A Re-assessment of the world society conceptualization

Tepeciklioğlu, Ali Onur
This dissertation argues that non-state actors were more apparent, and relatedly, more capable of controlling and transforming the international relations in the pre-modern period than they are in the modern. The role of non-state actors is dramatically limited in the modern international society because of the nation-state, the most centralized and penetrating polity that humankind have ever established. The organizing principles of the pre-modern international relations were more suitable for non-state action. World society conceptualization of the English School is adopted in order to develop this argument. As the existing accounts of the world society concept particularly concentrate on the possible effects of the values having the potential to be shared globally in the modern international society, they simply neglect interest-seeking and pre-modern forms of non-state action. For this reason, this dissertation makes a distinction between the value-based (ideational) and interest-seeking (functional) world society elements and analyzes their impact on the international system/society with respect to their aims. According to this distinction, functional world society elements only aim to control a specific sphere of international relations, while the ideational world society elements seek to reshape the core foundational principles of the international system/society. In order to support its main argument, the dissertation analyzes four distinct cases, namely the Roman Catholic Church, Amnesty International, the Hanseatic League, and International Chamber of Commerce, and compares them with each other. Main findings of the study show that the non-state dimension of international relations prevails against the state dimension in the pre-modern international relations.


Possibility of an islamic theory of international relations
Adiong, Nassef Manabilang; Yurdusev, Ahmet Nuri; Department of International Relations (2016)
International Relations is dominated by Western’s (Euro-American) enterprise on theories, methods, praxes and narratives. In order to have a more inclusive and truly globalized IR, it has to substantially acknowledge diversity of existence, stories, voices, realities, cosmologies, and locally produced knowledge systems particularly from non-Western or Global South societies. Calls for reexamination and rethinking of its traditions of thoughts so as to accommodate changes and new issues in the international ...
The Limits of realist conception of security: examing the views of Campbell and Waever /
Seven, Elfesiya; Deveci, Cem; Department of Political Science and Public Administration (2015)
This thesis examines two different and contemporary theories which criticize the centrality of “security issues” in the re-establishment of the post-Cold War international order as one of the fundamental principles of the realist school. The views of David Campbell and Copenhagen Securitization School focus on the role of “the security issue” in the determination of the Cold War policies, and ask whether this security care lost its effects or not in the process of determination of foreign policies. Both of ...
A constructivist criticism of neo-realist conception of “state” in international relations: Turkey’s five motions on military involvement in Iraq (2003–2007)
Apar, Altan; Çıtak Aytürk, Zana Ayşe; Department of International Relations (2009)
The thesis makes a constructivist criticism of neo-realism’s particular conceptualization of state through a comparative analysis of Turkey’s five motions (2003-2007) on military involvement in Iraq. Firstly, neo-realism and constructivism with regards to the concept of state are explored. Then, through the lights of the theoretical discussion, Turkey’s five military motions are examined. In the case study, parliamentary minutes are used as the primary historical evidences. In the parliamentary discussions,...
The Political analysis of the Syrian crises and the zero-problem policy with Syria
Arslantaş, Şenol; Bölükbaşıoğlu, Süha; Department of International Relations (2013)
This thesis aims to analyze both the evolution of Turkish-Syrian relations during the period of the AKP governments and the emergence of the Syrian revolt in March 2010. With the popular revolts in many Arab countries starting in December 2010, Turkey’s general foreign policy vision, which had already undergone considerable changes from the traditional foreign policy of Turkey under the rule of the AKP government, was deeply affected by the Arab revolts. With the newly-emerged political and social conjunctu...
Geopolitics and the study of international relations
Gökmen, Semra Ranâ; Polat, Necati; Department of International Relations (2010)
This study seeks to examine the main theories and theorists of geopolitical imagining and argue for an intrinsic relation between traditional geopolitics and the development of international relations both in theory and practice. By doing so the study aims to pursue an assessment of the insights of critical geopolitics, as reflected in the works of John Agnew, Geraróid Ó Tuathail (Gerard Toal), Simon Dalby, Klaus Dodds and others, for the theory of IR, more specifically its dominant paradigm realism. The ai...
Citation Formats
A. O. Tepeciklioğlu, “A Re-assessment of the world society conceptualization,” Ph.D. - Doctoral Program, Middle East Technical University, 2016.