RETHINKING HUMAN RIGHTS WITH ARENDT: CRISIS AND PARADOX FOR NON-CITIZENS BETWEEN THEORY AND PRACTICE

Download

10513911.pdf

Date

2022-12-29

Author

Fırat, Merve

Metadata

Show full item record

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.

Item Usage Stats

338
views

264
downloads

The thesis aims to understand and analyze Hannah Arendt's understanding of human rights which is developed over the mass of stateless/non-citizen people that she identified in the gap between theory and practice. From the perspective of the study, there are naturalistic conception and political conception approaches in the human rights literature on the theoretical level. Arendt, on the other hand, develops a critical perspective on human rights by expressing the human rights crisis experienced by stateless people, who are excluded from the form of citizenship and deprived of legal protection, as a paradox. Arendt conceptualizes the "right to have rights" by talking about the existence of a more fundamental right that should be had before human rights. This relationship that Arendt establishes between human rights and citizenship challenges the discourses of human rights such as universality and birthright. By examining Arendt's human rights perspective and conceptualization of the right to have rights, the thesis argues that Arendt produces an alternative way of thinking for human rights, different from these approaches in the literature. After the theoretical analysis, the thesis exemplifies the human rights problems experienced by non-citizens through the impact of the Covid-19 pandemic on refugees and the statelessness experience of the Syrian stateless Kurds. With these examples, the thesis defends the practical validity of the relationship Arendt established between the subject of rights and citizenship. Thus, the thesis aims to contribute to the literature by evaluating the current validity of Arendt's human rights critique in theoretical and practical terms.

Subject Keywords

Hannah Arendt, human rights, the right to have rights, non-citizens, stateless, haklara sahip olma hakkı, insan hakları, vatandaş olmayanlar, devletsizler

URI

https://hdl.handle.net/11511/101228

Collections

Graduate School of Social Sciences, Thesis

Suggestions

OpenMETU
Core

Discourse on human rights : representation of the idea in Turkish human right Duduhacıoğlu, Başak; Rittersberger Tılıç, Helga İda; Department of Sociology (2012) The main concern of this thesis is to analyze the transformation of domestic human rights discourse by looking at the shifting representations of the idea of human rights. The representation of the idea of human rights in ‘Turkey Human Rights Movement Conferences’ in different political contexts during the period 1998-2010 is evaluated with reference to three areas of literature on the idea of human rights and with a social constructionist perspective which begins with the proposition that ideas and practic...
Relational Understanding of the Derivative Concept through Mathematical Modeling: A Case Study Sahin, Zulal; Yenmez, Arzu Aydogan; Erbaş, Ayhan Kürşat (2015-02-01) The purpose of this study was to investigate three second-year graduate students' awareness and understanding of the relationships among the "big ideas" that underlie the concept of derivative through modeling tasks and Skemp's distinction between relational and instrumental understanding. The modeling tasks consisting of warm-up, model-eliciting, and model-exploration activities were used to stimulate participants to reflect and construct ideas about the concept of change. The data indicated that the parti...
Examining hate speech from the perspective of Arendt’s political theory Binbuğa, Burcu Nur (Orta Doğu Teknik Üniversitesi (Ankara, Turkey), 2016-12) This paper intends to contribute debate on hate speech from the perspective of political theory derived from Hannah Arendt’s theoretical works. Although Arendt does not deal with hate speech head-on, her theory has been selected for this study partly due to the strong emphasis on speech as a precondition for being a part of public life and political being. This study argues that although Arendt would have certain reservations about the restriction of hate speech, her conceptual framework gives us clues...
Empowering Critical International Theory by Applying Action Research Methodology to its Inquiry Kurtbağ, Ömer (Orta Doğu Teknik Üniversitesi (Ankara, Turkey), 2011-4) This paper analyzes the influence and relevance of Gramscian and Habermasian critical international theories within the context of recent developments in the world politics that do not function in favour of these discourses’ emancipatory objectives and projections. It first looks at their emergence as alternative paradigms to the traditional conceptualizations in the discipline of IR and then compares the roots of their theoretical positions and their contribution to the analysis of international politics. ...
30 years of gender inequality and implications on curriculum design in open and distance learning Koseoglu, Suzan; Öztürk, Tuğba; Ucar, Hasan; Karahan, Engin; Bozkurt, Aras (2020-01-01) Gender inequality is a pressing issue on a global scale, yet studies on this important issue have stayed on the margins of open and distance learning (ODL) literature. In this study, we critically analyse a batch of ODL literature that is focused on gender inequality in post-secondary and higher education contexts. We use Therborn’s social justice framework to inform and guide the study. This is a comprehensive social justice lens that sees inequality as “a life and death issue,” approaching empowerment as ...

Citation Formats

M. Fırat, “RETHINKING HUMAN RIGHTS WITH ARENDT: CRISIS AND PARADOX FOR NON-CITIZENS BETWEEN THEORY AND PRACTICE,” M.S. - Master of Science, Middle East Technical University, 2022.