A new systematic and flexible method for developing hierarchical decision-making models

The common practice in multilevel decision-making (DM) systems is to achieve the final decision by going through a finite number of DM levels. In this study, a new multilevel DM model is proposed. This model is called the hierarchical DM (HDM) model and it is supposed to provide a flexible way of interaction and information flow between the consecutive levels that allows policy changes in DM procedures if necessary. In the model, in the early levels, there are primary agents that perform DM tasks. As the levels increase, the information associated with these agents is combined through suitable processes and agents with higher complexity are formed to carry out the DM tasks more elegantly. The HDM model is applied to the case study 'Fault degree classification in a 4-tank water circulation system'. For this case study, the processes that connect the lower levels to the higher levels are agent development processes where a special decision fusion technique is its integral part. This decision fusion technique combines the previous level's decisions and their performance indicator suitably to contribute to the improvement of new agents in higher levels. Additionally, the proposed agent development process provides flexibility both in the training and validation phases, and less computational effort is required in the training phase compared to a single-agent development simulation carried out for the same DM task under similar circumstances. Hence, the HDM model puts forward an enhanced performance compared to a single agent with a more sophisticated structure. Finally, model validation and efficiency in the presence of noise are also simulated. The adaptability of the agent development process due to the flexible structure of the model also accounts for improved performance, as seen in the results.


Design and improvement of multi-level decision-making models
Beldek, Ulaş; Leblebicioğlu, Mehmet Kemal; Department of Electrical and Electronics Engineering (2009)
In multi-level decision making (DM) approaches, the final decision is reached by going through a finite number of DM levels. Usually, in each level, a raw decision is produced first and then a suitable decision fusion technique is employed to merge the lower level decisions with the raw decision in the construction of the final decision of the present level. The basic difficulty in these approaches is the determination of how the consecutive levels should interact with each other. In this thesis, two differ...
An Interactive partitioning approach for multiobjective decision making under a general monotone utility function
Karasakal, Esra (2013-09-01)
We develop an interactive partitioning approach for solving the multiobjective decision making problem of a decision maker (DM) who has an implicit general monotone utility function. The approach reduces feasible solution space using the DM's preferences. Hypothetical solutions called partition ideals (PIs) that dominate portions of the efficient frontier are generated and those that are inferior to a feasible solution are used to eliminate the dominated regions. We investigate the issues in representation ...
A Probabilistic Approach for Indirect Elicitation of the Preferences of a Decision Maker
Yet, Barbaros (2018-05-28)
Eliciting the preferences of a Decision Maker (DM) is a challenging task in multi criteria-decision making problems. DM preferences can be represented in the form of weights for criteria. Direct elicitation methods can be cognitively difficult for the DM especially when a large number of weights with close values are available. Indirect methods are beneficial in this regard as they use decision alternatives rather than weights for elicitation. However, the accuracy of these approaches can vary depending on ...
A parallel between regret theory and outranking methods for multicriteria decision making under imprecise information
Ozerol, Gul; Karasakal, Esra (Springer Science and Business Media LLC, 2008-08-01)
Incorporation of the behavioral issues of the decision maker (DM) is among the aspects that each Multicriteria Decision Making (MCDM) method implicitly or explicitly takes into account. As postulated by regret theory, the feelings of regret and rejoice are among the behavioral issues associated with the entire decision making process. Within the context of MCDM, the DM may feel regret, when the chosen alternative is compared with another one having at least one better criterion value. PROMETHEE II is a wide...
A genetic algorithm for biobjective multi-skill project scheduling problem with hierarchical levels of skills
Gürbüz, Elif; Sepil, Canan; Department of Industrial Engineering (2010)
In Multi-Skill Project Scheduling Problem (MSPSP) with hierarchical levels of skills, there are more than one skill type and for each skill type there are levels corresponding to proficiencies in that skill. The purpose of the problem is to minimize or maximize an objective by assigning resources with different kinds of skills and skill levels to the project activities according to the activity requirements while satisfying the other problem dependent constraints. Although single-objective case of the probl...
Citation Formats
U. BELDEK and M. K. Leblebicioğlu, “A new systematic and flexible method for developing hierarchical decision-making models,” TURKISH JOURNAL OF ELECTRICAL ENGINEERING AND COMPUTER SCIENCES, pp. 279–297, 2015, Accessed: 00, 2020. [Online]. Available: https://hdl.handle.net/11511/34763.