International Perspectives on the State-as-Parent: Naive Idealism or Reluctant Pragmatism

Dixon, John
Welbourne, Penelope
Too many children remain at risk of harm, regrettably, in all too many societies. This is despite the almost universal acceptance of the 1990 United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child (UNCRC). Its intention, arguably somewhat naively, is to create two state imperatives: to protect children against threats of harm; and to advance their welfare. Governments, however, have evidenced a pragmatic reluctance to meet these challenges, perhaps a product of conflicting community expectations on the appropriate role of the state, combined with a scarcity of public resources. For the state to meet its UNCRC obligations requires it to have three crucial capacities. The first is the governance capacity to be able to take the necessary actions to prevent or correct the harm experienced by children. The second is the organizational capacity to direct sufficient resources to do what needs to be done in a timely manner, in a culturally sensitive way, and without causing them other forms of harm. The third is the epistemological capacity to know when it is in the best interests of children for the state, in the public interest, to stop particular child practices or to separate particular children from their families in order to provide the care and protection they need. These are the ultimate challenges facing governments if they wish to achieve the vision of the state as the protector and promoter of the best interests of children that is embedded in the UNCRC, to which almost all states have committed.


Child Poverty and Youth Unemployment in Turkey
Bayırbağ, Mustafa Kemal; Göksel, Asuman (Wiley, 2018-09-01)
This article investigates the nature, causes, and consequences of child poverty and youth unemployment in Turkey, which is a transition country between the East and the West. It is argued that this in-betweenness leads to a gap between the intended goals and outcomes of relevant policies. The article places a special emphasis on how the post-1980 neoliberal turn has shaped the policy orientation of successive governments, and transformed the nature of child poverty and youth unemployment in Turkey, making t...
Challenges of primary education in Turkey: Priorities of parents and professionals
Demir, Cennet Engin; Paykoc, Fersun (Elsevier BV, 2006-11-01)
This article investigates the major issues and problems of Turkish society that may have an impact on people's daily lives, and the characteristics required of primary school graduates as citizens in response to those issues and problems from the perspectives of parents and educational professionals. Data was collected from 407 parents and 389 professionals using three questionnaires developed by the researchers. Results indicated that priority challenges of primary education were considered to relate to pe...
The Second International: The Impact of Domestic Factors on International Organization Dysfunction
Ugur Cinar, Meral; Çınar, Süleyman Kürşat (SAGE Publications, 2014-10-01)
This article explores the role of domestic factors in international organization dysfunction, exemplified by the failure of the Second International to agree on a common stance and policy for the prevention of the First World War. Focusing on the French and German socialist parties, the two most powerful forces in the Second International, it assesses how domestic factors, such as differences in the dependency on the electorate, internal party structure and party-trade union relationships affected the polic...
The political economy of peace processes and the women, peace and security agenda
Erturk, Yakin (Informa UK Limited, 2020-07-01)
This article examines why the Women, Peace and Security (WPS) agenda has been so challenging to implement and argues that the political economy of war and peace, driven by a complex network of power, is a deterrent to sustainable and gender-just peace. However, peace initiatives are not a zero-sum game. They are dialectical, offering possibilities for both regressive and transformative change. Although inclusion of women and gender concerns in current peace processes lags behind expectations, the WPS agenda...
Transformation of social and political demands through ballot box: from los Indignados to Podemos
Bedir, Nurdan Selay; Göksel Uçak, Asuman; Department of European Studies (2017)
After 2008 crisis, alternative remedies and resistance against this age’s predominant neoliberal policies have been sought in many states and societies. Europeans harshly encountered with the crisis and governments’ and the EU’s crisis management policies raised multilateral and multilevel struggles like: the Pots and Pans Revolution in Iceland (2009), the Geração à Rasca in Portugal (2011), the Indignant Citizens Movement in Greece (2010), and los Indignados (15M) in Spain (2011). These movements had world...
Citation Formats
J. Dixon and P. Welbourne, “International Perspectives on the State-as-Parent: Naive Idealism or Reluctant Pragmatism,” POVERTY & PUBLIC POLICY, pp. 39–55, 2016, Accessed: 00, 2020. [Online]. Available: