Academic Mobbing in Turkey and Suggestions for Solutions: Content Analysis of Graduate Theses

Erdemir, Burcu
The effects of globalization on various sectors around the world are reflected in academia through competition, diminishing job security and faculty collegiality, and changing managerial understanding which causes academics to feel pressured to maintain the balance between teaching and research. This transformation inevitably has made the concepts explained by Foucault as "the power exerciser" and "the subject of power" more apparent, as demonstrated by conflicts and mobbing cases. The aim of this study is to review all the master's theses and doctoral dissertations written in Turkey to pin down what has been done until now on mobbing and to form a reference point. Upon searching for certain key words on the website of Council of Higher Education Thesis Center in June 2017, 655 theses on mobbing in various sectors with diverse participant groups were detected. After examining these theses in terms of their participants, it was found out that 29 of them, written between 2005 and 2017, addressed the issue of mobbing among academics. Of these, 26 theses, written between 2006 and 2016, were included in the study. The findings of these theses indicate that while there is 4-100% mobbing in the state and the foundation universities, younger people, singles, and women are more vulnerable to mobbing regarding self-expression, social relations, and communication, and they prefer to remain silent in the face of this issue. Besides, there is a negative relationship between mobbing and seniority, title, organisational justice, trust, commitment, and job-satisfaction. The primary causes of mobbing in academia are nepotism, poor leadership, unhealthy organisational culture, solidarity, andlack of communication. This study is expected to contribute to the formation of a conceptual framework about academic mobbing for the future studies and to expediting the process of taking measures for the eradication of the problem.


Academic Mobbing in Relation to Leadership Practices: A New Perspective on an Old Issue
Erdemir, Burcu; Demir, Cennet Engin; Ocal, Julide Yildirim; Kondakçı, Yaşar (Informa UK Limited, 2020-01-01)
Constant pressures emanating from internal and external environments of the academy have resulted in many changes, one of which is the workplace mobbing, an old issue for the broader field of organization science but a relatively new phenomenon in the academic context. This study investigated the relationship between workplace mobbing and academic leadership and the results indicated that the more positive leadership there is in an institution, the less mobbing behaviors are observed.
Psychological abuse in higher education in relation to leadership and ethical climate
Erdemir, Burcu; Engin Demir, Cennet; Department of Educational Sciences (2015)
In today’s fast changing world, educational organizations and the individuals working in them have become a part of a competitive work atmosphere. In such kind of an environment, opposition with colleagues and supervisors is almost inevitable for some people. This friction sometimes reaches to such an unbearable extent that faculty academic staff has nothing left to do but run away from that organisation. This phenomenon is known as “mobbing, bullying or psychological abuse at workplace”. It not only causes...
Challenges of Chinese and European Universities in the Modernization and Global Context
Zayim Kurtay, Merve (Springer Science and Business Media LLC, 2019-06-01)
Higher education systems need to increasingly transform in order to face new challenges of society in a modern and global context. Both Europe and China are facing challenges in restructuring their higher education systems and embracing the potential for higher education to deliver innovative teaching and learning as well as social and economic services for a changing society. This paper analyses the challenges to European and Chinese universities today and elaborates on the implications of these challenges...
Academic Leadership in the Post-Covid Era for Research and Teaching Practices
Kulakoğlu, Büşra; Emil, Serap; Zayim Kurtay, Merve (2021-10-18)
In organizational cognition studies focusing on higher education institutions (HEIs), it is emphasized that HEIs could not be thought apart from open system thinking (Neumann, 2012). There are five major aspects of open system thinking as inputs, organizational processes, outputs, environmental factors and feedback loop. In that system, being affected by the environment in three purposes of HEI, teaching, research and community service, is inevitable as experienced in internationalization practices, Bologna...
University governance and academic leadership: Perceptions of European and Chinese university staff and perceived need for capacity building
Zhu, Chang; Zayim Kurtay, Merve (2018-04-01)
The main purpose of this study is to explore Chinese and European university staff members’ perceptions about the challenges and capacity building needs in terms of academic leadership and university governance. A survey questionnaire with open-ended questions was administered to 58 staff members from 7 Chinese universities and 31 staff members from 8 European universities. The results showed that in addition to the competitive challenges universities encounter, developing leadership and managerial skills f...
Citation Formats
B. Erdemir, “Academic Mobbing in Turkey and Suggestions for Solutions: Content Analysis of Graduate Theses,” YUKSEKOGRETIM DERGISI, vol. 9, no. 2, pp. 213–233, 2019, Accessed: 00, 2022. [Online]. Available: