Decision Support Tool for the Quantification of Fault Rates in Construction Fall Accidents

After the occurrence of construction work accidents, expert witness reports received with the aim of quantifying fault rates among parties, play an important role on the court's final decision. However, conflicting fault rates assigned by different expert witness groups for the similar cases are quite common practice, leading to unnecessary and iterative objections raised by the related parties until a consensus among reports has been reached. This unfavourable situation mainly originates due to subjectivity of expert judgments and unavailability of objective information about the causes of accidents. This paper proposes a decision support tool (DST) for the quantification of fault rates in construction fall accidents. The aim of developed DST is to eliminate the contradiction between fault rates assigned by different experts and decrease subjectivity prevailing in expert witness reports. For this purpose, 84 inspection reports prepared by the inspectors of Ministry of Labour and Social Security have been investigated and root causes of construction fall accidents in Turkey have been identified. By using this information, an evaluation form has been designed and submitted to experts. Experts are requested to evaluate the importance of the factors that govern fall accidents and determine fault rates under different scenarios. Based on expert judgments, a rule-based DST has been developed which may enable a decision maker to arrive at an objective conclusion about fault rates of parties involved in construction fall accidents. The proposed DST has been tested with the most frequently occurring cases in Turkey and satisfactory results have been reached.
ARCOM 2005, 7 - 09 Eylül 2005


Using the balanced scorecard as a safety management tool in construction companies : a qfd approach
Şimşek, Burak; Gündüz, Murat; Department of Civil Engineering (2006)
The aim of this thesis is to propose a safety management framework for construction companies. A literature review was performed to identify significant factors that would improve safety performance. Two management tools are used within the scope of this study: the balanced scorecard and quality function deployment (QFD). Strategic goals are established for each perspective of the balanced scorecard: financial and cultural, employee, process and learning and growth. Afterwards, a questionnaire was prepared ...
Case-based reasoning model for the management of design related changes in design-build construction projects
Özgüneş, Aydın; Tanyer, Ali Murat; Department of Building Science in Architecture (2016)
Project changes constitutes to an important problem in construction projects which are unavoidable and may appear at any stage of the construction. Most of the time, project changes cause conflicts between the parties and end with change orders or claims that lead to time and money losses. Moreover, design related changes, which can be defined as variations related with the design process of the construction project, are referred as one of the most frequently seen project change types in construction projec...
Identifying Bridge Rehabilitation Needs Using an Analytical Method Developed for Interpretation of Visual Inspection Data
AVŞAR, ÖZGÜR; Marianos, Ward Nicholas; Caner, Alp (American Society of Civil Engineers (ASCE), 2012-05-01)
Bridge management systems generally rely on the accurate interpretation of findings determined from planned bridge inspections. Bridge inspections typically focus on the overall condition of the bridge and the condition of its components. During a recent bridge inspection with multinational team, it was observed that the overall grade of a bridge could be significantly high, even though it contains one or more failing subcomponents. Over the years, it has been observed that failure of a deteriorated compone...
Mammadov, Ahmad; Tokdemir, Onur Behzat; Department of Civil Engineering (2021-12-2)
The main drive upon which this study relies is to introduce a prescriptive accident prevention model to avoid work related accidents by predicting outcomes of work-related accidents in pipeline construction with using machine learning algorithms. In depth study on construction accidents is crucial due to construction being one of the most hazardous industry and being temporary in nature. To come up with a prescriptive accident prevention model, all incident reports from a pipeline project were analysed and ...
Hybrid particle swarm optimization algorithm for obtaining pareto front of discrete time cost trade-off problem
Aminbakhsh, Saman; Sönmez, Rifat; Department of Civil Engineering (2013)
In pursuance of decreasing costs, both the client and the contractor would strive to speed up the construction project. However, accelerating the project schedule will impose additional cost and might be profitable up to a certain limit. Paramount for construction management, analyses of this trade-off between duration and cost is hailed as the time-cost trade-off (TCT) optimization. Inadequacies of existing commercial software packages for such analyses tied with eminence of discretization, motivated devel...
Citation Formats
M. T. Birgönül and İ. Dikmen Toker, “Decision Support Tool for the Quantification of Fault Rates in Construction Fall Accidents,” presented at the ARCOM 2005, 7 - 09 Eylül 2005, 2005, Accessed: 00, 2021. [Online]. Available: