Comparison of Semantic Intent and Realization in Product Design: A Study on High-End Furniture Impressions

This paper presents a comparative analysis of designers' intended impressions and users' realized impressions of products, within the context of design communication. Its originality comes from the empirical approach taken, which examines the extent of users' shared impressions from products and their closeness to originating designers' intentions. Visual stimuli and semantic differential evaluations involving high-end furniture (n = 8) and representative target users (n = 80) were used. Data analysis was carried out in two stages (macro-level and micro-level) to detect mismatches between intended and realized impressions. The macro-analysis established how prevalent mismatches were, and reveals that messages grouped under 'usability and interaction' and 'personality characteristics' were more problematic for users to recognize as intended than messages grouped under 'social values and position' and 'qualities of form.' Across the product samples, designers' communication was found quite successful: approximately 75% of semantic intent is realized by users within +/- 1 point tolerance of designers' evaluations on a 5-point Likert scale. Nevertheless, a 25% rate of semantic mismatch beyond this range was established. The follow-up micro-analysis pinpoints bipolar adjective/phrase pairs that were graded especially 'close' or 'far' from designers' intentions, thereby illuminating whereabouts design effort should be placed to better realize semantic intent.


Evaluation of products through the concept of national design : a case study on Art Decor magazine
Kaygan, Harun; Kurtgözü, Aren Emre; Department of Industrial Design (2006)
This study examines the ways in which the concept of 'national design' informs evaluation of products and their designers, through the example of the field of industrial design in Turkey and the recently influential design magazine Art+Decor. For this purpose, first of all, 'evaluation' is analyzed as a means in which meanings are imposed on products, and as a tool in struggles for positions and status within the field of industrial design. Then, the role of 'nationality' in such a function of evaluation is...
Users' understanding of fun in consumer products
Cila, Nazli; Erbug, Cigdem; Şener Pedgley, Bahar (2007-04-01)
This paper aims to provide an overall picture of fun in product design by analysing users' understanding of fun and comparing the findings with the related human-computer interaction (HCI) literature. The results reveal that users interpret fun from many different viewpoints, which can be categorized under four subject headings: functional qualities, enchanting qualities, visual qualities and metaphorical qualities. These keyword categories constitute a valuable database for product designers to understand ...
Comparison of cognitive modeling and user performance analysis for touch screen mobile interface design
Ocak, Nihan; Çağıltay, Kürşat; Department of Information Systems (2014)
The main aim of this thesis is to analyze and comparatively evaluate the usability of touch screen mobile applications through cognitive modeling and end-user usability testing. The study investigates the accuracy of the estimated results cognitive model produces for touch screen mobile phone interfaces. CogTool application was used as the cognitive modeling method. Turkcell Cüzdan application, which is suitable for the implementation of both methods, was chosen as the mobile application. Based on the feedb...
Use of large multi touch interfaces: a research on usability and design aspects
Dönmez, Mehmet; Çağıltay, Kürşat; Department of Information Systems (2015)
This study explores the design considerations and usability factors of using large multi touch interfaces. During this study, an experimental approach incorporating a large multi touch interfaces environment was used. After the expert analysis and pilot test session, there were end user usability test sessions. During the data collection from both expert and non-expert users, there were interview sessions. After collecting data, two different analysis methods were used, namely, analysis for eye movement dat...
Communication of smart materials: bridging the gap between material innovation and product design
Akın, Tuğçe; Pedgley, Owaın Francıs; Department of Industrial Design (2009)
This thesis is intended to help eliminate misconceptions and missing information over the realm of smart materials, by offering a newly structured ‘Information Hierarchy for Smart Materials Communication for Industrial / Product Design’. Industrial and product designers are invited to use the findings of the thesis to assist in developing a common smart materials language and culture, enriched by details, technicalities, opportunities, and creative and innovative material attributes. The study commences wit...
Citation Formats
J. Khalaj and O. F. Pedgley, “Comparison of Semantic Intent and Realization in Product Design: A Study on High-End Furniture Impressions,” INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF DESIGN, vol. 8, no. 3, pp. 79–96, 2014, Accessed: 00, 2021. [Online]. Available: