A critical review on the components of processability theory: identifying the limitations

Peker, Hilal
Toprak Çelen, Esma
There has been a tendency among the second language acquisition/learning theorists to make generalization about the stages that learners go through in learning a second language (L2). Processability Theory, developed by Pienemann (1998), is one of those theories. It is argued in Processability Theory that learners can learn an L2 in an order that they are capable of at specific times. In other words, learners acquire/learn L2s in a predictable order, which is called ‘developmental trajectory’. This article reviews Processability Theory from a critical perspective and investigates the limitations of and ambiguities in the theory through examining previous studies. The issues discussed in this paper include the hierarchical order, hypothesis space, grammar and lexicon, operational definition of language processor and its connection to Neurolinguistics and working memory, overgeneralization of features to all languages, and lexical functional grammar. Based on the review of these issues, it is proposed that Processability Theory may need some modifications and amendments in near future, as there is a need for more empirical studies.
ELT Research Journal


Design Development and Implementation of a Web Based Support Material for English as Second Language
Durdu, Levent; Özden, Muhammet Yaşar; Delialioğlu, Ömer (2012-01-01)
Language learning, especially second language learning requires systematic practice and repetition. Students are introduced with the new words in class sessions and they practice them via traditional methods such as continuously writing the direct meaning of the word or using flash cards. Computers have the potential to bring more attractive and enjoyable features to instructional materials. This case study tries to contribute to the understanding of design, development and implication phases of computer-as...
A study on motivation and anxiety for english language learners
Mutlu, Merve; Seferoğlu, Gölge (null; 2018-04-07)
Since scholars have discovered the importance of affective factors for language acquisition, anxiety and motivation has been frequently investigated in order to find how these concepts influence the success of a language learner. This study aims to investigate how the anxiety level and motivation level would affect the language learning process of a learner related to the learner’s gender, language proficiency level and major of study. The study was conducted in a School of Foreign Languages in a state univ...
EFL instructors’ cognitions and actions in relation to foreign language learning and teaching processes
Öztürk, Mustafa; Yıldırım, Ali; Department of Educational Sciences (2014)
The purpose of this study is to investigate EFL instructors’ language learning cognitions regarding linguistic aptitude, priorities in language learning, and good language learners; and language teaching actions with respect to pedagogical inclinations, instructional planning, error correction, learner-centeredness, and personal and professional development. The study also aims to describe the patterns of the relationships existing among those variables and examine the sources contributing to teachers’ cogn...
A Comparison of Student Attitudes towards Languages Other than English (LOTEs) in Turkey and in the USA
Çakır, Nur (2019-01-01)
The study aimed at investigating learners' attitudes towards languages other than English (LOTEs). The study also explored participant instructors' views on students' attitudes towards LOTEs. In order to collect data, a language attitude questionnaire was designed by adapting Students' Attitude Toward Foreign Language (SAFL) instrument. The study sampled a total of 316 students, 261 from Turkey, 55 from the USA. University students enrolled in a second language course in the USA and Turkey were compared in ...
A Case study on pre-service english language teachers‟ cognitions and practices regarding most commonly experienced in-class challenges
Çimen, Şeyda Selen; Daloğlu, Ayşegül; Department of Foreign Language Education (2017)
This study explores cognitions and practices of pre-service English language teachers in relation to dealing with most commonly experienced in-class challenges in foreign language teaching, the influences that shape their cognitions and practices, and the relationship between their cognitions and practices. Adopting qualitative research design, a case study was conducted to provide an account of pre-service English language teachers’ cognitions and practices. Data for this study were collected in two main s...
Citation Formats
H. Peker and E. Toprak Çelen, “A critical review on the components of processability theory: identifying the limitations,” ELT Research Journal, pp. 71–89, 2020, Accessed: 00, 2021. [Online]. Available: https://dergipark.org.tr/tr/download/article-file/1131078.