Different goals, different criteria: Perspectives of jury members in industrial design competitions in Turkey

Download
index.pdf
2018-11-01
Dilek, İrem
Kaygan, Pınar
Show full item record
Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.
224
views
94
downloads
In the last decade, popularity of industrial design competitions organized in Turkey has increased significantly. The increase in their number, and the educa-tional scholarships offered to the winner design students and young designers as a prize, led industrial design competitions to become prominent among design promotion activities in Turkey. Industrial design competitions also carry impor-tance in terms of bringing professionals from different fields of expertise togeth-er in their evaluation juries. Considering the increased importance of industrial design competitions, this article explores the perspectives of jury members from various fields of expertise in jury evaluations of industrial design competitions in Turkey. The fieldwork consists of observations in the evaluation juries of five design competitions and interviews with 15 jury members from different fields of expertise. Based on the findings obtained from the fieldwork, the study shows that the relationship between jury members are patterned by their different, in some situations even conflicting, perspectives on both the goals to be achieved with these competitions, and the priorities that shape their evaluation criteria.
Design competitions, Design juries, Design evaluation, Collaboration in design
https://hdl.handle.net/11511/42978
ITU AZ Journal of Faculty of Architecture
Department of Industrial Design, Article

Suggestions

Exploring the perspectives of jury members from different fields of expertise in industrial design competitions
Dilek, İrem; Kaygan, Pınar (2018-03-07)
In the last decade, the number of industrial design competitions in Turkey addressing industrial design students and young designers has increased significantly. The increase in the number, and the educational scholarships that are provided to the design students and young professionals,brought industrial design competitions into prominence among design promotion activities. In addition, design promotion activities that are organized with the aim of increasing visibility of industrial design profession in T...
Exploring the perspectives of jury members from different fields of expertise in industrial design competitions
Dilek, İrem; Kaygan, Pınar; Department of Industrial Design (2017)
In the last decade, the number of industrial design competitions in Turkey addressing industrial design students and young designers has increased significantly. The increase in the number, and the educational scholarships that are provided to the design students and young professionals, brought industrial design competitions into prominence among design promotion activities. In addition, design promotion activities that are organized with the aim of increasing visibility of industrial design profession in ...
Strategies for an effective university-industry collaboration in industrial design education : a case study of graduation projects
Baysal, Ömer Orhun; Hasdoğan, Gülay Fatma; Department of Industrial Design (2007)
Industrially supported projects, which are an important part of industrial design education, have been carried on with an increasing pace in universities in Turkey for a long time. This thesis develops strategies to improve collaborative projects with industry in industrial design education, by examining how collaboration member benefit from each other’s and which problems do they encounter with collaboration; and to find out what the needs and expectations of all members are through a case study of graduat...
The State Of Design: Towards An Assessment Of The Development Of Industrial Design In Turkey
Er, Alpay (Middle East Technical University, Faculty of Architecture, 1993)
It has been more than twenty-five years since the concept of industrial design was first introduced into the Turkish context. During this period, industrial design was primarily taught as an off-shoot course from the existing architecture and interior design programmes, then separate, fully fledged industrial design departments were founded at some universities. Today these departments have their own postgraduate programmes and the number of graduate industrial designers İn Turkey is appoaching towards one ...
Urban design competitions as discursive practice in Turkey: 1980-2009
Çimen, Devrim; Altaban, Özcan; Department of City and Regional Planning (2010)
It is being observed that there has been an increase in the number of urban design competitions in the last decade in Turkey. Competitions are crucial methods of enriching theoretical and practical frameworks of the disciplines by creating a platform for discursive attitudes. That reveals the importance of the notion of competition as a process covering from the decision for organizing a competition to the decision of the jury for the winner and also post-competition events such as colloquium. Due to these ...
Citation Formats
İ. Dilek and P. Kaygan, “Different goals, different criteria: Perspectives of jury members in industrial design competitions in Turkey,” ITU AZ Journal of Faculty of Architecture, pp. 13–27, 2018, Accessed: 00, 2020. [Online]. Available: https://hdl.handle.net/11511/42978.
METU IIS - Integrated Information Service open@metu.edu.tr