A new approach to evaluate the MODIS annual NPP product (MOD17A3) using forest field data from Turkey

Gulbeyaz, Onder
Bond-Lamberty, Ben
Akyürek, Sevda Zuhal
West, Tristram O.
In this study, we present the first evaluation of the MODIS (Moderate Resolution Imaging Spectroradiometer) annual net primary production (NPP) for Turkey's forest ecosystems using field measurements. Due to lack of country scale field measurements (i.e. flux tower for forest ecosystems), tree DBH (diameter at breast height) data set provided by Ministry of Forest and Water Affairs (MFWA) of Turkey is used to calculate NPP of Turkey's forest ecosystems. The lack of a reliable NPP data set leads the researchers to use global NPP models such as MODIS annual NPP product. The MODIS MOD17A3 product of vegetation NPP is one of the most highly used data sources for studies of global carbon cycle. However, it is still necessary to test its predictions in multiple biomes, especially for heterogeneous areas in terms of its accuracy and potential bias. Here, we studied a new approach to evaluate coarse scale NPP estimates from the MODIS NPP-MOD17A3 data product, using 2008-2013 field measurements of tree growth throughout Turkey. Three different methods were used to calculate field NPP, including standardized growth coefficients (ministry coefficients [MC]), growth coefficients from North America (Jenkins coefficients [JC]), and annual expected increment (AEI). The average NPP values for all the country is calculated as 2.06kgC m(-1)/5years (0.412kgC m(-2)year(-1)) (SD=1.15kgC m(-1)/5years) from MOD17A3, 0.90kgC m(-1)/5years (0.18kgC m(-2)year(-1)) (SD=0.57kgC m(-1)/5years) with MC, 0.63kgC m(-1)/5years (0.126kgC m(-2)year(-1)) (SD=0.37kgC m(-1)/5years) with JC and 0.58kgC m(-2)year(-1) (SD=0.29kgC m(-1)/5years) with AEI for the studied plots. We found that the MODIS NPP product has a clear relation with both the NPP estimates obtained by using MC (R-2=0.34, root mean square error (RMSE)=1.51kgC m(-1)/5years) and JC (R-2=0.32, RMSE=1.73kgC m(-1)/5years). In addition to that, the relation between MOD17A3 product and AEI-derived NPP is relatively strong (R-2=0.48, RMSE=0.26kgC m(-2)year(-1)). We discuss possible reasons for these trade-offs among different methods. This study lays out a new approach to validate coarse scale MODIS product using field data directly, including for highly heterogeneous areas.


Assessment of soil acidification due to a natural gas-fired power plant by using two different approaches
Soyupak, S; Yurteri, C; Mukhallalati, L; Kilic, B; Kayin, S; Onder, K (Informa UK Limited, 1996-01-01)
Potential soil acidification impacts of a proposed natural gas-fired combined cycle power plant were assessed using an integrated approach coupling an atmospheric deposition model with soil acidification quantification. The deposition model was used to estimate the rates of nitrogen oxide (NOx) deposition on the air-soil boundary. The expected changes in the soil column were then predicted by utilizing mechanistic and experimental methods, and the number of years required to reach critical pH values were pr...
Evaluation of Remotely-Sensed and Model-Based Soil Moisture Products According to Different Soil Type, Vegetation Cover and Climate Regime Using Station-Based Observations over Turkey
Bulut, Burak; Yılmaz, Mustafa Tuğrul; Afshar, Mahdı Hesamı ; Sorman, A. Unal; Yücel, İsmail; Cosh, Michael H.; Simsek, Osman (MDPI AG, 2019-08-01)
This study evaluates the performance of widely-used remotely sensed- and model-based soil moisture products, including: The Advanced Scatterometer (ASCAT), the Advanced Microwave Scanning Radiometer-Earth Observing System (AMSR-E), the European Space Agency Climate Change Initiative (ESA-CCI), the Antecedent Precipitation Index (API), and the Global Land Data Assimilation System (GLDAS-NOAH). Evaluations are performed between 2008 and 2011 against the calibrated station-based soil moisture observations coll...
Evaluation of SeaWiFS chlorophyll-a in the Black and Mediterranean seas
Sancak, S; Besiktepe, ST; Yılmaz, Ayşen; Lee, M; Frouin, R (Informa UK Limited, 2005-05-20)
The performance of NASA's OC2 and OC4 algorithms to estimate chlorophyll-a concentrations from SeaWiFS radiometric measurements on the global scale was tested in two contrasted bio-optical environments, the Black Sea and the Mediterranean Sea. The in situ bio-optical measurements were made during October 1999 at 25 stations. Comparisons of the in situ measurements with the concurrent SeaWiFS retrievals indicate that the OC2 and OC4 algorithms are not working satisfactorily in both seas. Case 2 waters domina...
Integration of environmental variables with satellite images in regional scale vegetation classification
Domaç, Ayşegül; Süzen, Mehmet Lütfi; Bilgin, Cemal Can (Informa UK Limited, 2006-04-01)
The difficulty of collecting information at conventional field studies and relatively coarse spatial and spectral resolution of Landsat images forced the use of environmental variables as ancillary data in vegetation mapping. The aim of this study is to increase the accuracy of species level vegetation classification incorporating environmental variables in the Amanos Mountains region of southern central Turkey. In the first part of the study, ordinary vegetation classification is attained by using a maximu...
Evaluating a mesoscale atmosphere model and a satellite-based algorithm in estimating extreme rainfall events in northwestern Turkey
Yücel, İsmail (Copernicus GmbH, 2014-01-01)
Quantitative precipitation estimates are obtained with more uncertainty under the influence of changing climate variability and complex topography from numerical weather prediction (NWP) models. On the other hand, hydrologic model simulations depend heavily on the availability of reliable precipitation estimates. Difficulties in estimating precipitation impose an important limitation on the possibility and reliability of hydrologic forecasting and early warning systems. This study examines the performance o...
Citation Formats
O. Gulbeyaz, B. Bond-Lamberty, S. Z. Akyürek, and T. O. West, “A new approach to evaluate the MODIS annual NPP product (MOD17A3) using forest field data from Turkey,” INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF REMOTE SENSING, pp. 2560–2578, 2018, Accessed: 00, 2020. [Online]. Available: https://hdl.handle.net/11511/42046.