Nation-state building in Central Asia : a lost case?

2004-01-01
Köksal, Pınar
Show full item record
180
views
0
downloads
With the collapse of the Soviet Union in 1991, the five Central Asian republics of Kazakhstan, Kyrgyzstan, Tajikistan, Turkmenistan, and Uzbekistan have entered a period of nationstate building, which had been started to a large extend by the political elites of the former Soviet Union. These republics were not prepared for independence that came to the region suddenly. The former communist leaders of the Soviet era became the new national elites to take their countries by publicly declared goals and policies through the path of independent nationhood and independent statehood. However, it remains unclear whether this top-to-bottom approach will prove successful in the long run. This article discusses nationstate building in the region by first looking at problems of external sovereignty. Second, domestic state building policies and structures, more specifically, the newly formulated official discourse on-building nation- and the political-legal framework to develop that discourse, are analyzed. Then, the limitations of this process with specific emphasis on supranational identities (basically religious identity of Islam), subnational identities (local and/or tribal identities), and ethnic minorities (with a specific on the Russians in these five countries) are examined. It is concluded that the process of nation-state building in Central Asia is not complete yet and that each republic has unique problems that may challenge this process. For the time being, there exist certain frictions between the goals of the official discourse and nonofficial levels of identity that may hinder the success of the nation building process in the region.
https://hdl.handle.net/11511/78771
https://brill.com/view/journals/pgdt/2/3/article-p409_4.xml?language=en
Department of Political Science and Public Administration, Book / Book chapter

Suggestions

Turkish involvement in higher education in Kazakhstan: the case of international Hoca Ahmet Yesevi Türk-Kazakh University
Türkoğlu, Özcan; Şen, Mustafa; Department of Eurasian Studies (2005)
After the disintegration of the Soviet Union in 1991, Turkey involved in many projects in all spheres with the Central Asian republics. In contrast, less of them have been realized. Turkey was more succesful in educational projects. It has initiated more permanent projects with the republics. In this regard, International Hoca Ahmet Yesevi Turk-Kazakh University, established in 1993 in Turkestan city of Kazakhstan, is one of the first and outstanding project of Turkey not only in education sphere but also i...
The Evolution of National Identity and Nationalism in Azerbaijan (1900-2018)
Guliyeva, Narmin; Ergun Özbolat, Ayça; Department of Sociology (2022-9-22)
The de- and re-construction of national identity have been accelerated in Azerbaijan since the fall of the Soviet Union thanks to which Azerbaijan emerged as an independent nation-state. Azerbaijanism has been promulgated to be the main backbone of state official ideology since independence, except for a short time of Turkism. Though a quarter of a century has passed since the elites started formulating the national identity, it is still incomplete and there from time to time emerges questions about the pro...
Impact of Russia's Military Transformation on Black Sea Security
Mevlütoğlu, Mehmet Arda; Bağcı, Hüseyin; Department of International Relations (2022-9)
After the dissolution of the Soviet Union, Russian Federation struggled to keep its economy, society and military together, not to mention its borders throughout the 1990s. The bad shape of economy and rapidly decomposing capabilities of the armed forces weakened strategic posture and deterrent capability of Russia. Starting from early 2000s, Russia showed signs of recovery in economy, which in turn helped maintenance and upgrade of the armed forces. It was in this period that Russia showed more cooperation...
Azerbaijan's relations with the United States in the post- Soviet Era
Küpçük, Yeliz; Tanrısever, Oktay Fırat; Department of Eurasian Studies (2006)
After the Soviet dissolution, the newly independent post-Soviet state of Azerbaijan intensified its efforts at developing its relations with the United States. Based on the analysis of the AzerbaijanاU.S. relations between1991-2006, the thesis tries to answer which factors could account for the existing political problems between these countries, given that both countries have a common interest in deepening their cooperation concerning the Caspian energy resources as well as the fight against international ...
Reflections of nationalism and the role of language policies in national identity formation in Post-Soviet Azerbaijan
Akyıldız, Selma; Tokluoğlu, Ayşe Ceylan; Department of Eurasian Studies (2019)
After the dissolution of the Soviet Union, the newly independent Azerbaijan has entered its nation-building process. Azerbaijani political elites aimed to re-form national identity through a set of language policies. In this context, they focused on the alphabet, and on the name of the official language which they consider as markers of their national identity. Turkism versus Azerbaijanism as the two competing ideologies have left their mark on this process. Language has been used as a political tool for pr...
Citation Formats
P. Köksal, Nation-state building in Central Asia : a lost case? 2004, p. 429.
METU IIS - Integrated Information Service open@metu.edu.tr