Comparative analysis of post industrial dockland transformation initiatives: guidance for policy for the haydarpaşa port and surroundings

Urkun Bowe, İlknur
Urban transformation initiatives are interventions that aim to manage urban change. Evolving from slum clearance and renewal, these initiatives took different forms throughout the century, in accordance with their social, economic and spatial contexts. The dominant urban context of the late 20th and early 21st century being deindustrialization and decentralization, urban redevelopment and regeneration initiatives became the highlights of urban policy. Alongside the ever-transforming residential neighborhoods and city centers, deindustrialization brought about change in some other parts of the city that had incredible value: Docklands. These areas were slowly being abandoned in this period; creating serious socio-economic and spatial problems while also creating unique opportunities for cities in their adaptation to the postindustrial economy. The fall of production as the basis of urban economies was followed by the rise of consumption, which cherished these vast and publicly owned spaces abandoned by production related uses. Turkish cities are, and have been, transforming with a pace which policy intervention can barely catch up with. Turkish docklands are under real estate investment pressure in a similar way to the vacant docklands of postindustrial cities around the world, but with one significant difference. Dockland transformation has not been the condition, but is the desired situation in our port cities; Haydarpaşa port constituting one of the best examples. While still fully functional, this important port and its surroundings, including the Haydarpaşa train station, has been subject to transformation proposals throughout the last decade. Following a number of unsuccessful initiatives, the latest proposal for the area has been “Haydarpaşa World Trade Center and Cruiser Project”. This thesis aims to understand the actual forces behind transformation of a dockland area in Turkey, and to determine if the proposals have been addressing these forces and factors. The study involves examination of the conditions of urban development in the postindustrial era and some cases of dockland transformation schemes launched in this period. The aim is to compare these cases and their backgrounds to the context of the Haydarpaşa area, in order to determine the relevance of the utilized policy models to transform this extremely valuable part of the Bosphorus.


Looking at the urban transformation project from the gecekondu dwellers’ perspective: the case of Mamak
Poyraz, Ufuk; Şengül, Hüseyin Tarık; Department of Urban Policy Planning and Local Governments (2011)
The gecekondu settlements emerged as a grassroots solution to the housing problem of migrant population in the lack of effective state intervention. Although most of these settlements gained legal status and title deeds in the following decades, they were still considered to be problem to be solved in due process. Starting from the mid-1980s, as a result of the so-called rehabilitation plans, considerable part of the gecekondu areas underwent a rapid redevelopment process through the market mechanism. The g...
Analysis of urban morphology in squatter transformation areas
Şahin, Mustafa Raşit; Yetişkul Şenbil, Emine; Department of City and Regional Planning (2014)
The impacts and results of urban transformation has been discussed as an important issue in developing countries by different disciplines as political economy, urban design, city planning and urban sociology. Urban transformation projects in Turkey are mainly criticized since the main focus is about physical transformation. In this context, the aim of the study is to determine what quality of space is produced by urban transformation projects in Turkey. Urban transformation projects creates a different scal...
A Critical evaluation of the urban transformation in Çukurambar, since the late 1980s
Ajazi, Gerta; Sargın, Güven Arif; Meij, Agnes van der; Department of Architecture (2015)
The primary purpose of this study is to put forward a critical examination on the urban transformation of Çukurambar district in the last three decades, under the forces of changing political, administrative, economic and social structure of the city. The fragmented structure of the neighborhood which resulted from the insufficient policies regarding the planning procedures in Turkey, is an inevitable problem which should be dealt with and the urban renewal plans prepared for Çukurambar should be investigat...
A design problem of under-utilized spaces : the case of Ankara-old industrial district
Cırık, Umut; Osmay, Sevin; Urban Design in City and Regional Planning Department (2005)
The problem of under-utilized spaces has become an important problem of cities during the last decades. In rapidly urbanizing cities, especially in the city centers where the early city settlement or old town was situated, many urban and industrial functions have moved out leaving behind abandoned or under-utilized. These spaces, due to political, economical, cultural and spatial reasons, could neither undergo healthy urban transformation process nor be reused. Such spaces pose problems to contemporary urba...
Do politics and ideology make any difference: an analysis of Dikmen valley project
Eren, Mert Anıl; Balaban, Osman; Department of Urban Policy Planning and Local Governments (2016)
Urban regeneration is the last part of a series of policies that are implemented to tackle the problems that cities face. The concept of urban regeneration has been evolved in relation to a series of social, economic and political change that mark different periods in historical context. There are both continuities and discontinuities between different periods of historical progress of urban regeneration. Urban regeneration projects are multi-faceted processes that require involvement of various actors in w...
Citation Formats
İ. Urkun Bowe, “Comparative analysis of post industrial dockland transformation initiatives: guidance for policy for the haydarpaşa port and surroundings,” M.S. - Master of Science, Middle East Technical University, 2008.