Effectiveness of Price Limits in Controlling Daily Stock Price Volatility Evidence from an Emerging Market

Price limits are instituted to control the volatility of daily stock price movements through establishing price constraints and providing time for rational reassessment of investment decisions during times of panic trading. They function in a similar manner as the circuit breakers in the US exchanges. Advocates of price limits argue that establishing such limits will not interfere with trading activity on an exchange. On the other hand, opponents of price limits assert that these limits can be the source of higher volatility on subsequent trading days, or can delay full incorporation of information into prices, or can interfere with trading activities of investors. Previous research on the subject provides conflicting evidence (Kyle, 1988; Ma, Rao and Sears, 1989; Kuhn, Kurserk and Locke, 1991; Kim and Rhee, 1997).The objective of this paper is to examine the effectiveness of the price limit system employed at the Istanbul Stock Exchange (ISE)-an emerging market that has attracted a lot of attention from international money managers recently. The ISE is a fullyautomated, order-matching market. Such a system enables fast dissemination of information among investors (Naidu and Rozeff, 1994). Also, the trading takes place in separate morning and afternoon sessions. Thus, price volatility can be expected to be higher in such a market and price limits may help to control this volatility. Hence, with its characteristics, ISE provides an excellent platform for studying the impacts of price limits on stock price volatility.For analysis, daily stock price data for the period of January 2, 1995 to December 31, 1999 is used. During this time period, there are two types of price stabilization mechanisms employed by the ISE: tick size and trading session price limit. The tick size rule specifies the minimum allowable price change from one trade to the other and the tick size varies with the security price. The trading session price limit rule determines the maximum allowable percentage change in the price of a security during a session and this limit is ten percent during the sample period analyzed in this paper.For examining the impact of price limits, this paper performs two different tests. The first set of tests aims to determine whether hitting a price limit on a given day has an impact on the volatility of stock prices during the subsequent trading days. For this purpose, for a window of ten days around the limit day, the daily price volatility of stocks that hit the limit is compared to that of stocks that did not hit the price limit. The second set of tests is conducted to determine whether hitting a price limit on a given day has an impact on the volume of trading during the subsequent days. For these tests, over a ten-day event window, the daily volume of trading for stocks that hit the limit are compared to that of stocks that did not hit the limit.
Computing in Economics and Finance 2000 Meeting (6 - 08 Temmuz 2000)


Do price limits help control stock price volatility?
Danışoğlu, Seza; Güner, Zehra Nuray (Springer Science and Business Media LLC, 2018-01-01)
On the negative side, price limits are criticized for increasing stock price volatility and hindering the price discovery process. On the positive side, price limits are argued to give panicky investors additional time to reassess their judgments and thus provide an opportunity for correcting the element of overreaction in pricing stocks. This study analyzes the effectiveness of price limits in Borsa Istanbul by utilizing a propensity-matched control sample in addition to the traditional benchmarks used in ...
How does the stock market volatility change after inception of futures trading?
Esen, İnci; Danışoğlu, Seza; Department of Financial Mathematics (2007)
As the trading volume in TURKDEX, the first and only options and futures exchange in Turkey, increases, it becomes more important to have an understanding of the effect of stock index futures trading on the underlying spot market volatility. In this respect, this thesis analyzes the effect of ISE-National 30 index futures contract trading on the underlying stocks’ volatility. In this thesis, spot portfolio volatility is decomposed into two components and this decomposition is applied to a single-factor retu...
Effects of opening trading mechanism and information flow on return volatility: additional evidence from the Istanbul Stock Exchange
Başer, Alper; Danışoğlu, Seza; Department of Business Administration (2009)
In this study, the effects of opening trading mechanism and information flow on return volatility are examined in the Istanbul Stock Exchange. The change in the morning opening mechanism from a continuous auction to a call auction on February 2, 2007 and the extension in afternoon trading hours on September 7, 2007 provide unique opportunities in this respect. First, it is found that the call auction trading mechanism has a decreasing effect on the morning open-to-open interday volatility and morning intrad...
Optimal market making models in high-frequency trading
Aydoğan, Burcu; Uğur, Ömür; Aksoy, Ümit; Department of Financial Mathematics (2021-4-08)
In this thesis, we aim to develop optimal trading strategies in a limit order book for high-frequency trading by stochastic control theory. First, we address for evolving optimal prices where the underlying asset follows the Heston stochastic volatility model including jump components to explore the effect of the arrival of the orders. The goal of the market maker is to maximize her expected return while controlling the inventories where the remaining is charged with a liquidation cost. Two types of ...
The role of trading volume, open interest and trader positions on volatility transmission between spot and futures markets
Ordu-Akkaya, Beyza Mina; Ugurlu-Yildirim, Ecenur; Soytaş, Uğur (2019-06-01)
In this paper, we investigate the role of open interest, trading volume and trading positions of trader groups on volatility spillover between futures and spot markets of two major commodities; oil and gold during the last two decades. The initial analysis including only spot and futures markets imply that the relationship is bi-directional for crude oil, and uni-directional for gold. Though, including open interest and trading volume enrich our results indicating open interest and spot markets are closely ...
Citation Formats
S. Danışoğlu and Z. N. Güner, “Effectiveness of Price Limits in Controlling Daily Stock Price Volatility Evidence from an Emerging Market,” presented at the Computing in Economics and Finance 2000 Meeting (6 - 08 Temmuz 2000), Barselona, İspanya, 2000, Accessed: 00, 2021. [Online]. Available: https://hdl.handle.net/11511/85084.