The Impact of modality and feedback on reasoning about base rate neglect problems in behavioral and eye tracking studies: a cognitive science perspective

Download

index.pdf

Date

2014

Author

Verim, Burcu

Metadata

Show full item record

Item Usage Stats

216
views

97
downloads

The base rate fallacy is a type of reasoning error which is rooted in judgements of humans about the likelihood of some state or some event on prior beliefs and intuitions about the representativeness of the problem while neglecting base rate probabilities of this state or event. So far, base rate neglect problems have been presented in the verbal modality, in the form of story scripts. The purpose of this study is to investigate to what extent the different modalities (verbal vs. graphical) have an effect on reasoning about these problems via providing random sampling and feedback. Eye-tracking data, reaction times and accuracy rates of judgments will be measured. It is hypothesized that providing the participants feedback for questions about frequency distributions along with the direct experience of random sampling will cause a decrease in the base-rate neglect. The results indicated a significant difference between the three experimental groups. This study has implications for education in terms of multi-modal teaching, learning, and reasoning.

Subject Keywords

Uncertainty., Reasoning., Visual perception., Interactive multimedia., Computer-assisted instruction.

URI

http://etd.lib.metu.edu.tr/upload/12617918/index.pdf
https://hdl.handle.net/11511/24049

Collections

Graduate School of Informatics, Thesis

Suggestions

OpenMETU
Core

The influence of the context of conditional probability problems on probabilistic thinking: A case study with teacher candidates Olgun, Beyza; Işıksal Bostan, Mine (null; 2019-02-10) This study investigates the influence of the context of conditional probability problems on probabilistic thinking processes of mathematics teacher candidates. Data were collected from four mathematics teacher candidates through semi-structured clinical interviews. Teacher candidates were expected to solve and explain three conditional probability problems, which were selected based on specific contexts. The findings revealed that, when the context is related to a social issue such as health or justice, tha...
The influence of the context of conditional probability problems on probabilistic thinking: A case study with teacher candidates Olgun, Beyza; Işıksal Bostan, Mine (2019-12-21) This study investigates the influence of the context of conditional probability problems on probabilistic thinking processes of mathematics teacher candidates. Data were collected from four mathematics teacher candidates through semi-structured clinical interviews. Teacher candidates were expected to solve and explain three conditional probability problems, which were selected based on specific contexts. The findings revealed that, when the context is related to a social issue such as health or justice, tha...
The Interaction of probability learning and prefrontal cortex Gözenman, Filiz; Gökçay, Didem; Çakır, Murat Perit; Department of Cognitive Sciences (2012) Probability learning is the ability to establish a relationship between stimulus and outcomes based on occurrence probabilities using repetitive feedbacks. Participants learn the task according to the cue-outcome relationship, and try to gain in depth understanding of this relationship throughout the experiment. While learning is at the highest level, people rely on their working memory. In this study 20 participants were presented a probability learning task, and their prefrontal cortex activity was measur...
The Emerging Interplay Between Subjective and Objective Notions of Probability in Young Children Kazak, Sibel; Leavy, Aisling (2022-09-01) To promote the development of young children's probabilistic intuitions through experience, we focus on the dual nature of probability related to both belief (subjective notion) and frequency (objective notion). This paper reports on the responses of 7-8-year-olds on two tasks used to bridge subjective and objective notions of probability. We explore how these two conceptions interact in children's estimations of the likelihood of outcomes from chance events as new information is obtained from data collecte...
How technology supports argumentation structures in the geometry context Erkek, Özlem; Işıksal Bostan, Mine (null; 2018-07-02) Argumentation encompasses higher order thinking skills, such as generating hypothesis, justifying ideas, synthesizing problems, challenging others’ views, comparing different positions and evaluating hypotheses via empirical evidence (Hewit, 2010). The teacher plays a crucial role in the argumentation process and, thus, should be pedagogically equipped to effectively prepare and implement an argumentation-based instruction. The aim of the present study was to investigate the nature of the argumentation stru...

Citation Formats

B. Verim, “The Impact of modality and feedback on reasoning about base rate neglect problems in behavioral and eye tracking studies: a cognitive science perspective,” M.S. - Master of Science, Middle East Technical University, 2014.