and communication with animals. Then we turn to a "transpositional" strategy from Uexkull's Umwelt theory in which we objectively determine the components of a non-human animal's subjective world of experience and then map those coordinates onto our own subjective world. While this method gives us partial access to the animal's "perception-world" aspect of its Umwelt, it does not inform us about what it is like to live in the interactive, "effectworld" aspect. To better overcome this limitation, we add a "transformational" approach derived from Deleuze's & Guattari's notion of "becoming-animal," in which we take on an animal's manners and capacities for interacting with the other objects and creatures in its world.

Subject Keywords

Deleuze & Guattari, Thomas Nagel, Jakob von Uexkull, Umwelt, Becoming-animal

URI

https://hdl.handle.net/11511/39179

Journal

STUDIA PHAENOMENOLOGICA

DOI

https://doi.org/10.5840/studphaen20171710

Collections

Department of Philosophy, Article

Suggestions

OpenMETU
Core

Ecocentric polyphony: the subversion of dualistic thinking in Dylan Thomas’s poetry Altındağ, Zümrüt; Birlik, Nurten; Department of English Literature (2019) As part of its subversion of dichotomous logic, ecocriticism draws attention to the significant function the literary works can play in the process of calling for fundamental changes in the ethical values regarding the appreciation of the ecological interconnectedness between the human and the nonhuman beings. In this respect, post-pastoral literature and ecopoetry target dichotomous logic and try to revitalise ecocentrism. This thesis argues that prior to the introduction of these two recent ecocritical fr...
On the Evolutionary Origin of Morality Sakin Hanoğlu, Derya (2022-03-01) In this study, I will approach morality from a naturalistic perspective and defend that morality is a product of evolutionary processes shared by both human and non-human animals rather than that of human culture. My naturalistic approach is based on simpler components instead of high-level cognitive capabilities such as cognition. Rationality, judgment, and free will are indeed presented as necessary for morality in classical definitions of morality. However, I will put forward that the roots of morality c...
Preschool children's use of perceptual-motor knowledge and hierarchical representational skills for tool making Gönül, Gökhan; Takmaz, Ece; Hohenberger, Annette Edeltraud (2021-10-01) Although other animals can make simple tools, the expanded and complex material culture of humans is unprecedented in the animal kingdom. Tool making is a slow and late-developing ability in humans, and preschool children find making tools to solve problems very challenging. This difficulty in tool making might be related to the lack of familiarity with the tools and may be overcome by children's long term perceptual-motor knowledge. Thus, in this study, the effect of tool familiarity on tool making was inv...
In What Sense Exactly Are Human Beings More Political According to Aristotle? Güremen, Refik (2018-06-01) According to Aristotle, human beings are by nature political animals. It is now common knowledge that being political is not a human privilege for him: bees, wasps, ants and cranes are other political species. Although they are not the only political animals, human beings, for Aristotle, are still more political than the other political animals. The present article investigates the precise sense of this comparison; and it claims that the higher degree of human politicalness is not to be explained by referen...
Study of effects of selective hunting on a bear population through pva simulation Ağzıtemiz, Mehmet Melih; Bilgin, Cemal Can; Department of Biology (2008) Management of big wildlife such as bears can be a difficult task, especially in the face of human-wildlife conflict and demands of the hunting industry. The Brown Bear (Ursus arctos) population at Yusufeli County (Artvin, northeastern Turkey) has recently been the focus of scientific, social and economic concerns. This study population of c. 140 individuals occurs within 800 km2 of forested and alpine land. Legal hunting of male bears was allowed in 2007 after an interval of four years. This study aims to f...

Citation Formats

C. M. Shores, “What Is It Like To Become a Rat? Animal Phenomenology through Uexkull and Deleuze & Guattari,” STUDIA PHAENOMENOLOGICA, pp. 201–221, 2017, Accessed: 00, 2020. [Online]. Available: https://hdl.handle.net/11511/39179.