Shrinking humanitarian space in Turkey: The government of Turkey’s agency in shaping the operations of humanitarian NGOs in Turkey

2019-12
Boztaş, Özge
Applying the theoretical framework of NGO-government relations, this article shall look into the Government of Turkey (GoT)’s critical role in shaping humanitarian space in Southeast Turkey, which increasingly gained a reputation as the hinterland of cross-border response to Northern Syria and Syrian refugee response in Turkey. The year of 2015 proved a turning point for change in the Turkish government’s stance towards humanitarian activities, stemming from proliferating security concerns over the spill-overs of the Syrian Civil War. Meanwhile, Turkey’s political stance has evolved into playing a more active role through military involvement, which has also constituted the basis for widening controls and pressure over non-governmental organisations (NGOs) sending cross-border aid deliveries from Turkey to Syria. As the case study, I shall explore the government’s management of its Southeast border with Syria to restrict NGO operations while reinforcing the operational space of several favoured organisations. Overall, this article argues that GoT used its certain leverage guaranteed through institutional conditioning factors, and its agency on not adopting select border management practices introduced through EU externalisation, to regulate and hamper humanitarian aid flow over its Southeast border with Syria to be in consistence with its political stance towards the Syrian Civil War, which overall led to shrinking humanitarian space in the Turkey context.

Suggestions

Adjustment experiences of Syrian refugees in Turkey: findings from a community-based participatory research
Altunay Yılmaz, Hilal; Erdur Baker, Özgür; Department of Educational Sciences (2018)
The present study aimed to understand the resettlement experiences of Syrian refugees, who are resettled in Ankara, Turkey, with respect to their strengths and assets. This study conducted under the framework of a community-based participatory research approach (CBPR). Seven adult Syrians (4 females, 3 males) with a mean age of 24.14 (SD=4.33) were reached with the help of community partners and attended in semi-structured interviews. The content analysis of the interviews was completed through a qualitativ...
The Limits of an International Burdensharing Approach: Syrian Refugee Protection Crisis and its Consequences
Kale Lack, Başak (2018-09-01)
This article analyses the consequences of the Syrian refugee protection crisis on the development of an effective international burden-sharing approach. It argues that despite the proven necessity of developing effective burden-sharing mechanisms at the EU and international levels, the Syrian refugee protection crisis has shown that limited progress has been achieved both at the international and the regional levels. This article brings these discussions under a systematic framework to show how the Syrian r...
Understanding state-civil society relations in education provision for non-camp syrian children in Turkey
McCarthy, Aslıhan; Şen, Mustafa; Department of Sociology (2016)
In the shadow of the Syrian conflict generating millions of displaced people, education provision for Syrian children has become a challenge for Turkey as the leading refugee hosting country. While great number of children who do not speak the national language is putting a strain on the limited capacity of state institutions, civil society organizations are trying to bridge the education gap for non-camp Syrian children. Given Turkey’s political interests and the evolving migration management context, this...
Policy and Planning in the Age of Mobilities: Refugees and Urban Planning in Turk
Güngördü, Nazda; Bayırbağ, Mustafa Kemal (Springer, 2019-01-01)
This chapter discusses the challenges posed by Syrian refugee problem (a multifaceted “mobility” problem especially hitting metropolitan cities) on urban planning practices and discourses in Turkey. Here, we portray the refugee problem as a multiscalar one, where international, national and local authorities meet the challenge in different ways. The multiscalar lens allows us to detect how various problem areas (security, sheltering, etc.) have become intertwined and concentrated on urban areas after refuge...
Intersecting interventions of global and regional powers in the Syrian civil war: motives, methods, and timing
Bilgin, İnci; Göçer Akder, Derya; Department of International Relations (2018)
Following the spread of the Arab Uprisings to Syria, a civil war broke out between Syrian opponents and government; consequently, thousands of people have died, injured, and been displaced. The Syrian Civil War paved the way for the emergence of various local armed groups which have claims over the Syrian territory. In the meantime, the world has witnessed multiple-interventions of global and regional actors in the conflict in Syria through diplomatic, economic and military means. This thesis focuses on the...
Citation Formats
Ö. Boztaş, “Shrinking humanitarian space in Turkey: The government of Turkey’s agency in shaping the operations of humanitarian NGOs in Turkey,” ODTÜ Gelişme Dergisi, vol. 46, no. 2, pp. 153–174, 2019, Accessed: 00, 2020. [Online]. Available: http://www2.feas.metu.edu.tr/metusd/ojs/index.php/metusd/article/view/1053.