White Masters and Dark Servants in A S Byatt s Morpho Eugenia

2011-12-01
The aim of this paper is to read A. S. Byatt's novella, “Morpho Eugenia, ” from the perspective provided by the postcolonial paradigm shift regarding definitions of the “domestic.” In the light of the postcolonial contestation of conceptualizations of the domestic as an insular site exclusive of the “foreign, ” this paper is built on the premise that domestic has always been informed by what it has left outside its boundaries. I will argue that the country house, Bredely Hall, where the story is set in “Morpho Eugenia, ” is a site deeply informed by Britain's imperial position in that the domestic hierarchies in the house are entangled with colonial / global hierarchies. Therefore, explicit references to “whiteness” and “darkness” in Byatt's text in relation to the masters / mistresses and servants in Bredely Hall should be read bearing in mind this entanglement of the domestic and the global. In “Morpho Eugenia” Byatt re-defines “whiteness” and “darkness” to contest, from a global perspective, their hierarchical associations with “masters” and “servants, ” respectively. Interestingly, in “Morpho Eugenia, ” the parties associated with hierarchical categories of “whiteness” and “darkness” do not change : both masters / mistresses and servants in Bredely Hall continue to be characterized by being “white” and “dark, ” respectively. Yet, “whiteness” is emptied of its association with “moral superiority” and luminosity emerges as a quality that could obstruct clear vision whereas “darkness” is foregrounded as a quality that can contribute to visibility. Furthermore, Byatt's text problematizes the hierarchical dichotomy between “culture” / “cultivation” and “nature” / “savagery” used in connection with the European (colonizer) and the non-European (colonized). One textual strategy contributing to this is the deconstruction of domesticity embodied in the figure of the “pure” domestic woman : Eugenia Alabaster, an upperclass white woman, is portrayed as sexually-desiring and in an incestuous relationship, which she attempts to “justify” by its “naturalness.” What is more, domestic life in an English country house is represented in terms of its glaring similarities to practices carried out in “nature.” As pointed out in many critical readings of “Morpho Eugenia, ” there is an explicit analogy between society in Bredely Hall and ant communities. The mistress of the house, Lady Alabaster, for example, is likened to a queen ant, which is constantly taken care of by her “servants.” The Mother / Queen and daughter / servant relationship was a dominant analogy used over the colonial period to describe Empire. Interestingly, the analogy established in “Morpho Eugenia” between the Queen and the queen ant de-naturalizes the ideologies that served to legitimize imperialism through such notions as mutual, familial love and responsibility by foregrounding the discrepancies between the elevated ideological representations of imperialism and the colonizing and predatory practices that can be observed in wild nature, particularly among ant communities.
Hacettepe Üniversitesi Edebiyat Fakültesi Dergisi

Suggestions

Empowering Critical International Theory by Applying Action Research Methodology to its Inquiry
Kurtbağ, Ömer (Orta Doğu Teknik Üniversitesi (Ankara, Turkey), 2011-4)
This paper analyzes the influence and relevance of Gramscian and Habermasian critical international theories within the context of recent developments in the world politics that do not function in favour of these discourses’ emancipatory objectives and projections. It first looks at their emergence as alternative paradigms to the traditional conceptualizations in the discipline of IR and then compares the roots of their theoretical positions and their contribution to the analysis of international politics. ...
Construction of security cultures: a content analysis of the representations of video-surveillance in urban space in Turkish print media
Erdem, Merve Tuğba; Mücen, Barış; Department of Sociology (2016)
This thesis provides an examination of the representations of MOBESE revealed in the print media. MOBESE portrayal is evaluated from an evaluative perspective seeking to know to what end do these representations given in the print media serve; furthermore; to amplify where MOBESE surveillance stand in the process of constructing security cultures. This research is conducted in terms of print media articles downsized to MOBESE-related items in four selected newspaper articles published between the years of 2...
A Rhetorical Narratological Approach to the Treatment of Crime and Criminals in Great Expectations
NAZLİ, ELZEM; Öztabak Avcı, Elif (2018-06-01)
This paper aims to present a rhetorical narratological analysis of Charles Dickens’s Great Expectations (1861) with a specific focus on the issue of crime and the figure of the criminal. There are many studies pointing out that the novel provides the reader with an anatomy of crime and the criminal; yet, its differing treatment of the criminal characters and its possible effects over the reader have not received much narratological attention. Although Magwitch, Compeyson, and Molly can all be equally consid...
Alternative Assessment as a Motivational Tool for Young Learners
Çetin, Lynn Bethard; Gürbüz, Nurdan (2015-05-10)
This paper is conducted to highlight the motivational role of alternative assessment in the teaching/learning of English for specific purposes (ESP). The population is the students of Sudan International University (SIU). Mixed methods are adopted. The use of both thematic and statistical analysis techniques, has interpreted a significant encouraging correlation between students' final accomplishment and their achievement in in-class activities. Moreover, students...
Old game in a new world: turkey and the united states from critical perspective
Atmaca, Ayşe Ömür; Altunışık, Meliha; Department of International Relations (2011)
The main objective of this dissertation is to analyze Turkish-American relationship from critical perspective. In this study critical geopolitics is used to examine the US policymakers‘ discourses over representations of Turkey. Drawing on the theoretical literature, this dissertation took geopolitics as a deeply ideological concept and analyzed the ways in which US geopolitical discourse has shaped the Turkish-American relationship over time. The study outlined the historical evolution of the concept of th...
Citation Formats
E. Öztabak Avcı, “White Masters and Dark Servants in A S Byatt s Morpho Eugenia,” Hacettepe Üniversitesi Edebiyat Fakültesi Dergisi, pp. 201–212, 2011, Accessed: 00, 2021. [Online]. Available: https://hdl.handle.net/11511/82886.