The Benacerraf Problem as a Challenge for Ontic Structural Realism

Date

2020-02-01

Author

Davoody Benı, Majıd

Metadata

Show full item record

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.

Item Usage Stats

39
views

0
downloads

Benacerraf has presented two problems for the philosophy of mathematics. These are the problem of identification and the problem of representation. This paper aims to reconstruct the latter problem and to unpack its undermining bearing on the version of Ontic Structural Realism that frames scientific representations in terms of abstract structures. I argue that the dichotomy between mathematical structures and physical ones cannot be used to address the Benacerraf problem but strengthens it. I conclude by arguing that versions of OSR that do not rely on mathematical frameworks for representational purposes need not be vulnerable to Benacerraf's second problem.

URI

https://hdl.handle.net/11511/93861

Journal

PHILOSOPHIA MATHEMATICA

DOI

https://doi.org/10.1093/philmat/nkz022

Collections

Department of Philosophy, Article

Suggestions

OpenMETU
Core

The role of dynamic geometry software on mathematical creativity of pre-service mathematics teachers in geometry tasks Melek, Zülal; Çakıroğlu, Erdinç; Department of Mathematics Education (2021-7-14) The purpose of the study was to investigate the role of the dynamic geometry software on mathematical creativity of pre-service mathematics teachers in geometry tasks. The sample of the present study was five pre-service mathematics teachers in a public university in Ankara. The sample of the study was selected by the convenience sampling method from the pre-service mathematics teachers who took Exploring Geometry with Dynamic Geometry Applications course. The pre service mathematics teachers asked to...
The influence of the context of conditional probability problems on probabilistic thinking: A case study with teacher candidates Olgun, Beyza; Işıksal Bostan, Mine (2019-12-21) This study investigates the influence of the context of conditional probability problems on probabilistic thinking processes of mathematics teacher candidates. Data were collected from four mathematics teacher candidates through semi-structured clinical interviews. Teacher candidates were expected to solve and explain three conditional probability problems, which were selected based on specific contexts. The findings revealed that, when the context is related to a social issue such as health or justice, tha...
The influence of the context of conditional probability problems on probabilistic thinking: A case study with teacher candidates Olgun, Beyza; Işıksal Bostan, Mine (null; 2019-02-10) This study investigates the influence of the context of conditional probability problems on probabilistic thinking processes of mathematics teacher candidates. Data were collected from four mathematics teacher candidates through semi-structured clinical interviews. Teacher candidates were expected to solve and explain three conditional probability problems, which were selected based on specific contexts. The findings revealed that, when the context is related to a social issue such as health or justice, tha...
Philosophical implications of cantor’s set theory Şahin, Şafak; Grünberg, David; Department of Philosophy (2020-10-13) This thesis is devoted to examining Georg Cantor’s understanding of infinity and his philosophy of mathematics. Even though Aristotle differentiated the concept of infinity as potential infinite and actual infinite, he argued against the existence of actual infinity and accepted only the existence of potential infinity. With the effect of this distinction, the impossibility of actual infinity was regarded as the fundamental principle in the history of the concept of infinity. Cantor was the first think...
THE DEVELOPMENT OF ATTITUDES AND BELIEFS QUESTIONNAIRE TOWARDS USING HISTORY OF MATHEMATICS IN MATHEMATICS EDUCATION Alpaslan, Mustafa; Işıksal Bostan, Mine; Haser, Çiğdem (2011-02-13) This study intends developing a valid and reliable instrument in order to determine pre-service mathematics teachers' attitudes and beliefs towards using history of mathematics in school mathematics courses. The data were collected at the beginning of the fall semester of 2010-2011 academic year from 237 teacher candidates in Turkey via Attitudes and Beliefs towards the Use of History of Mathematics in Mathematics Education (ABHME) Questionnaire developed by the researchers. The reliability coefficient of t...

Citation Formats

M. Davoody Benı, “The Benacerraf Problem as a Challenge for Ontic Structural Realism,” PHILOSOPHIA MATHEMATICA, vol. 28, no. 1, pp. 35–59, 2020, Accessed: 00, 2021. [Online]. Available: https://hdl.handle.net/11511/93861.