A Dea based sorting approach for industrial R&D projects

Aker, Pınar
In this study, multicriteria sorting methods based on Data Envelopment Analysis (DEA) are developed to evaluate industrial Research and Development (R&D) projects proposed to Technology and Innovation Grant Programmes Directorate (TEYDEB) of the Scientific and Technological Research Council of Turkey (TÜBİTAK). Even though DEA is used extensively as a multicriteria decision making (MCDM) tool for ranking; to our knowledge, this study is the first attempt utilizing DEA for sorting purpose. A five level R&D project selection criteria hierarchy and an assisting point allocation guide with a scale of ten-points are derived to measure and quantify the performance of the proposals. The interval pairwise comparison matrices determined from the judgments of TEYDEB managers are used to obtain weight intervals from Analytic Hierarchy Process (AHP) model. These weights are employed as assurance region constraints. Motivated from the fact that derived criteria constitute inputs and outputs of R&D projects; DEA determining efficiencies based on inputs and outputs is utilized for sorting. Based on this approach, two threshold estimation models, PM1 and PM2, and five assignment models, APM1, APM2, APM3, APM4 and APM5, are proposed. The models are applied to a case study in which 60 projects are placed into four groups according to two reference sets composed of proposals from the year 2009. The well-known muticriteria sorting method, UTADIS, is also implemented for comparison. It is concluded that proposed methods are more stable than UTADIS and the integrated application of threshold estimation model PM2 and assignment model APM4 provides the best results.


A multicriteria sorting approach based on data envelopment analysis for R&D project selection problem
Karasakal, Esra (Elsevier BV, 2017-12-01)
In this paper, multiple criteria sorting methods based on data envelopment analysis (DEA) are developed to evaluate research and development (R&D) projects. The weight intervals of the criteria are obtained from Interval Analytic Hierarchy Process and employed as the assurance region constraints of models. Based on data envelopment analysis, two threshold estimation models, and five assignment models are developed for sorting. In addition to sorting, these models also provide ranking of the projects. The de...
R&D project performance evaluation with multiple and interdependent criteria
Tohumcu, Zeynep; Karasakal, Esra; Department of Industrial Engineering (2007)
In this study, an Analytic Network Process (ANP) and Data Envelopment Analysis (DEA) based approach was developed in order to measure the performance of customer-based Research and Development projects being executed in TÜB TAKSAGE, Defense Research and Development Institute, under the Scientific and Technological Research Council of Turkey. In order to evaluate project performance, many criteria, containing various subcriteria were determined. In order to handle the interdependencies among the criteria and...
An integrated scheduling and control model for multi-mode projects
Hazır, Öncü; Schmidt, Klaus Verner (2013-01-01)
In today's highly competitive uncertain project environments, it is of crucial importance to develop analytical models and algorithms to schedule and control project activities so that the deviations from the project objectives are minimized. This paper addresses the integrated scheduling and control in multi-mode project environments. We propose an optimization model that models the dynamic behavior of projects and integrates optimal control into a practically relevant project scheduling problem. From the ...
A method for supporting data collection in user research studies at domestic environments
Öztoprak, Aydın; Erbuğ, Çiğdem; Department of Industrial Design (2011)
This thesis analyzes data collection tools and methods in domestic environments for smart product development processes. The aim of the study is to create a method for supporting data collection studies in user research of smart products at domestic environments. The study examines the utilization of information and communication technologies in ethnographic data collection methods at domestic environments with a qualitative approach. Two case studies are conducted to understand and analyze the effects of c...
An innovative integrated framework towards effective collaboration environments in construction
Erdogan, Bilge; Anumba, Chimay J.; Bouchlaghem, Dino; Nielsen, Yasemin (Inderscience Publishers, 2010-01-01)
The research reported in this paper was aimed at exploring the introduction of IT enabled collaboration environments to construction organisations and managing the changes required to obtain full benefits. The paper firstly presents the results of a literature review on the factors affecting the success of collaboration environment implementations. Secondly, it summarises the results of case studies providing the perspectives of the construction organisations on the implementation of collaboration environme...
Citation Formats
P. Aker, “A Dea based sorting approach for industrial R&D projects,” M.S. - Master of Science, Middle East Technical University, 2010.