Justice as the requirement of toleration: contemptuous tolerance and punitive intolerance in the sixteenth century Ottoman Empire

Download

index.pdf

Date

2011

Author

Eğilmez, Devrim Burcu

Metadata

Show full item record

Item Usage Stats

242
views

114
downloads

This dissertation investigates the historical knowledge of the idea/practice of Ottoman toleration/intolerance, in terms of a conceptual-theoretical framework and methodology derived from philosophical theories of toleration, theories of religious toleration of Western historiography and critical theories of toleration, which are in turn revised and reformulated according to “way of reasoning” of the Ottomans. The objective of deriving a conceptual-theoretical framework is related with the attempt to clarify different linguistic uses of the toleration, the semantics of the concept and presenting circumstances, requirements, levels, degrees and forms of the category. Methodologically, the objective is to abolish the hierarchy between kâfir (infidel) and zındîk/ilhâd (heretic) in terms of identification of subjects of toleration/intolerance in the Ottoman Empire. In order to apply this conceptual-theoretical framework and methodology concerning the idea/practice of toleration, this study focuses on the sixteenth-century Ottoman Empire, particularly its laws (firmans, fetvâ, Ottoman criminal law) and its conception of justice, which is conceptualized as the most important requirement of toleration. The objective is to argue how justice primarily regulated society in order to sustain public order and to v prevent political and economic instability. The idea/practice of toleration/intolerance, in this sense, is discussed as the policy that was incorporated into the discourse of the Ottoman Empire to the extent that it contributed to the regulation objective of justice as the art of government, which was pragmatic and prudent in essence. In accordance with this framework, the idea/practice of tolerance in the sixteenth-century Ottoman Empire is conceptualized as contemptuous tolerance, followed by the analysis of its laws. Intolerance, on the other hand, is named as punitive intolerance which aims for either the reform or the incapacitation of the heretics and infidels in the Ottoman lands.

Subject Keywords

Social Sciences.

URI

http://etd.lib.metu.edu.tr/upload/12613865/index.pdf
https://hdl.handle.net/11511/20903

Collections

Graduate School of Social Sciences, Thesis

Suggestions

OpenMETU
Core

The role of religious identity in Turco-European relations Genç, Ezgi; Yurdusev, Ahmet Nuri; Department of International Relations (2004) This thesis analyzes the role of the religious identity in Turco-European relations in terms of historical and perceptional levels. Within this context, ways in which an enriched understanding of the concept of religion, as a principal element of culture and identity and as one of the main and oldest concepts in European identity which may contribute to a better comprehension of contemporary Turco- European relations, especially within the framework of Turkish candidacy to the European Union will be explore...
Continuities and changes in the minority policy of Greece: the case of western thrace Chousein, Ali; Tayfur, Mehmet Fatih; Department of International Relations (2005) This thesis analyzes the Greek minority policy of Western Thrace by dwelling on the history of the Muslim Turkish minority of Western Thrace from the beginning of 1920s until today. Until the early 1990s, changes in the Greek policy of Western Thrace had not been observed. However, the year 1991 marks a turning point both in the attitude of Greece towards the Muslim Turkish minority and in the history of the Western Thracian minority. As a result of the change in the Greek minority policy of Western Thrace ...
The reconstruction of Albanian politics and identity in the context of european integration Nikolla, Dorina; Ertuğrul, Kürşad; Department of Political Science and Public Administration (2004) This thesis analyses the change of the Albanian national identity and ideology during its contemporary history, beginning from the national awakening period up to post-communism. The break with the dictatorial Enver Hoxha regime marked the begining of a new era for the Albanian ideology and politics. To this regard, the political elite, played a prominent role in the process of transition and the opening of Albania to the world.The prospect for the EU membership became the major motivation of the Albanian p...
Discourses of Kemalism and Islamism on the political dimension of EU - Turkey Relations Çilingir, Sevgi; Dağı, İhsan Duran; Department of International Relations (2005) This thesis aims at defining and analyzing the positions of Kemalism and Islamism about the relationship between the European Union and Turkey, with respect to identity and political reform. The study is conducted by the usage of academic literature and examples of the writings of intellectuals from both positions; in order to analyze their discourses on the issue.With respect to the political dimension of EU - Turkey relations, the problems and EU demands on democracy, human rights, minority rights - with ...
Russian foreign policy and the discourse of eurasianism rhetoric versus reality Akgül, Esra; Tanrısever, Oktay Fırat; Department of Eurasian Studies (2005) This thesis aims to examine the evolution of the discourse of Eurasianism and its impact on the formulation and implementation of post-Soviet Russian foreign policy. The thesis argues that both of Russia̕s post-Soviet leaders: Boris Yeltsin and Vladimir Putin have used the discourse of neo-Eurasianism pragmatically whenever it suited Russia̕s interests. Moscow ignored this discourse when its foreign policy interests contradicted with the main tenets of this ideology. The thesis has five chapters. Following ...

Citation Formats

D. B. Eğilmez, “Justice as the requirement of toleration: contemptuous tolerance and punitive intolerance in the sixteenth century Ottoman Empire,” Ph.D. - Doctoral Program, Middle East Technical University, 2011.