Risk assessment by fault tree analysis of methane explosions in Turkish hard coal enterprises underground mines

Mevsim, Rıdvan
Mining is one of the most hazardous industries in the world. Among all mining professions, underground coal mining has the highest occupational accident and disease rates. Methane explosion appears as the major accident type which results in severe loss of life and property in underground coal mining. Including underground coal mines, preparing a practicable risk assessment is the primary step to sustain a safe workplace environment. The main objective of this study is to specify the root causes of methane explosions in underground hard coal mines by performing quantitative risk assessment. Total of 67 methane explosions resulted in 815 fatalities between the years 1875 and 2014 within Turkish Hard Coal Enterprises (TTK), which is the major hard coal producer in Turkey, are evaluated in order to achieve the goal. A deductive risk analysis technique, fault tree analysis (FTA), was implemented in order to specify the root causes of methane explosions. The methodology starts with examining the occupational accident statistics gathered from TTK. Using the data, events and gates of the fault tree were constructed by a step-wise approach. Major and minor causes of methane explosions were identified by utilising ReliaSoft BlockSim-7 software. Research findings revealed that mechanical ignitions are the most significant failure event for a possible methane explosion. It is followed by deficient ventilation practice, methane outburst, blasting, and electrical ignition, respectively. The time period in which a methane explosion has a 100% probability to occur was found as 108 months. Excluding the most significant failure event mechanical ignitions from the fault tree, the period increases to 255 months. Besides the quantitative FTA, also qualitative FTA was conducted. Qualitative fault tree has 27 intermediate events and 65 basic events (root causes) which make it a comprehensive fault tree of methane explosions among other studies in the field. This study, as being the first implementation of FTA for methane explosions in Turkish underground coal mines, is expected to contribute to mining industry and current literature in various ways. Research area could be extended in the future studies from TTK to Turkish coal mining industry, including also the private sector companies. The monotype 5 x 5 matrix risk analysis practice in the country could be improved by raising the awareness of coal industry to the comprehensive nature of FTA approach and performing FTA at mining companies. A general guide to prevent methane explosions could be prepared by considering the root causes on the fault tree and it could also contribute to the provisions of national occupational safety and health legislation. The ultimate goal is to prevent possible accidents caused by methane explosions.


A Quantitative risk assessment methodology for occupational accidents in underground coal mines: a case of Turkish hard coal enterprises
Erdoğan, Hasan Hüseyin; Düzgün, H. Şebnem; Kestel, Sevtap Ayşe; Department of Mining Engineering (2016)
Underground coal mining is one of the most dangerous occupations throughout the world. The incidence of injuries and the days lost due to accidents in underground coal mines are much greater than industrial average. In general, the reasons behind an underground occupational accident are too complex to analyze. The risk analysis and assessment is the most suitable method to cope with these type of issues. This study proposes a quantitative methodology for the analysis and assessment of risks associated with ...
Development of a computer-based risk assessment tool for underground coal mines
Başayar Büyükkara, Fatma Nur; Karpuz, Celal; Department of Mining Engineering (2016)
Underground coal mining remains one of the world’s most hazardous occupations. There are numerous hazards in a mine, such as gas, dust, noise, temperature, and high humidity. Besides, increasing number of occupational accidents in underground coal mines shows the importance of occupational health and safety in these workplaces. By means of Occupational Health and Safety Law No 6331, attention to health and safety in the workplace has grown in recent years in Turkey. In addition, conducting an occupational h...
Monitoring and statistical modelling of dust concentration of some Turkish lignites under laboratory conditions
Karakaş, Ahmet; Güyagüler, Tevfik; Department of Mining Engineering (2010)
Although technological developments enable maximum safety, high dust formation is still a crucial problem in coal mining sector. This study is aimed to investigate the relationship between amount of coal dust produced during cutting operation and some important coal properties together with cutting parameters for different particle size ranges in laboratory conditions. For this purpose, six Turkish lignite samples were used in the experiments. Two experiment sets were designed to generate coal dust by using...
Analysis and modelling for risk management for underground coal mines’ safety
Eratak, Özlem Deniz; Karpuz, Celal; Department of Mining Engineering (2014)
Safety in underground coal mining has become an important issue because of increasing number of accidents. There are many different hazards may cause these accidents and the most efficient method for coping with risks is the use of risk management techniques. In this thesis, accident data including workday losses, age of the injured, organ affected by accident, season, shift and reason of the accident was collected from TKI mines (ELI- Soma Eynez and GLI Tuncbilek) and TTK mines. Those variables were initia...
Soil contamination mapping for an abandoned coal mine site by using worldview 2 and aster imagery
Soydan, Hilal; Düzgün, H. Şebnem; Department of Mining Engineering (2013)
Being an indispensable economic and energy source, coal mining may be the cause of long term environmental damages like serious water and soil contamination due to inappropriate mining operations. In order to detect and avoid it, mapping the contamination levels related to mining industry has been a challenge for soil scientists to find the most appropriate and time and cost effective method for constructing soil contamination maps. So far, Remote Sensing (RS) and Geographical Information Systems (GIS) have...
Citation Formats
R. Mevsim, “Risk assessment by fault tree analysis of methane explosions in Turkish hard coal enterprises underground mines,” M.S. - Master of Science, Middle East Technical University, 2016.