A class-based analysis of poverty reduction discussions and global middle-class argument in light of antagonistic character of capitalism: case study of Turkey between 2000-2020

Özgün, Gizem
The discussions about poverty, which started in 1980 and peaked in the 2000s, shifted from production relations to consumption relations. This orientation has reduced poverty debates to consumption relations and purchasing power by defining the poor at their consumption and purchasing power levels. Thus, based on monadic explanations, concepts such as individual-based social exclusion, citizenship rights, absolute poverty, and capability approach have replaced the class-based approach. Some debates have gone even further, linking poverty directly with economic growth and generating arguments that purely economic growth and globalization create a global middle class. Against this approach based on non-relational and individual-based explanations that divert poverty debates from historical, material, and class-based contexts, this study, taking Turkey as a case study between 2000-2020, explains poverty in line with the antagonistic character of capitalist accumulation. The study excludes 2021-2022 to subtract the Covid-19 pandemic’s effects on the economy. It reviews the neoliberal policies, data, and articles on poverty reduction, global middle-class arguments, and the transformation of labor-capital relations through the Marxist understanding of the antagonistic character of capital accumulation and capital-labor relations in Turkey. By doing so, the study analyzes poverty with Marxist concepts of dispossession, depeasantization, and proletarianization, which serve the capital/wealth creation for the capitalist and poverty for the laboring classes. The study contends against the global middle-class argument and the poor being a separate group, not a part of the working class, and argues that the poor are part of the working class. It also focuses on an understanding of poverty which lies its roots in production relations and exploitation, not the market relations and consumption.


Bringing classes back into poverty discussions
Özgün, Gizem; Dolcerocca, Antoıne (2023-1-17)
The 1980s saw a shift in the emphasis of discourse on poverty from production relations to consumption relations, with levels of consumption and purchasing power used to define poverty. Based on this concept, much of the research establishes absolute poverty lines or develops relative indicators to distinguish between “poor” and “non-poor.” This paper makes the case that such poverty measurement, while useful for assessing trends over the long term or taking into account relative dynamics, distorts our know...
An Analysis of social assistance programmes during the neoliberal era : Bolsa familia programme in Brazil as a case study
Durdu, Tuba; Yalman, Osman Galip; Department of Political Science and Public Administration (2012)
Brazil was confronted with high inflation while implementing neoliberal economic policies which were imposed as a panacea to the debt crisis during the process of transition to democracy since 1985. In this context, implementation of structural adjustment and stabilization programs further deteriorated its already unequal distribution of income and exposed the poor to devastating effects of the intermittent crises which were in turn the result of macro-economic policies pursued. Conditional cash transfers w...
The unionization (Problems) concieved by journalists in the post-1980 mediascape in Turkey
Arslantaş, Selma; Tılıç, L. Doğan; Department of Media and Cultural Studies (2009)
The 1980s as a decade is characterized by the proliferation of new information and communication technologies as well as the expansion of US-led economic policy following the economic depression of the 1970s. Deregulation, privatization and the withdrawal of the state from many areas due to the disintegration of the welfare state model were all common all around the world. All these significant changes affected the structure of the labour market, the work organization and the framework for the employment re...
The evolution of central Eurasia policy of the US in the post-Soviet era and the geopolitics of the Caspian oil
Değer, Deniz; Altunışık, Meliha; Department of International Relations (2006)
The objective of this thesis is to analyze the US Central Eurasia Policy in the period between 1991 and 2006. Within this context, the purpose is to figure out the foremost motive behind the US’s strategic engagement in the region with a due regard to changing geopolitical context with the demise of the Soviet Union. The main argument rests upon the assumption that the US regional policy is primarily motivated by geopolitical imperatives as the Central Eurasian region becomes the primary springboard for the...
Measurement of CO2 Adsorption Capacity on Selected Turkish Coals for CO2 Sequestration Purposes
BUNANI KEZA, BIENVENU CHRISTIAN; Argönül, Aykut ; Sustainable Environment and Energy Systems (2021-2)
The rapid industrialization in the nineteenth century caused an increase in energy consumption. This consumption is mainly met by burning fossil fuels which are the primary source of CO2 emissions. Geological storage is one option that can substantially reduce CO2 emissions in the atmosphere. In this work, the storage capacities of four different coal basins in Turkey have been estimated: Soma, Tunçbilek, Tekirdağ-Saray and Afşin-Elbistan. First, CO2 adsorption capacities of samples from the four coal basin...
Citation Formats
G. Özgün, “A class-based analysis of poverty reduction discussions and global middle-class argument in light of antagonistic character of capitalism: case study of Turkey between 2000-2020,” M.S. - Master of Science, Middle East Technical University, 2022.