Assembling the Ethnic Identity in the Early Modern Ottoman Society through Clothing Consumption

2017-06-30
Assembling the Ethnic Identity in the Early Modern Ottoman Society through Clothing Consumption Eminegül Karababa Department of Business Administration, Middle East Technical University, Ankara, Turkey Assembling the Ethnic Identity in the Early Modern Ottoman Society through Clothing Consumption 274 Abstract Purpose The purpose of this paper is to understand and conceptualize the ethno-religious identity construction process in an early modern society, sixteenth and seventeenth century Ottoman society. Design/methodology/approach Historical data sources such as visual records, travelers notes and governmental records are analyzed in this study to show the ethno-religious identity formation. Assemblage theory is utilized to conceptualize the identity construction process. Research limitation/implications This study mostly excludes male members of the society because of the uniforms that they wore for their occupations. Keywords identity, Ottoman society, early-modernity, clothing, assemblage Paper Type Research Ethnic identities are expressed, produced and reproduced through consumption. (Askegaard et al., 2005; Crockett and Wallendorf, 2004; Oswald, 1999; Peñaloza, 1994; Thompson and Tambyah, 1999). Ethnicity is a relatively new concept (Spencer, 2006), emerged after nation states became dominant form of system of government. In contemporary social theory, an ethnic group is understood as a subgroup within a broader society; its members see themselves as distinct, and they claim kinship and common history, and share symbols such as consumption objects representing the group identity (Cornell and Hartmann, 1998). However, when this concept is applied to the early modern context, religion is more significant than the claims of kinship, culture, or common history in defining ethnicity (Bartlett, 2001). The aim of the current study is to understand and conceptualize the ethno-religious identity construction process in an early modern society, sixteenth and seventeenth century Ottoman society. Ethnic identity is continuously constructed by group members and others whom they encounter. That is, internal and external definitions of ethnicity are continuously constructed (Spencer, 2006). Ethnic identities are assigned to a group and defined, accepted, resisted, redefined, rejected, or defended by the group members (Cornell and Hartmann, 1998). In other words, groups continuously make assumptions based on the categories of us and them (Spencer, 2006). Symbolism expressed through dress is a way of representing the categories of us and them and their characteristics. This chapter specifically looks at how ethnicities in early modern Ottoman society were continuously constructed through the symbolism of dress. Ottoman context is interesting in the sense that geographically it extended from Crimea to Sudan, from Bosnia to the Persian Gulf, from the Caucasus to Morocco. It was made up of many populations (Fisher, 1971) such as Hungarians, Serbians, Croatians, Bosnians, Albanians, Romanians, Bulgarians, Greeks, Turks, Arabs, Jews, Berbers, Kurds, Laz people, Armenians, and Georgians. Groups had their own shared histories, customs, belief systems, and everyday practices that differentiated them from the others and gave them an identity. Also, interactions between groups in the region resulted in similarities or hybrid formations between groups. The ways that people adorned their bodies, their dress, and their accessories were symbols representing group identities. This study utilizes European travellers notes and their drawings, costume albums, and Sultans decrees as data sources. Travellers described and interpreted and sometimes sketched clothing of different ethnicities that they have encountered. Costume albums depict the Ottoman people s clothing styles according to their social categories such as gender, age, profession, ethnicity. Travellers notes and visual data are useful for identifying the dress of different ethnic and religious groups, and how interactions with outsiders construct external definitions of an ethnicity. Sartorial codes show both the state s interpretation of original ethnic clothing and their role in shaping the ethnic identity. Also, ethnic group s practices are presented in the texts of these sartorial code
onference on Historical Analysis and Research in Marketing (CHARM), (1 - 04 Haziran 2017)

Suggestions

The role of the Young Ottomans in the transformation of mentality in the Ottoman Empire
Kaplan, Ferhat; Ertuğrul, Kürşad; Department of Political Science and Public Administration (2007)
The main topic of this study is determining the role of the Young Ottomans in mentality transformation in the Ottoman Empire from the traditional one to a modern one. Their proposals aim to change three patterns of the Ottoman state and society. The relation between state and the individual is the first issue. They tried to create an Ottoman citizenry, enhanced with freedom and political rights, from a reaya. In the second step they imagined a modern society. Their proposals, which imply a secular system, a...
The effects of tanzimat and origins of political conflict between the Armenian and Kurdish communities in the Ottoman Empire, 1839-1876
Özdemir, Fatih; Boztemur, Recep; Department of History (2006)
This thesis, depending on some Ottoman archival documents, examines the effects of the Tanzimat reforms on the Ottoman Armenians and Kurds and the origins of the conflicts amongst these communities in the Ottoman Empire. The reforms initiated in the Tanzimat era had such a transformative effect both on the Ottoman Armenian and Kurdish societies that social, political and economic structures of the two communities changed radically. Due to the effects of the Tanzimat reforms and of these structural changes, ...
Contributions of the Ottoman Empire to the construction of Modern Europe
Palabıyık, Mustafa Serdar; Yurdusev, Ahmet Nuri; Department of International Relations (2005)
This thesis aims to analyze the contributions of the Ottoman Empire to the construction of modern Europe in the early modern period. Conventional historiography generally argues that the Ottoman Empire contributed to the emergence of the modern European identity only through acting as the ءother̕ of Europe. This thesis, however, aims to show that such an analysis is not enough to understand the Ottoman impact on the European state system. Moreover, it argues that the Ottoman Empire contributed to the constr...
Investigating early modern Ottoman consumer culture in the light of Bursa probate inventories
Karababa, Eminegül (Wiley, 2012-02-01)
This study investigates the development of early modern Ottoman consumer culture.In particular, the democratization of consumption, which is a significant indicator of the development of western consumer cultures, is examined in relation to Ottoman society. Sixteenth and seventeenth century probate inventories of the town of Bursa combined with literary and official sources are used in order to identify democratization of consumption and the macro conditions shaping this development. Findings demonstrate th...
The formation of a modern city: Antalya, 1920s-1980s
Bölükbaş Dayı, Esin.; Altan, T. Elvan.; Department of History of Architecture (2019)
This dissertation examines the place of the concept of “local” in architectural historiography by focusing on the modernization process of Antalya. The analysis of the process is realized within two major contexts. On the one hand, the “peripheral” position of Antalya in canonic historiography is discussed in the frame of center-periphery relations and central-local actors; on the other hand, the developments both in the city center and its hinterlands are examined through the dualities of rural and urban, ...
Citation Formats
E. Karababa, “Assembling the Ethnic Identity in the Early Modern Ottoman Society through Clothing Consumption,” presented at the onference on Historical Analysis and Research in Marketing (CHARM), (1 - 04 Haziran 2017), Liverpool, İngiltere, 2017, Accessed: 00, 2021. [Online]. Available: http://charmassociation.org/CHARM20proceedings/CHARM20article20archive20pdf20format/Volume2018202017.pdf.