An assessment of the status of the multiple realizability thesis in cognitive science

Download

index.pdf

Date

2011

Author

Baysan, Emin Umut

Metadata

Show full item record

Item Usage Stats

150
views

58
downloads

It has been argued that there are physically different ways of instantiating mental properties, the nature of which is the subject matter of cognitive science. This claim has been known as the Multiple Realizability Thesis (MRT). It has been suggested that the MRT shows that a reduction of mental properties to physical properties is impossible, as there cannot be one-to-one correspondences of mental properties to the properties of the brain. Moreover, it has been argued that the latter point shows that physical explanations are not relevant to the explanations of cognitive science, as they would lack the generality of psychological explanations. This thesis will try to explain from which assumptions of a traditional cognitive science perspective the MRT follows. It will also discuss several responses that have been introduced against both the MRT and the anti-reductionist conclusions that are assumed to follow from it. The responses include a challenge to the scientific status of cognitive science. According to this challenge, the MRT entails that the subject matter of cognitive science, namely mental properties, lack a similarity in the physical level, hence an instance of a mental property is not informative about another instance. While discussing these theories, a revision of the MRT will be proposed. According to this revision, the MRT is compatible with the assumption that there could be an underlying similarity between different physical realizers of a given mental property. It will be argued that by means of this revision, both the challenge to the scientific status of cognitive science, and the argument for the irrelevance of physical explanations will fail.

Subject Keywords

Cognition., Cognitive Sciences.

URI

http://etd.lib.metu.edu.tr/upload/12613265/index.pdf
https://hdl.handle.net/11511/20639

Collections

Graduate School of Informatics, Thesis

Suggestions

OpenMETU
Core

A Case study of problem solving in eye-tracking Özdemir, Doruk; Çakır, Murat Perit; Department of Cognitive Sciences (2013) Traditional theories of cognition have been critiqued for underestimating the role and contributions of embodied processes, more specifically the role of sensorimotor skills, in higher-order cognitive processes such as reasoning and problem-solving. Embodied theories of cognition have started to emphasize and illustrate the prominent roles of lower-level processes and sensorimotor skills in mental processes. This thesis aims to reveal the connection between higher cognitive skills, specifically problem-solv...
Cortical localization debate with its historical background Ekemen, Cengiz; Bağçe, Samet; Gökçay, Didem; Department of Philosophy (2012) The primary aim of this thesis is the consideration of neuroscientific studies regarding the localization of high-level cognitive (i.e., nonsensory and nonmotor) processes into the brain. To accomplish this aim, I briefly summarized history of the localizations which lead to the cortical localization of high-level cognitive processes. Then, I present a case study, memory consolidation to compare molecular neuroscience (MN) and cognitive neuroscience (CN) as to how they differ in their localizations. After I...
A new outlier detection method based on convex optimization: application to diagnosis of Parkinson's disease TAYLAN, PAKİZE; Yerlikaya-Ozkurt, Fatma; Bilgic Ucak, Burcu; Weber, Gerhard Wilhelm (Informa UK Limited, 2020-12-01) Neuroscience is a combination of different scientific disciplines which investigate the nervous system for understanding of the biological basis. Recently, applications to the diagnosis of neurodegenerative diseases like Parkinson's disease have become very promising by considering different statistical regression models. However, well-known statistical regression models may give misleading results for the diagnosis of the neurodegenerative diseases when experimental data contain outlier observations that l...
A FLAW IN THE EXPLANATION OF THE STEREOKINETIC CONE ILLUSION AND 2 GUIDING HYPOTHESES FOR NEW RESEARCH TALASLI, U (SAGE Publications, 1993-06-01) The basic conceptions used in the literature for the explanation of the stereokinetic cone illusion are examined and shown to contain an important flaw which concerns the presumed equivalence of retinal images projected by 2- versus 3-dimensional structures. Upon showing that such equivalence does not prevail, two hypotheses are proposed, pointing out that the illusion must arise from inherent characteristics of the nervous system and their interaction with the stimulus at critical parameters.
Longitudinal data analysis with statistical and machine learning methods in neuroscience Çakar, Serenay; Gökalp Yavuz, Fulya; Department of Statistics (2022-8) Exploration of brain activity under different conditions has been subject to many neuroscience studies. The recent developments in cognitive studies provide the opportunity to work on neural correlates of specific cognitive processes such as working memory, decision making, response inhibition, perception, and sensation. Brain response studies constitute multidimensional, multilevel or nested data sets formed by different parts of the brain of individuals. Hence, it is of significant importance to implement...

Citation Formats

E. U. Baysan, “An assessment of the status of the multiple realizability thesis in cognitive science,” M.S. - Master of Science, Middle East Technical University, 2011.