Generating positive bounding boxes for balanced training of object detectors

Oksuz, Kemal
Cam, Baris Can
Akbaş, Emre
Kalkan, Sinan
© 2020 IEEE.Two-stage deep object detectors generate a set of regions-of-interest (RoIs) in the first stage, then, in the second stage, identify objects among the proposed RoIs that sufficiently overlap with a ground truth (GT) box. The second stage is known to suffer from a bias towards RoIs that have low intersection-over-union (IoU) with the associated GT boxes. To address this issue, we first propose a sampling method to generate bounding boxes (BB) that overlap with a given reference box more than a given IoU threshold. Then, we use this BB generation method to develop a positive RoI (pRoI) generator that, for the second stage, produces RoIs following any desired spatial or IoU distribution. We show that our pRoI generator is able to simulate other sampling methods for positive examples such as hard example mining and prime sampling. Using our generator as an analysis tool, we show that (i) IoU imbalance has an adverse effect on performance, (ii) hard positive example mining improves the performance only for certain input IoU distributions, and (iii) the imbalance among the foreground classes has an adverse effect on performance and that it can be alleviated at the batch level. Finally, we train Faster R-CNN using our pRoI generator and, compared to conventional training, obtain better or on-par performance for low IoUs and significant improvements when trained for higher IoUs for Pascal VOC and MS COCO datasets. The code is available at:
Citation Formats
K. Oksuz, B. C. Cam, E. Akbaş, and S. Kalkan, “Generating positive bounding boxes for balanced training of object detectors,” 2020, Accessed: 00, 2020. [Online]. Available: