Sense of community for distance education: Asynchronous discussion strategies

2019-10-30
STEPHENSON, SIMON
Sadık, Olgun
Sense of community (SoC) is the feeling of belongingness and recognition from others that one gets in a group. SoC is especially important in distance education programs where students often feel a sense of isolation and which tend to have higher dropout rates and lower performance than their face-to-face counterparts. Discussion forums play a significant role in the development of SoC for online courses, yet despite this there is limited research into the best asynchronous strategies to foster a strong SoC. Social constructivist theory emphasizes the interactions people have with others in their community to create knowledge as they interpret their world around them. The Community of Inquiry (CoI) framework draws from social constructivism specifically for the online learning environment, explaining successful online learning outcomes through cognitive, social and teaching presence. In this research study these theories, as well as previous studies in the literature, have been drawn on to design six different asynchronous discussion strategies including problem based solutions, audio response posts, sharing of personal experiences, debate, high teacher involvement and peer facilitation. Social presence, which refers to learner’s feeling of self-projection and recognition of others as real people, was the most instrumental aspect drawn on from the CoI framework to develop SoC. However, aspects of cognitive and teaching presence were also taken into account. Each week fifteen students in a post-graduate, online class at a private university in Turkey will participate in these discussions as part of their course work. For each discussion, data will be gathered on the students’ experiences of SoC through a series of responses to ten open-ended interview questions delivered via a phone call by the researcher. The scope of this conference presentation will be limited to the first strategy, problem based solutions, due to the available data by the conference date. For this discussion task students will first read a chapter on instructional design, following which they will be presented with an instructional design case study problem. In groups of three they will communicate via a discussion board, posting potential solutions to the proposed problem and working towards a solution they all agree on. This discussion strategy was designed on the basis that the social negotiation required to construct a solutıon as a group would promote higher levels of cognitive engagement as well as social engagement between students through higher levels of interaction. Both higher levels of cognitive engagement and social interactivity have been shown to be strongly associated with SoC for online courses. Data will also be collected from the first discussion posts, including the total word count contribution, discussion content and frequency of the response posts. The available data will be analysed using content analysis, based on the codes that emerged from the theoretical framework and thematic analyses to identify themes that emerge from the data. Furthermore, the students’ participation frequency results will also be reported in a table. The process of gathering data has recently commenced and preliminary findings will be presented at the conference. It is the hope of the researcher that this study will contribute to the literature by providing evidence for which strategies best develop SoC for online learning communities, and may be drawn on by instructors when designing their courses.
7. Uluslararası Öğretim Teknolojileri ve Öğretmen Eğitimi Sempozyumu (ITTES)

Suggestions

Contribution to the collaborative work in virtual organization - a case study
Weber, Gerhard Wilhelm; Özdamar, Linet; Pedamallu, Chandra Sekhar; Crespo, Fernando A. (Walter de Gruyter GmbH, 2012-10-1)
A virtual organization is a community of people who interact together socially on a technical platform. These kinds of communities are built on a common interest, a common problem or a common task of its members that is pursued on the basis of implicit and explicit codes of behavior. The six dimensions that are normally used to analyze virtual organizations are the use of technologies, sense of belonging, success factors, level of trust from members, virtual community management, and contents of the virtual...
Conjoint individual and group tracking framework with online learning
Yiğit, Ahmet; Temizel, Alptekin; Department of Information Systems (2016)
A group is a social unit which consists of people interacting with each other and sharing the similar characteristics. Because of social properties of group, group tracking re-quires taking into account not only visual properties but also social properties such as interaction of people with each other. Also, people groups are dynamic entities and they may grow and shrink with merge and split events. This dynamic nature makes it difficult to track groups using conventional trackers. Besides these difficultie...
Event Detection on Communities: Tracking the Change in Community Structure within Temporal Communication Networks
Aktunç, Rıza; Toroslu, İsmail Hakkı; Karagöz, Pınar (Springer, Cham, 2020-01-01)
In this work, we focus on social interactions in communities in order to detect events. There are several previous efforts for the event detection problem based on analyzing the change in the network structure in terms of the overall network features. However, in this work, event detection is considered as a problem of change detection in community structures. Particularly, communities extracted from communication network are focused on, and various versions of the community change detection methods are dev...
Examining the process of professional identity development of psychotherapists in supervision process: a critical discursive psychological approach
Uyar Suiçmez, Tuğba; Gençöz, Tülin; Department of Psychology (2019)
Identity is a forming notion based on the interactions people live in, and it is continuously formed throughout life (Burr, 2003; Erikson, 1968) like psychotherapists’ education process. The current study consists of two interdependent studies which examine the process of psychotherapists' professional identity development via Critical Discursive Psychology (CDP) approach. The first study comprises of two parts and aims to observe the changes in participants’ discourses through supervision training. In the ...
Building Resilience Amongst Communities in Europe (EMBRACE)
Karancı, Ayşe Nuray(2015-9-30)
In an interdisciplinary, socially inclusive and collaborative context, emBRACE aims to improve the framing of resilience in the context of disasters in Europe. It will develop a conceptual and methodological approach to clarify how the resilience capacity of a society confronted with natural hazards and disasters can be characterized, defined and measured. On the basis of a systematic evaluation of the widest literature base, the project will first elaborate an initial conceptual framework. Disaster footpri...
Citation Formats
S. STEPHENSON and O. Sadık, “Sense of community for distance education: Asynchronous discussion strategies,” presented at the 7. Uluslararası Öğretim Teknolojileri ve Öğretmen Eğitimi Sempozyumu (ITTES), 2019, Accessed: 00, 2022. [Online]. Available: https://2019.ittes.org.tr/dosyalar/files/ozetler.pdf.