Articulation of tribalism into modernity : the case of Pashtuns in Afghanistan

Download
2013
Sungur, Zeynep Tuba
The main objective of this thesis is to analyse the relationship between tribalism and modernity in Afghanistan. Focusing on Pashtuns, who constitute the largest ethnic group in Afghanistan, the thesis traces their transformation from a tribal confederacy into a central state that introduced modernity to Afghanistan. In this regard, the thesis is, basically, a discussion of the struggle for power between two institutions in Afghanistan: the tribe and the state. In an effort to reveal the relationship between the two, the thesis looks at the modern strategies and ideologies used by the Afghan state to beat the power of tribalism. Nationalism and Socialism, in this regard, come up as two modern ideologies that are discussed in relation to Pashtun Tribalism. Questioning the concepts of Afghan Nationalism and Pashtun Nationalism as well as their relation to Pashtun Tribalism, the thesis discusses the concept of a tribe within the frame of modern border demarcation, nation-building efforts and modernist reform programmes. Passing on to the discussion on Socialism, the thesis then addresses the question of tribe in relation to the idea of class struggle, a communist party, a modern coup d’état and a communist revolution. Contrasting the concept of tribe with such modern notions, the thesis finally reveals how tribalism managed to survive within these modern ideologies by articulating into them in various ways.

Suggestions

Reproduction of nationalism (Ulusalcılık) in the process of democratic opening in Turkey : the case of Türksolu magazine
Kütküt, Özgür Mehmet; Topal, Çağatay; Department of Sociology (2013)
The aim of this thesis is to analyse how the Türksolu magazine reproduced ulusalcılık during the democratic opening process in 2009-2011, which was oriented toward solving the Kurdish Issue being one of the most burning problems of the Turkish social and political life. For this reason the nationalism theories have been examined, the relationship between socialism and nationalism, tactical positions and the ideas of Sultan Galiev, who was one of the fundamental sources of Türksolu’s ulusalcılık, as well as ...
Continuity and change in European social democracy: reasserting its viability within the context of globalization
Kamalak, İhsan; Okyayuz, Mehmet; Department of Biochemistry (2006)
The arguments concerning the unviability of Social Democracy at the beginning of new century within the context of globalization, and the accusations for its shift towards the New Right/Neo-Liberalism in the case of the Third Way has been criticized in a historico-critical way in this thesis. It is claimed that the insufficiency of these arguments arises from their analysis of Social Democracy merely through policies, or party politics, which have displayed great variety in the evolution of Social Democracy...
Early Modern State Formation in Afghanistan in Relation to Pashtun Tribalism
Sungur, Zeynep Tuba (2016-12-01)
The overall objective of this article is to analyse the encounter between Pashtun tribalism and state centralization as part of a modernization programme in Afghanistan in the almost fifty-year period between 1880 and 1929. Focusing on Pashtuns, the article attempts to show howa segment of Pashtuns acted as the founders and rulers of the modern Afghan state while another segment sustained their tribal features and rejected the authority of the central state. Presenting the tribe-state conflict through the c...
Hearing and remembering the voices of women in the Turkish nation building process: Kadinlar Dünyası and Türk Kadın Yolu
Uçak, Deniz; Çıtak Aytürk, Zana Ayşe; Department of International Relations (2018)
This thesis examines the relationship between nationalism and gender with a particular focus on the making of Turkish nationalism and women, based on the analysis of two women’s periodicals: Kadınlar Dünyası and Türk Kadın Yolu. While the former was published in the latest stage of the Ottoman period between 1913 and 1921, coinciding with the emergence and rise of Turkish nationalism, the latter was published after the foundation of the Republic between 1925 and 1927. Accordingly, this thesis tries to under...
Political modernization and informal politics in Uzbekistan
Şır, Aslan Yavuz; Yıldırım, Erdoğan; Department of Eurasian Studies (2007)
The objective of this thesis is to examine the political modernization experience of the Uzbeks. In order to do that, first, this dissertation critically analyze the modernization theory, and second, the identity- and socio-political transformation of Uzbeks in the pre-modern and modern eras. The political modernization of Uzbeks and its relation with the peculiar social-political structures, as well as the impact of Tsarist and the Soviet rule on those structures are examined. Moreover, the dissertation an...
Citation Formats
Z. T. Sungur, “Articulation of tribalism into modernity : the case of Pashtuns in Afghanistan,” M.S. - Master of Science, Middle East Technical University, 2013.