Review of THE BOLSHEVIKS AND BRITAIN DURING THE RUSSIAN REVOLUTION AND CIVIL WAR, 1917-24

Date

2023-01-01

Author

Dietrich, Richard

Metadata

Show full item record

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.

Item Usage Stats

215
views

0
downloads

This book examines Soviet-British relations during the Revolution and Civil War, and is comprised of 10 chapters which deal with various significant issues in Soviet-British relations. The introduction outlines the topics that the book will discuss, among them: the effect of the revolutionary events of 1917 on the military alliance between Petrograd and London, the origins of dramatic transition from friendly cooperation to outright animosity in later years, the reasons for the failure of the British armed intervention, and the reasons that the British government eventually recognized the Bolshevik dictatorship. The author bases his arguments on information retrieved from diplomatic documents, declassified intelligence reports, parliamentary debates and private papers in Russian and British archives. The book begins with a discussion of the 1907 Anglo-Russian convention on the delimitation of spheres of influence in Asia, the Bolsheviks’ peace negotiations with the Quadruple Alliance, Britain’s desire to keep Russia in the First World War, Provisional government assurance that Russia would continue fighting, and British efforts to forge a new policy towards Russia after the Bolsheviks came to power. The second and third chapters are dedicated to the issues of British military intervention in Russia and Allied plotting to overthrow the Bolsheviks. The use of archival sources, both western and Russian, in these two chapters is particularly valuable in clarifying the complex events and developments connected with these two subjects. The revival of Great-Game type rivalry between Soviet Russia and Great Britain, primarily in the Caucasus and northeastern Iran is the subject of the next chapter. British anti-Bolshevik machinations at the 1919 Paris peace conference, disputes related to the Baltic and Poland, and disagreements between Britain and the Soviet Union at international conferences held in 1922-24 are discussed in the following three chapters. The tenth and final chapter discusses Britain’s recognition of the Soviet Union and the impact of this official recognition. A short epilogue conclude the book. This work is a valuable study of the relations between two major powers, one an established empire and the other a newly formed state struggling to secure its hold on power internally and seeking to establish its presence externally. The use of Russian archival sources makes it especially useful for researchers who either lack either access to these materials, or the language skills to read the original documents. The only real criticism to be made is that the small, but numerous grammar errors that appear throughout the text indicate that the book was not written by a native English speaker. Future editions could be improved with more careful editing. Nevertheless, The Bolsheviks and Britain during the Russian Revolution and Civil War, 1917-24 is highly recommended for anyone interested in the Soviet Union’s early relations with the west, and Britain in particular.

URI

https://www.ijors.net/issue12_1_2023/issue12_1.php
https://hdl.handle.net/11511/102456

Journal

International Journal of Russian Studies

Collections

Department of History, Article

Suggestions

OpenMETU
Core

Review of Putin's War in Syria: Russian foreign policy and the price of America's absence Dietrich, Richard (2022-07-01) This book is a study of Russia’s role in the Syrian civil war as well as an examination of the place of the Middle East in Russia’s overall foreign policy. In the course of examining these issues, the book documents how Russian intervention changed the course of the Syrian civil war and the impact it has had in Syria in the absence of a strong American presence to counter Russia. In addition, it looks at how the Russian military has applied lessons learned in the Soviet war in Afghanistan in its operations ...
Review of RUSSIA RISING: PUTIN’S FOREIGN POLICY IN THE MIDDLE EAST AND NORTH AFRICA Dietrich, Richard (2022-07-01) Russia Rising is a collection of articles by fourteen authors on different aspects of Russian foreign policy in the Middle East and North Africa (MENA). It is organized in four sections: the introduction and then Parts I-III. While the majority of articles discuss topics related to current Russian foreign policy in the Middle East, the two articles that make up Part I: “Russia in the Middle East: From the Soviet Union to Putin” provide a historical overview of Russian involvement and policy in the MENA regi...
Modern Theatre in Russia Tradition Building and Transmission Processes (Book Review) Pamir Dietrich, Ayşe (2022-01-01) This book is about the history of Russian theater tradition and practice, and consists of six chapters. In the first chapter, Introduction, the writer gives a brief sketch of Russian theater tradition in the 19th century and how this tradition was transmitted to the 20th century, and explains what cultural transmission means. Aquilina introduces his methods and the outlines of his study. He states that he will examine Stanislavsky, Meyerhold, Smyshlaev, Kerzhentsev and the Proletkultists to analyze the trad...
Stalinism at War, 1937-49, the Soviet Union in World War II (Book Reivew) Pamir Dietrich, Ayşe (2023-01-01) This book, organized in nine chapters, is about World War II and Stalin’s policies. Chapter 1 discusses whether the Soviet Union was ready to confront the assault of a modern, industrialized army; mass warfare; the question of how important the different stages of World War II were in the lives of ordinary citizens, whether Stalin’s totalitarian state adequately prepared the country for World War II; the deportations; and the Great Purges of 1937–1938 that eliminated many of the most capable and sophistica...
The Limits of realist conception of security: examing the views of Campbell and Waever / Seven, Elfesiya; Deveci, Cem; Department of Political Science and Public Administration (2015) This thesis examines two different and contemporary theories which criticize the centrality of “security issues” in the re-establishment of the post-Cold War international order as one of the fundamental principles of the realist school. The views of David Campbell and Copenhagen Securitization School focus on the role of “the security issue” in the determination of the Cold War policies, and ask whether this security care lost its effects or not in the process of determination of foreign policies. Both of ...

Citation Formats

R. Dietrich, “Review of THE BOLSHEVIKS AND BRITAIN DURING THE RUSSIAN REVOLUTION AND CIVIL WAR, 1917-24,” International Journal of Russian Studies, vol. 12, no. 1, pp. 73–74, 2023, Accessed: 00, 2023. [Online]. Available: https://www.ijors.net/issue12_1_2023/issue12_1.php.