Uncertainty analysis of a snowmelt runoff model using Markov Chain Monte Carlo (MCMC) approach

Date

2018-04-13

Author

Akyürek, Sevda Zuhal

Metadata

Show full item record

Item Usage Stats

147
views

0
downloads

Mountainous watersheds have always remained a challenge for the modelers due to ample variations taking place in those watersheds. The key reason could be the lack of ground observations and model parameter uncertainty. Generalized Likelihood Uncertainty Estimation (GLUE) approach is used widely to account for the parameter uncertainty only. However, appraisal of other sources of uncertainty is likewise important such as, forcing data uncertainty, model structural errors etc. This study employs Markov Chain Monte Carlo (MCMC) sampler, entitled Differential Evolution Adaptive Metropolis (DREAM) algorithm to account for the forcing data uncertainty, and a comparison is made with the formally used GLUE approach. A conceptual, degree day snow melt model, NAM is used to simulate the snow melt runoff of Ilgaz basin located in the northern part of Turkey and having 28.4km2 area. Mean elevation is around 1700 m and the basin is covered with broad leaf forest while the main soil is brown soil having high water holding capacity. Instead of daily precipitation and evapotranspiration (ET) values, individual storms and monthly ET values are optimized in combination with model parameters, and corrected values of the input forcing data are used for the calibration (2013-2016 water years) and validation (2017 water year) purposes. Results showed an over estimation in the observed precipitation values by almost 10% while an under estimation in the evapotranspiration values calculated by Penman Monteith method. The mean values of storm and ET multipliers are obtained as 1.14 and 0.84 respectively. Considering only parameter uncertainty, both GLUE and DREAM could not give Nash-Sutcliffe (NSE) values greater than 0.64, while an improved value of NSE (0.84) is obtained when explicit treatment of forcing data error is done using DREAM approach. Calibration of the model along with careful treatment of forcing data errors provided reasonable prediction uncertainty bounds and well shaped posterior distribution of NAM model parameters. Despite using a conceptual model, the physical meanings of the model parameters are also discussed.

URI

https://meetingorganizer.copernicus.org/EGU2018/EGU2018-523.pdf
https://hdl.handle.net/11511/84319

Conference Name

EGU General Assembly (2018)

Collections

Department of Civil Engineering, Conference / Seminar

Suggestions

OpenMETU
Core

Geochemical and geochronological data from charnockites and anorthosites from India's Kodaikanal-Palani Massif, Southern Granulite Terrain, India Sayıt, Kaan; Sivasubramanian, P; Dubey, C. S. (Springer, 2011-01-01) The Kodaikanal–Palani Massif is an important component of India’sSouthern Granulite Terrain; understanding the tectonic history of its rocks lendsconsiderable insight into its role within South India. The massif is located southof the Palghat Cauvery Shear Zone (PCSZ). Compilations of available geochronologicand geochemical information from charnockites north and south of the PCSZshow these rocks largely differ in age, with northern samples recording Archaeancrystallization events, whereas those to the sout...
Deterioration Problems of Basalts in Diyarbakır City Walls Dursun, Felat(2017-08-01) Diyarbakir province comprises characteristic examples of a geographical region that carries the traces of many civilizations from prehistoric to modern times. The remains and artifacts of civilizations reigned in Diyarbakir can be found all around the city. The Diyarbakir City Walls are one of the unique remains that surround throughout the city. Diyarbakir Fortress, as an important structural design of common mankind product, has saved its importance till the XXI. Century. The fortress is located on a basa...
Dinoflagellate cyst biostratigraphy of Miocene strata in the Adana Basin, Eastern Mediterranean, Turkey Turkecan, Aksel Tugba; Munsterman, Dirk; Isik, Ugras; Altıner, Demir; Pinar, Mehtap; Cevik, Tugba; Alay, Zeynep (Informa UK Limited, 2018-01-01) The Adana Basin is one of the major Neogene basins situated in SW Turkey with sedimentary successions providing good records of the paleoenvironmental changes that affected the Mediterranean area. Since a detailed biochronostratigraphic framework has not been properly established in the Adana Basin yet, this study will be the first multidisciplinary approach carried out in this region. In addition, a detailed biozonation based on marine palynomorphs was the first ever documented from the Kopekli Formation d...
Palaeoenvironment and human interaction during the last 4k years in the dried lake sediments (amik lake, southern turkey): evidences of lake level changes El Ouahabi, Meriam; Hubert-ferrari, Aurelia; Auwera, Vander; Avşar, Ulaş; Karabacak, Volkan (2019-02-01) The Amik Basin in the Eastern Mediterranean region has been continuously occupied since 6000-7000 BC. The landscape has sustained with highly variable anthropic pressure culminating during the Late Roman Period when the Antioch city reached its golden age. The basin also sustained a high seismic activity (M≥7) as it is a releasing step-over along the Dead Sea Fault. The study focuses on the sedimentary record of the Amik Lake occupying the central part of the Basin. Our objective is to constrain major paleo...
REVERSE-ENGINEERING EVALUATION AND MONITORING OF NEMRUT MONUMENTS Türer, Ahmet; Şahin Güçhan, Neriman (2012-01-01) The focus of this study is on the Nemrut Dag monuments, which were constructed approximately 2000 years ago at the peak of Mount Nemrut, 2206 meters elevation, are among the most valuable historical heritage sites in Turkey. Since the discovery of Nemrut monuments in 1881, many questions are unresolved, such as how the monuments were destroyed and why the damage level is very different between the symmetric east and west terraces. Natural causes, such as earthquakes, snow, or wind or manmade damages in the ...

Citation Formats

S. Z. Akyürek, “Uncertainty analysis of a snowmelt runoff model using Markov Chain Monte Carlo (MCMC) approach,” Vienna, Avusturya, 2018, p. 523, Accessed: 00, 2021. [Online]. Available: https://meetingorganizer.copernicus.org/EGU2018/EGU2018-523.pdf.