Mapping relations between state and humanitarian NGOs: the case of Turkey

2022-02-01
Bahçecik, Şerif Onur
Turhan, Yunus
The relationship between states and non-governmental organisations (NGOs) is the subject of differing interpretations. Many observers of transnational civil society have pointed out a closing of civic space, including humanitarian space. Accordingly, many have focused on conflict and cooperation as main modes of interaction between states and NGOs. In this article we argue that a more in-depth look at state-NGO relations in Turkey shows that this binary framework is not sufficient. Relying on a framework that delineates conflict, cooperation, competition and co-optation as the four main patterns of interaction between states and NGOs, we look at the case of humanitarian NGOs based in Turkey. While aspects of state-NGO relations in Turkey indicate a co-opted humanitarian space, based on interviews with humanitarian NGOs in Turkey and secondary sources, we show that relations between the state and civil society actors are much more complex and evade simple categorisation. This underscores that ideological proximity does not always bring about smooth cooperation, and co-optation does not prevent NGOs from acting contrary to the wishes of the government. Humanitarian NGOs are also able to exert autonomous influence on governments.
THIRD WORLD QUARTERLY

Suggestions

BILATERAL AND REGIONAL DIMENSIONS OF THE RELATIONS BETWEEN TURKEY AND BANGLADESH
Rahman, Afzalur; Tanrısever, Oktay Fırat; Department of International Relations (2022-3)
This thesis seeks to examine the bilateral and regional dimensions of the relations between Turkey and Bangladesh. The thesis explores the relations between Turkey and Bangladesh in the diplomatic, security, economic and socio-cultural dimensions. This thesis argues that contrary to the views of those scholars who think that relations between Turkey and Bangladesh are insignificant because of the geographical distance between these two countries, Turkey and Bangladesh have developed their both bilateral and...
IMPACT OF THE LAW ON FOREIGNERS AND INTERNATIONAL PROTECTION ON THE STATE AND NGO RELATIONS IN TÜRKİYE
Gemici, Ali Aycan; Göçer Akder, Derya; Applied Ethics (2022-9)
This thesis examines the relations between the state & Non-Governmental Organizations (NGOs) within the scope of the Law on Foreigners and International Protection (LFIP) in Türkiye. In parallel with the new legislative practices, there has been a quite critical transition in the Turkish asylum system that initiates the Europeanization of main institutions and the manner of application in this field. In consideration of Türkiye’s promising to harmonize its migration-related policies in the process of full m...
VALUE PLURALISM AND COMPROMISE IN THE POLITICAL SPHERE
ATALAY, MERT; PARKAN, BARIŞ; Department of Philosophy (2022-9)
This thesis develops an account of value pluralism which claims that the conception of “the political” is constituted by value pluralism and accordingly, “the political” is the sphere that is comprised of plural values and aims. Within this account of value pluralism, making compromises is accepted to be the viable option of resolving conflicts and disagreements in the political sphere. Besides, as this thesis argues, when compromises are made sensibly, the plural ways of expression are maintained in the po...
Civil society in Turkey: the experience of civil society organizations
Tabakoğlu, Bahar; Akşit, Bahattin; Department of Sociology (2002)
This study concentrates its attention on civil society organizations (CSOs) - associations, foundations, chambers and unions- with a view to comprehending the existing situation of civil society in present-day Turkey. The research endeavors to catch the relationship between the state and CSOs and the relationship among the CSOs through the perspectives of the actors of civil society (the administrators and members of CSOs) and to describe the main social and political orientations of these actors. The study...
Rights-based civil society organizations and democratization in Turkey
Tanca, Dersu Ekim; Alpan, Başak Zeynep; Department of European Studies (2019)
This thesis investigates the role of the rights-based civil society organizations in promoting democratization in Turkey. I consider rights-based civil society organizations as focal actors for democratization because they initiate, secure and advance democratic rule by upholding liberties and freedoms. From the late Ottoman period to the 198ights-based civil society organizations were absent. However, after the 1980s, they emerged to represent different right themes. By employing the existing literature on...
Citation Formats
Ş. O. Bahçecik and Y. Turhan, “Mapping relations between state and humanitarian NGOs: the case of Turkey,” THIRD WORLD QUARTERLY, pp. 0–0, 2022, Accessed: 00, 2022. [Online]. Available: https://hdl.handle.net/11511/96891.