Post-disaster recovery process and location choices of businesses in case of Adapazarı

Download
2012
Orhan, Ezgi
Turkey has been less responsive to changes in global policies of risk reduction and resilience compared to developed countries. Turkish administrations usually concentrate on allocating resources for the compensation of survivors and recovery procedures. The post-disaster implementations focus on households and usually compel them to leave their current accommodation and move elsewhere. Whereas business enterprises mostly maintain their location and property in the disaster hit areas. Due to lack of appropriate policy and tools, businesses often remain in their facilities or make their own location choices as a part of their recovery strategy. Since physical damage in facilities is not the only determinant of business disruption, it is required to define the factors that lead to disparities in recovery among businesses. In this regard, this study explores the factors that affect recovery process of businesses in the city of Adapazarı heavily damaged in the 1999 Earthquake. The main argument of the study is that urban spatial structure of Adapazarı is fragmented due to the implemented recovery policies which isolated business recovery from household recovery. In the absence of a coherent policy in monitoring the business recovery processes, it is highly relevant to understand the strategy and decisions of the business enterprises in their own efforts of recovery. This should allow planners to asses whether such independent recovery decisions could be compatible with some overall urban spatial structure. For the purposes of research an empirical investigation was carried out surveying a sample of business enterprises in Adapazarı. According to the analysis of results of the empirical research, the most notable impact on business recovery positively associated with „finance, insurance and real estate (FIRE) sector‟ and negatively correlated with „trade sector‟, „service sector‟, and with variables expressing states of „being financially in trouble‟, and „taking more damage‟. The variables of „educational level‟, „construction sector‟ and „extent of damage‟ are found to contribute significantly to firm mobility. In addition, variables of „having disaster experience‟ and „owner-occupation‟ are negatively correlated with business relocation. The post-disaster location choices of firms determine the new structure of the city not necessarily in conformity with spatial decisions concerning the residential recovery processes and spatial structure they manifest. The outcome of the study is that the interventions in the recovery period in the form of strict provision of new resettlement districts in Adapazarı could not contribute to the creation of a safer spatial, environmental, economic and social context due to the inadequacy of policies designed for business recovery.

Suggestions

Critical evaluation of “adjacent areas” concept from urban growth perspective in Turkish urban planning: the case of Ankara
Yıldırım, Sibel; Keskinok, Hüseyin Çağatay; Department of City and Regional Planning (2008)
The effects of expansion of cities on the fringe area are still the common problems of several countries as well as Turkey. The main problem stemming from rapid urban growth was described as urban sprawl that has been used as waste of land, time, and natural resources. Although sprawl becomes usually unplanned, uncontrolled, and uncoordinated, it can be claimed that some local and national government policies triggers the urban sprawl by creating planned areas more than required. The growth management polic...
Urban transformation projects in Ankara: challenge for a holistic urban planning system
Karaburun, Nursun; Uzun, Cemile Nil; Department of City and Regional Planning (2009)
The global weakening of nation states has isolated cities. On the other hand, the authority of local administrations has been increasing rapidly. Urban planning responsibility is under the authority of local governments. Due to intense competition for attractive solutions, local authorities have tended to use methods that produce immediate results. Therefore, planning approach has been changing and in place of comprehensive plans, we find quick fix projects. According to comprehensive planning approach and ...
Sociospatial impacts of deindustrialization : the case of Karabük
Çevik, Murat; Şengül, Hüseyin Tarık; Department of City and Regional Planning (2003)
The main objective of this study is to evaluate the socio-spatial impacts of the restructuring of a locality, Karabük, which was shaped under a different development strategy, namely, import substitution industrialization strategy. Karabük case shows that establishment of Karabük Iron and Steal Factories was decided on the basis of political and social priorities of a period when there was limited competitive environment and such priorities have lost their primacy under the export oriented growth strategy i...
Methodology and database requirements for urban regenerration action planning : the case of Zeytinburnu, İstanbul
Burnaz, Ahmet Mert; Balamir, Murat; Department of City and Regional Planning (2004)
As a result of the disregard of governments̕ direct urbanization policies for more than 50 years, most of the settlements in Turkey today demonstrate sub-standard environments and unauthorized developments subject to severe natural hazards. Turkey will have to focus in the near future on the renewal and regeneration of cities built over the past six decades, rather then sticking to urban policies solely devoted to extend new urban areas. The production of legal instruments and urban policies to facilitate t...
Process and participation in legal regulations of urban regeneration: the case of Zeytinburnu, İstanbul
Çiçek, Hüseyin; Balamir, Murat; Department of City and Regional Planning (2005)
High risks imposed by natural hazards, and changes in economic, socio-cultural and technological conditions compel Turkey to transform its cities rather than promote growth. In this respect, urban regeneration became a significant concern demanding a comprehensive and integrated vision and action. Turkey will have to focus on regenerating the built environment in the near feature, rather than follow conventional trends of city-extension development. As scope and methods of urban regeneration planning differ...
Citation Formats
E. Orhan, “Post-disaster recovery process and location choices of businesses in case of Adapazarı,” Ph.D. - Doctoral Program, Middle East Technical University, 2012.