The given in perceptual experience

Date

2015-08-01

Author

Demircioglu, Erhan

Metadata

Show full item record

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.

Item Usage Stats

35
views

0
downloads

How are we to account for the epistemic contribution of our perceptual experiences to the reasonableness of our perceptual beliefs? It is well known that a conception heavily influenced by Cartesian thinking has it that experiences do not enable the experiencing subject to have direct epistemic contact with the external world; rather, they are regarded as openness to a kind of private inner realm that is interposed between the subject and the world. It turns out that if one wants to insist that perceptual experiences provide epistemic reasons for perceptual beliefs about the external world as we pre-reflectively take it to be, then one should find a way of avoiding Cartesianism. Here are the two main aims of this paper: firstly, identify the premise that is doing the heavy-lifting work in the Cartesian thinking; and, secondly, formulate an adequate way of denying that premise. The adequacy I claim for my formulation of a way of denying the premise will roughly amount to this: the way I offer is not as susceptible to Cartesian traps as other apparently available ways of denying the premise are.

Subject Keywords

Epistemic given, Empirical rationality, Disjunctivism, John McDowell, Anil Gupta

URI

https://hdl.handle.net/11511/64211

Journal

SYNTHESE

DOI

https://doi.org/10.1007/s11229-015-0730-4

Collections

Department of Philosophy, Article

Suggestions

OpenMETU
Core

THE ART OF MEMORY IN A PLURALISTIC UNIVERSE: WILLIAM JAMES'S "REPUBLICAN BANQUET" Çırakman, Elif (2007-06-22) The aim of this paper is to conduct an inquiry that would illuminate how a phenomenological account of memory may govern some basic issues of our lives: the meaning of our collectivity and spirituality, the cultural embodiment of our experiences and memories, and their collective status, the question of intimacy and unity in the universe of our experiences. I shall consider this account of memory by focusing on William James's radically empiricist, pluralist, and pragmatic philosophy. In reading James, my a...
The growing desert: nihilism and metaphysics in Martin Heidegger's thought Duman, Musa; İnam, Ahmet; Department of Philosophy (2009) In this study, we explore Heidegger’s understanding of nihilism as the essential dimension of metaphysics, of metaphysical experience of Being, and in the following, we address his responses to it. Heidegger takes nihilism as rooted in the metaphysical way of thinking, hence metaphysics and nihilism standing in a primordial identity. Such metaphysical way of thinking as a framework in which Being is experinced and articulated, explicitly or implicitly in all areas of Western culture, from art to science, gi...
The Embodiment of the individual self: a conceptualization of body in hegel’s phenomenology of spirit Önder, Sevi Emek; Çırakman, Elif; Department of Philosophy (2018) The primary purpose of this thesis is to investigate and conceptualize the notion of “body” in the context of certain sections of the Phenomenology of Spirit. While investigating the notion of “body” in the thesis, my intention is to see the possibility of reading the Phenomenology as “the science of the embodiment of consciousness”. By relying on this approach, I will try to thematize and give a comprehensive account of the “body” in the “Consciousness” and “Self-Consciousness” sections of the Phenomenolog...
The formation of the self as mental unity and moral agency in hume’s philosophy Neslioğlu, E. Funda; Grünberg, David; Department of Philosophy (2008) This dissertation proposes to analyze the stages in the formation of the idea of self in Hume’s philosophy. According to Hume we have no a simple and individual impression that we can call the self where the self is the totality of conscious life of a person. Nevertheless, we do have an idea of personal identity that must be accounted for. He begins his explanation of this idea by noting that our perceptions are fleeting, and he concludes from this that all we are is a bundle of different perceptions. But ...
THE ARGUMENT FROM CONSCIOUSNESS: A CRITICAL EXAMINATION Özketen, Mehmet; Sol, Ayhan; Department of Philosophy (2022-2-21) This thesis is devoted to critically examining the Argument from Consciousness. The Argument from Consciousness takes consciousness as its datum to arrive at the conclusion that there is a god. Accordingly, one of the premises of the argument draws either on the very existence of consciousness or the correlations between the mental and physical states. There are some different versions of the argument that have been proposed by different philosophers. These different versions of the argument are classified ...

Citation Formats

E. Demircioglu, “The given in perceptual experience,” SYNTHESE, pp. 2667–2693, 2015, Accessed: 00, 2020. [Online]. Available: https://hdl.handle.net/11511/64211.