Uses of ANT in design research: towards a critical dialogue

Date

2018-07-28

Author

İlhan, Ali Oğulcan
Kaygan, Harun
Timur Öğüt, Şebnem

Metadata

Show full item record

Item Usage Stats

45
views

0
downloads

Actor Network Theory (ANT) has been increasingly utilized in recent design literature, albeit often with a celebratory rather than critical tone.ANT indeed provides a powerful toolbox to untangle complex technoscientific assemblages, yet—like any other large framework—it is not without its shortcomings. We argue that ANT's full potential in design research can only be realized through a critical lens. To this end, we review four distinct uses of ANT terminologies in design research. These are (a) theoretical introductions for design researchers, (b) ANT analyses of design products, which typically foreground the concept of nonhuman agency, (c) ANT analyses of design processes, which often return to Callon and Law's early work, and (d) the uses of ANT concepts, and especially Latour's writings, to theoretically ground co-design practices. For each of these headings, we identify key opportunities and potential pitfalls by turning to the original theory and its well-established critiques such as the problematic status of the notion of non-human agency, problem of managerialism and disregard for existing social structures. We argue that such a critical dialogue with design research can be beneficial also for the STS field at large. Despite its increased relevance today with regard to material, organizational and social change, the agency of design is still largely missing from STS accounts. We demonstrate that current engagements with ANT in design literature provides questions and arguments that complements the STS interest in the mutual shaping of the social and the technological.

URI

https://easst2018.easst.net/wp-content/uploads/2018/07/easst2018.pdf
https://hdl.handle.net/11511/86055

Conference Name

MAKING SCIENCE, TECHNOLOGY AND SOCIETY TOGETHEREuropean Association for the Study of Science and Technology (EASST) Conference, 25 - 28 Temmuz 2018

Collections

Department of Architecture, Conference / Seminar

Suggestions

OpenMETU
Core

Alternative experimental methods for machine tool dynamics identification: A review Iglesias, Alexander; Taner Tunç, L.; Özşahin, Orkun; Franco, Oier; Munoa, Jokin; Budak, Erhan (2022-05-01) © 2022An accurate machine dynamic characterization is essential to properly describe the dynamic response of the machine or predict its cutting stability. However, it has been demonstrated that current conventional dynamic characterization methods are often not reliable enough to be used as valuable input data. For this reason, alternative experimental methods to conventional dynamic characterization methods have been developed to increase the quality of the obtained data. These methods consider additional ...
Design for social innovation for rural development in Turkey: actor relationships in the smart village project Vatan, Duygu; Kaygan, Harun; Department of Industrial Design (2019) Today, the availability of the collaborative networks enables the collaboration of many actors that embraces the creation of new opportunities inside the problems that were otherwise assumed to be unsolvable over the years. The innovative way of looking at the problems to seek potential ideas is also known as social innovation. Design as a discipline takes part in social innovation practices by increasing the design capabilities of collaborative networks. In the area of social innovation, rural development ...
WEIGHTED MATRIX ORDERING AND PARALLEL BANDED PRECONDITIONERS FOR ITERATIVE LINEAR SYSTEM SOLVERS Manguoğlu, Murat; Sameh, Ahmed H.; Grama, Ananth (Society for Industrial & Applied Mathematics (SIAM), 2010-01-01) The emergence of multicore architectures and highly scalable platforms motivates the development of novel algorithms and techniques that emphasize concurrency and are tolerant of deep memory hierarchies, as opposed to minimizing raw FLOP counts. While direct solvers are reliable, they are often slow and memory-intensive for large problems. Iterative solvers, on the other hand, are more efficient but, in the absence of robust preconditioners, lack reliability. While preconditioners based on incomplete factor...
Communication of distributed discrete-event supervisors on a switched network Schmidt, Klaus Verner; Schmidt, Şenan Ece (2008-05-30) In order to tackle the controller synthesis problem for large-scale discrete-event systems, recent approaches suggest the design of interacting modular or decentralized supervisors. In these works, information exchange between the supervisors is either required implicitly by the synchronization of shared events or explicitly by the communication of events or symbols. However, it is not discussed how the communication can be realized if the supervisors are implemented in distributed controller devices that a...
Design of a variable five-axes adjustable configuration robot manipulator YUCEL, AS; Ersak, Aydın (1994-04-14) A robot manipulator design is presented in this paper supplying a few kinematical configurations in a single structure which is in the mean time, reconfigurable for given tasks and hence making the level of flexibility and adaptability much higher for changing working environments

Citation Formats

A. O. İlhan, H. Kaygan, and Ş. Timur Öğüt, “Uses of ANT in design research: towards a critical dialogue,” presented at the MAKING SCIENCE, TECHNOLOGY AND SOCIETY TOGETHEREuropean Association for the Study of Science and Technology (EASST) Conference, 25 - 28 Temmuz 2018, Liverpool, İngiltere, 2018, Accessed: 00, 2021. [Online]. Available: https://easst2018.easst.net/wp-content/uploads/2018/07/easst2018.pdf.