Towards a Method for Building Causal Bayesian Networks for Prognostic Decision Support

2011-07-02
Yet, Barbaros
Marsh, William
Fenton, Norman
We describe a method of building a decision support system for clinicians deciding between interventions, using Bayesian Networks (BNs). Using a case study of the amputation of traumatically injured extremities, we explain why existing prognostic models used as decision aids have not been successful in practice. A central idea is the importance of modeling causal relationships, both so that the model conforms to the clinicians ‟ way of reasoning and so that we can predict the probable effect of the available interventions. Since we cannot always depend on data from controlled trials, we depend instead on „clinical knowledge ‟ and it is therefore vital that this is elicited rigorously. We propose three stages of knowledge modeling covering the treatment process, the information generated by the process and the causal relationship. These stages lead to a causal Bayesian network, which is used to predict the patient outcome under different treatment options.

Suggestions

Building Bayesian networks based on DEMATEL for multiple criteria decision problems: A supplier selection case study
Kaya, Rukiye; Yet, Barbaros (2019-11-01)
Bayesian Networks (BNs) are effective tools for providing decision support based on expert knowledge in uncertain and complex environments. However, building knowledge-based BNs is still a difficult task that lacks systematic and widely accepted methodologies, especially when knowledge is elicited from multiple experts. We propose a novel method that systematically integrates a widely used Multi Criteria Decision Making (MCDM) approach called Decision Making Trial and Evaluation Laboratory (DEMATEL) in BN c...
Combining data and meta-analysis to build Bayesian networks for clinical decision support
Yet, Barbaros; Rasmussen, Todd E.; Tai, Nigel R. M.; Marsh, D. William R. (2014-12-01)
Complex clinical decisions require the decision maker to evaluate multiple factors that may interact with each other. Many clinical studies, however, report 'univariate' relations between a single factor and outcome. Such univariate statistics are often insufficient to provide useful support for complex clinical decisions even when they are pooled using meta-analysis. More useful decision support could be provided by evidence-based models that take the interaction between factors into account. In this paper...
A comparison of data mining methods for prediction and classification types of quality problems
Anaklı, Zeynep; Anaklı, Zeynep; Department of Industrial Engineering (2009)
In this study, an Analytic Network Process (ANP) and Preference Ranking Organization MeTHod for Enrichment Evaluations (PROMETHEE) based approach is developed and used to compare overall performance of some commonly used classification and prediction data mining methods on quality improvement data, according to several decision criteria. Classification and prediction data mining (DM) methods are frequently used in many areas including quality improvement. Previous studies on comparison of performance of the...
Empirical evaluation of a decision support model for adopting software product line engineering
Tuzun, Eray; Tekinerdogan, Bedir; Kalender, Mert Emin; Bilgen, Semih (2015-04-01)
Context: The software product line engineering (SPLE) community has provided several different approaches for assessing the feasibility of SPLE adoption and selecting transition strategies. These approaches usually include many rules and guidelines which are very often implicit or scattered over different publications. Hence, for the practitioners it is not always easy to select and use these rules to support the decision making process. Even in case the rules are known, the lack of automated support for st...
Application of impulsive deterministic simulation of biochemical networks via simulation tools
Purutçuoğlu Gazi, Vilda (2017-01-01)
In order to understand the possible behaviour of biochemical networks, deterministic and stochastic simulation methods have been developed. However in some cases, these methods should be broaden. For oxii.rupie, if the biochemical system is subjected to the unexpected effects causing abrupt changes in the network, the ordinary simulation algorithms cannot capture these impulsive expressions. In 1.1) is study, we select, 1.1 ic simulations lools. specifically, CO PA ST and Systems Biology Toolbox for MATLAR ...
Citation Formats
B. Yet, W. Marsh, and N. Fenton, “Towards a Method for Building Causal Bayesian Networks for Prognostic Decision Support,” presented at the AIME’11 Workshop onProbabilistic Problem Solving in Biomedicine (ProBioMed-11), Bled, Slovenya, 2011, Accessed: 00, 2021. [Online]. Available: http://probiomed.cs.ru.nl/probiomed11.pdf.