Prehistoric cognition by description: a Russellian approach to the upper paleolithic

Date

2007-06-01

Author

Bolender, John

Metadata

Show full item record

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.

Item Usage Stats

41
views

0
downloads

A cultural change occurred roughly 40,000 years ago. For the first time, there was evidence of belief in unseen agents and an afterlife. Before this time, humans did not show widespread evidence of being able to think about objects, persons, and other agents that they had not been in close contact with. I argue that one can explain this transition by appealing to a population increase resulting in greater exoteric (inter-group) communication. The increase in exoteric communication triggered the actualization of a dormant potential for greater syntactic computational power; specifically it triggered syntactic movement. Syntactic movement, in turn, made possible variable binding, which crucially figures into cognition by description, a naturalistic analogue of Russell's knowledge by description. Cognition by description made possible the ability to conceive of things one had never experienced, such as mythological beings, places only visited by the dead, and so forth. The Amazonian Pirah (a) over tilde provide some corroboration for this hypothesis, since they exhibit the combination of traits here attributed to Middle Paleolithic individuals, namely exclusively esoteric (intra-group) communication, evident lack of syntactic movement, and a limitation to knowledge (cognition) by acquaintance.

Subject Keywords

Philosophy, History and Philosophy of Science, General Agricultural and Biological Sciences

URI

https://hdl.handle.net/11511/63597

Journal

BIOLOGY & PHILOSOPHY

DOI

https://doi.org/10.1007/s10539-006-9058-2

Collections

Department of Philosophy, Article

Suggestions

OpenMETU
Core

Archaeogenetics of Late Iron Age Cemialo Srt, Batman: Investigating maternal genetic continuity in north Mesopotamia since the Neolithic Yaka, Reyhan; Birand, Aysegul; Yilmaz, Yasemin; Caner, Ceren; Acan, Sinan Can; Gunduzalp, Sidar; Parvizi, Poorya; Ozdogan, Asli Erim; Togan, Inci; Somel, Mehmet (2018-05-01) ObjectivesNorth Mesopotamia has witnessed dramatic social change during the Holocene, but the impact of these events on its demographic history is poorly understood. Here, we study this question by analysing genetic data from the recently excavated Late Iron Age settlement of Cemialo Srt in Batman, southeast Turkey. Archaeological and radiocarbon evidence indicate that the site was inhabited during the second and first millennia BCE. Cemialo Srt reveals nomadic items of the Early Iron Age, as well as items ...
Upgrading Participation Through Computational Thinking in Architecture Albayrak de Brito Colaço, Canan; Mennan, Zeynep (Springer, 2021) Advances in socio-technologies have contributed to a cultural shift towards active participation in society and eventually gave rise to a participatory culture. In the design context, the distinction between pseudo- and genuine participation comes into prominence. This paper traces the intersection and convergence of design participation and design computation in architecture. The starting point of this research is an inquiry into the thread of user participation in architectural design grounded in the desi...
Genomic and Strontium Isotope Variation Reveal Immigration Patterns in a Viking Age Town Krzewinska, Maja; Kjellstrom, Anna; Guenther, Torsten; Hedenstierna-Jonson, Charlotte; Zachrisson, Torun; Omrak, Ayca; Yaka, Reyhan; Kilinc, Gulsah Merve; Somel, Mehmet; Sobrado, Veronica; Evans, Jane; Knipper, Conine; Jakobsson, Mattias; Stora, Jan; Gotherstrom, Anders (Elsevier BV, 2018-09-10) The impact of human mobility on the northern European urban populations during the Viking and Early Middle Ages and its repercussions in Scandinavia itself are still largely unexplored. Our study of the demographics in the final phase of the Viking era is the first comprehensive multidisciplinary investigation that includes genetics, isotopes, archaeology, and osteology on a larger scale. This early Christian dataset is particularly important as the earlier common pagan burial tradition during the Iron Age ...
Archaeogenomic analysis of genetic and cultural interactions in Neolithic Anatolian societies (NEOGENE) Somel, Mehmet; Atakuman, Çiğdem; Sürer, Elif(2023) The Neolithic Transition in the Near East (c.10,000-6,000 BC) was a period of singular sociocultural change, when societies adopted sedentary life and agriculture for the first time in human history. This project will jointly use genomic and quantitative cultural data to explore Transition societies’ organisation, interactions, and their social and demographic evolution in time. (1) We will start by dissecting social structures within Neolithic communities in Anatolia, studying the role of kinship, postmari...
KNOWLEDGE IN THE HISTORICAL PERSPECTIVE OF COMING-TO-BE AND PASSING-AWAY Yıldırım, Erdoğan (2018-06-01) Since the last decades of the 20th century the meaning and content of knowledge has dramatically changed. This necessitates adopting a historical perspective in approaching the questions of knowledge. But so far all the efforts of putting knowledge in a historical perspective since Hegel's historization of Spirit either suffer from the limitations of the presupposition of the One (Spirit or Being) or fail to ground the historicity of knowledge on the history of coming-to-be and passing-away. Moving from Hei...

Citation Formats

J. Bolender, “Prehistoric cognition by description: a Russellian approach to the upper paleolithic,” BIOLOGY & PHILOSOPHY, pp. 383–399, 2007, Accessed: 00, 2020. [Online]. Available: https://hdl.handle.net/11511/63597.