Consequentialist versus deontological ethical dispositions of Turkish banking sector managers : comparing a public and a private bank

Karaoğlu (Kırbaşlı), Dilşad
The aim of this thesis is to see in a descriptive manner, whether there is a difference in the ethical disposition of public and private banking sector managers in Türkiye, according to two ethical theories: consequentialism (based on the consequences of the action) and deontologism (based on principles). The study analyzes the preferences of the managers both in the way of thinking and acting to see whether people act consistently with their way of thinking. The degree of validity of consequentialism/deontologism dichotomy and the daptability of these western theories to the Turkish context are also analyzed. Two hypotheses have been formed: private sector managers, young and male managers tend to be more consequentialist whereas public sector managers, elderly and female managers have a tendency toward deontologism. These hypotheses were tested on 58 managers working in the headquarters in Ankara (34 in the public, 24 in the private sector) through vignettes and interviews as data collection methods. As a result of the ANOVA analysis and content analysis performed on the data, private sector managers and male managers seem to be more consequentialist and they are consistent in their way of thinking and acting, but public sector managers, elderly and female managers do not have a tendency toward deontologism. The semistructured interviews showed that the level of awareness of the term ethics was low. Due to radical changes in social values in the last two decades in Türkiye, contradictory values co-exist. The suitability of the consequentialist/deontological dichotomy may be questioned for Türkiye.


The practice of journalism in Turkey as to the views of Turkish parliament journalists
Bayar (Ekren), Duygu; Kaya, Ahmet Raşit; Department of Political Science and Public Administration (2006)
Journalists’ commitment to an objective, impartial, balanced way of reporting and their respect for ethical norms are considered a vital prerequisite for democracy to be carried out. The general purpose of this thesis is to reveal whether established journalistic practices in Turkey are shaped through commonly acknowledged professional principles in a way that is compatible with democratic expectancies. In order to achieve this goal, a group of journalists were interviewed in the summer of 2003 who worked a...
An analysis of of the Romanian public affairs management in the accession process
Septar, Leila; Türkeş, Mustafa; Department of European Studies (2006)
This thesis analyzes the lobbying process taking place within the comitology committees of the European Union responsible with the the implementation process of the employment policy. It presents a critical view on the EU decision-making and implementation processes by studing the way these could be influenced by using public affairs management instruments. The European Union accession negotiations of the Romanian case is taken as a case study to exemplify on the professionalism of a lobby group in formatio...
Political modernization and informal politics in Uzbekistan
Şır, Aslan Yavuz; Yıldırım, Erdoğan; Department of Eurasian Studies (2007)
The objective of this thesis is to examine the political modernization experience of the Uzbeks. In order to do that, first, this dissertation critically analyze the modernization theory, and second, the identity- and socio-political transformation of Uzbeks in the pre-modern and modern eras. The political modernization of Uzbeks and its relation with the peculiar social-political structures, as well as the impact of Tsarist and the Soviet rule on those structures are examined. Moreover, the dissertation an...
An examination of Turkish insurance industry in light of information asymmetry
Aygen, Mehmet Fırat; Oran, Adil; Department of Business Administration (2005)
The objective of this study is to understand information asymmetry concept with its causes and consequences and its effects on insurance business especially in Turkey. Perfect markets, moral hazard, adverse selection, market signaling, and guarantee concepts are important to have a better examination of asymmetric information as a whole and there are many examples of these concepts faced in insurance sector. In order to have a closer look to Turkish insurance business, some insurance companies are chosen ra...
The influence of job satisfaction, organizational commitment, and perceptions of organizational justice on organizational citizenship behavior in Turkish education sector
Pirali, Jülide; Aşcıgil, F. Pınar; Department of Business Administration (2007)
This thesis examines the influence of job satisfaction, organizational commitment, and perceptions of organizational justice on organizational citizenship behaviors (OCBs) of private primary school teachers in Ankara. Previous research has shown that these three variables are significantly correlated with OCB. The effect of these three variables on OCB are studied collectively in the education sector. The study of the effects of the three variables on OCB are rare in Turkey, especially in the education sect...
Citation Formats
D. Karaoğlu (Kırbaşlı), “Consequentialist versus deontological ethical dispositions of Turkish banking sector managers : comparing a public and a private bank,” M.S. - Master of Science, Middle East Technical University, 2006.