The British Museum, Muze-i Humayun and the travelling "Greek ideal" in the nineteenth century

Date

2014-03-01

Author

Özkaya, Ayşe Belgin

Metadata

Show full item record

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.

Item Usage Stats

84
views

0
downloads

In standard architectural history surveys, the British Museum is portrayed as an example of nineteenth-century "neoclassicism": or the "Greek revival:" Usually cited as among the motive factors in this revival are the writings about European travels and archaeological explorations in the then Ottoman lands of ancient Greece, as well as a general interest in Hellenic culture. Yet the cultural and architectural appropriation of the Hellenic is not analyzed in relation to the possible ties and tensions between European archaeological culture and the Ottoman response to antiquity. This paper is an attempt to align the British Museum's "Arcadia in Bloomsbury" with the Ottoman Imperial Museum, Muze-i Hamayun, in Istanbul, and to look at them afresh beyond the usual discourse of style. The paper analyzes the "neo-Grecian""Temple of Arts and Sciences" in London, supposedly inspired by those in Priene and Teos in the Ottoman Empire, and the Muze-i Hamayun, whose facade allegedly replicates the Sarcophagus of the Mourning Women, transported to the museum from Sidon in Lebanon by Ottoman officials, understanding them as charged manifestations of "correspondence" or "transfer" within the web of circulating ideas, models, ancient remains, travellers, and architects of the nineteenth century.

Subject Keywords

British Museum, Muze-i Humayun, Philhellenism, Museum architecture, Neoclassicism, Robert Smirke, Alexandre Vallaury, Osman Hamdi, Istanbul Archaeological Museum

URI

https://hdl.handle.net/11511/54808

Journal

NEW PERSPECTIVES ON TURKEY

Collections

Department of Architecture, Article

Suggestions

OpenMETU
Core

Interpretation and presentation of natural and cultural heritage sites : environmental design project for Göreme Open Air Museum Özçakır, Özgün; Şahin Güçhan, Neriman; Restoration in Department of Architecture (2012) The main subject of the thesis is “interpretation” and “presentation” of cultural and natural heritage sites which is an important phenomenon providing sustainability and protection of the heritage sites. Interpretation and conservation are tightly associated to each other. Individuals will learn more about the heritage site by the help of interpretation and as a result of understanding; they will have an intention to protect the historic site more; and protection will ensure continuity of the site. Interpr...
Afterlives of Hagia Sophia: the change in the official attitudes towards preserving antiquities in the Late Ottoman and Early Republican Periods Keskin, Ümran; Güven, Suna Naziyet; Department of History of Architecture (2011) The history and ideology of preservation increasingly arouse interest in parallel with the rising importance of the cultural heritage and preserving it. Hagia Sophia is one of the monuments that comes to mind immediately when the cultural heritage of Turkey is mentioned. Both as a Byzantine and an Ottoman ecclesiastical and imperial monument, Hagia Sophia bears political and religious importance besides its artistic and architectural uniqueness, 1500 years after its construction. This study aims to expose t...
Personifying history: Vernon Lee and re-imagining the Florentine renaissance Kutluata, Cemre Naz; Enginsoy Ekinci, Ayşe Sevil; Department of History of Architecture (2015) This thesis analyses the alternative approaches to the history writing that emerged during the later half of the nineteenth century with the re-discovery of Florence as the centre of Renaissance art and architecture. It discusses this topic by focusing on the British writer and critic Vernon Lee (1856–1935) and her works on interpreting the past through a personal and impressionistic viewpoint, including her ‘formal’ studies of the Renaissance Euphorion (1884) and Renaissance Fancies and Studies (1895), and...
"The citadel of Ankara": Aspects of visual documentation and analysis regarding material use Sülüner, Hasan Sinan; Bakırer, Ömür; Department of Architecture (2005) This thesis examines the history, written sources and physical aspects of the citadel at Ankara with respect to building materials, masonry styles, design and topography. The distribution of different types of building materials in selected areas are analyzed and documented by using modern methods.
The Social and symbolic role of early pottery in the Near East Yıldırım, Burcu.; Atakuman, Çiğdem; Department of Settlement Archaeology (2019) The aim of this thesis is to investigate the social and symbolic role of the earliest pottery in the Near East which flourished during the Neolithic Period. This dissertation provides a comparative analysis of the earliest ceramics and the relationship of pottery form and technology to the plaster and figurine technologies. As early as the 9th millennium BC, the skilled use of ceramic technology and control of fire was evident in the production of lime plaster, as well as anthropomorphic and zoomorphic figu...

Citation Formats

A. B. Özkaya, “The British Museum, Muze-i Humayun and the travelling “Greek ideal” in the nineteenth century,” NEW PERSPECTIVES ON TURKEY, pp. 9–28, 2014, Accessed: 00, 2020. [Online]. Available: https://hdl.handle.net/11511/54808.