An Analysis of Efficiency and Profitability in the Turkish Banking System

Since the mid-1990s, a number of studies have been conducted that analyze the profitability and cost structure of Turkish banks by using different research methodologies. Due to the advances in modeling techniques during the 2000s, it is now possible to address the same issues in a more detailed and rigorous manner. The main objective of this study is to conduct an analysis of profitability and cost in the Turkish banking sector by using data between 1960 and 2009. The particular data set that is to be used in this study makes it possible to examine the issue of profitability and cost over a much longer time period compared to previous studies. The first step in the study involves the estimation of profit and cost efficiencies by using the stochastic frontier approach. This part of the study presents the changes that took place in the profit and cost efficiency of Turkish banks since the 1960s. The results in this part of the study also make it possible to make efficiency comparisons between banks with different institutional characteristics, such as state-owned versus private banks and Turkish versus foreign banks. The stochastic frontier approach creates an X-efficiency score for each sample bank analyzed. This score is calculated by comparing a specific bank’s profit or cost performance against the “best practice” performance determined based on the performances of all banks in the sample. The stochastic frontier approach also generates an “inefficiency” score for each bank based on the same “best practice” guideline. So, for instance, while the “cost efficiency” score of a bank measures how closely that bank performs with respect to the best cost practice in the sample, the “cost inefficiency” score measures the deviation of a bank’s cost performance from the best practice guideline. The same efficiency and inefficiency scores can also be calculated for the profit performance of a sample bank. In the second part of the study, a profitability model is estimated for the Turkish banks and traditional industrial organization hypotheses, such as “collusion” versus “efficiency” are tested. One of the independent variables in this profitability model is the efficiency scores that are calculated in the first part of the study. The previous studies on the Turkish banking sector that ask a similar research question and adopt a similar methodology mostly focus on the cost inefficiency of banks in the market. For instance, the study by Oral and Yolalan (1990) uses the non-parametric data envelopment method and presents results based on a case study conducted about a one sample bank. Later, Zaim (1995) uses the same method and concludes that the Turkish commercial banks benefited from the financial liberalization environment during the 1981-1990 period and experienced increases in their technical and distributional efficiencies. Contrary to these findings, Denizer et al. (2000) utilize a similar methodology and present evidence that there has been a decline in the efficiency of Turkish banks following the market changes that came as a result of financial liberalization. One of the first studies on Turkish banks that use a stochastic cost estimation approach is by Altunbaş and Molyneux (1994). In this study, the analysis results suggest that there is no difference between state-owned and private commercial banks in terms of their cost inefficiencies. Denizer’s 1997 study, on the other hand, shows that, as of 1990, Turkish banks are at least five times more profitable when compared to their peers in the other OECD countries. In a more recent study, Işık and Hassan (2002) employ both parametric and non-parametric methods and analyze the Turkish banks in terms of their distributional, technical, cost and profit efficiencies. Their results imply that the main source of inefficiency for Turkish banks during the 1988-1996 period is not the distributional but technical inefficiency. The succeeding studies by Kasman (2002 and 2005) provide evidence that the Turkish banks enjoy scale efficiencies. Interestingly, the same studies show that although during the 1981-1990 period most banks have experienced an improvement in their efficiencies, there has been no improvement in the bank efficiencies during the following 10 years. When the literature on the Turkish banks is reviewed, it is seen that most studies analyze either the cost or the profit efficiency of banks. However, these two types of efficiencies are closely related to each other and if they are analyzed together, a more complete picture can be constructed regarding the efficiency of Turkish banks. Moreover, the previous studies mostly use a sample period that goes back as far as the 1980s. The current study proposes to use data that cover approximately five decades and go back as far as the 1960s.
ASSA Middle East Economic Association 2011 Meeting (7 - 09 Ocak 2011)


An analysis of stock splitz in the İstanbul Stock Exchange
Yılmaz, Işıl Sevilay; Rhoades, Seza Danışoğlu; Department of Business Administration (2003)
The primary purpose of this study is to test the validity of the trading range hypothesis as a basis for stock split decisions of Turkish companies. In the first part, the liquidity effects of stock splits on Turkish stocks are examined. Second, the optimal trading ranges for different-sized firms and firms with different investor bases are determined. Finally, the main empirical question of the study is analyzed by testing whether or not Turkish firms whose share prices rise above their optimal trading ran...
An Empirical Analysis of the Bank Lending Channel in Turkey
Ozsuca, Ekin Ayse; Akbostancı Özkazanç, Elif (2013-07-01)
The purpose of this paper is to empirically analyze the role of the banking sector in monetary policy transmission in Turkey covering the period 1988-2009. By exploiting dynamic panel data modeling approaches, the heterogeneity in banks' lending response to changes in policy interest rates is analyzed. Given the changes in the policy stance and developments in the financial system following the 2000-01 crisis, the analysis is further conducted for the two sub-periods, 1988-2001 and 2002-2009, to examine whe...
An Empirical Analysis of the Risk-Taking Channel of Monetary Policy in Turkey
Ozsuca, Ekin Ayse; Akbostancı Özkazanç, Elif (2016-03-01)
This article investigates the bank-specific characteristics of risk-taking behavior of the Turkish banking sector as well as the existence of risk-taking channel of monetary policy in Turkey. Using bank-level quarterly data over the period 2002-2012 a dynamic panel model is estimated. We find evidence that low short-term interest rates reduce the risk of outstanding loans; however short-term interest rates below a theoretical benchmark increase risk-taking of banks. This result holds for macroeconomic contr...
An Empirical model of the international cost of equity
Uzunkaya, Mehmet; Küçükkaya, Halit Engin; Department of Business Administration (2015)
The aim of the study is to propose an empirical model of the international cost of equity by investigating and analyzing the long-run relation between disaggregated country risk ratings and country stock market index returns for a large panel of countries. The study tests the hypothesis that, given the available theoretical and empirical evidence, country risk ratings and country stock market index returns should move together in the long-run and there should be a long-run equilibrium between them; thus cou...
Analysis of Turkish stock market with Markov regime switching volatility models
Karadağ, Mehmet Ali; Danışoğlu, Seza; Department of Financial Mathematics (2008)
In this study, both uni-regime GARCH and Markov Regime Switching GARCH (SW-GARCH) models are examined to analyze Turkish Stock Market volatility. We investigate various models to find out whether SW-GARCH models are an improvement on the uni-regime GARCH models in terms of modelling and forecasting Turkish Stock Market volatility. As well as using seven statistical loss functions, we apply Superior Predictive Ability (SPA) test of Hansen (2005) and Reality Check test (RC) of White (2000) to compare forecast...
Citation Formats
S. Danışoğlu, “An Analysis of Efficiency and Profitability in the Turkish Banking System,” presented at the ASSA Middle East Economic Association 2011 Meeting (7 - 09 Ocak 2011), Denver, Amerika Birleşik Devletleri, 2011, Accessed: 00, 2021. [Online]. Available: