Ex contingente necessarium or a philosophical analysis of the connection between Weber and Marx

Download

index.pdf

Date

2010

Author

Kundakçı, Deniz

Metadata

Show full item record

Item Usage Stats

206
views

98
downloads

Max Weber and Karl Marx have been compared in various ways, especially since Weber’s Protestant Ethic and the Spirit of Capitalism was first published in the beginning of 20th century. The general claim was that their perspectives are completely different from each other. With the analysis of Protestant Ethic, they claim, Weber came up with a negative answer to Marx in terms of his analysis of the relationship between society and economy. However, in this study it is indicated that Weber’s analyses were in close proximity with those of Marx’s and these similarities can be seen in Weber’s both early and late period works such as “The Social Causes of the Decline of Ancient Civilization”, Economy and Society and General Economic History. Weber’s approach in this all corpus can be considered to be “a quasi Marxist perspective”. In these texts, he refers widely to Marx and elaborates the factors which he thought Marx had excluded from his analysis. Although he accused Marx of using a one-sided causal interpretation of history, Weber’s approach in relation to Marx has close parallels with historical materialism.

Subject Keywords

Ethics, Professional ethics.

URI

http://etd.lib.metu.edu.tr/upload/12612526/index.pdf
https://hdl.handle.net/11511/20094

Collections

Graduate School of Social Sciences, Thesis

Suggestions

OpenMETU
Core

Epicurus and Kant: a comparison of their ethical systems Kutan, Ali Haydar; Turan, Şeref Halil; Department of Philosophy (2010) In this Study, the empiricist ethical system of Epicurus and idealist ethical system of Kant will be compared. Kant maintains that as Epicurus’ ethics regards morality as a means for the attainment of happiness, it is nothing but a self-love ethics. He, for this reason, calls Epicurean morality “selfishness.” According to Kant, the maxims of happiness can be known only through experience but he says, experience can never produce a law which is universal and necessary. He contends that as Epicurean ethics ha...
Therapeutic philosophy: wittgenstein and heidegger Temizler, Büke; Turan, Şeref Halil; Department of Philosophy (2020) Considering comparative studies in philosophy, the relationship between philosophies of Ludwig Wittgenstein and Martin Heidegger has a remarkable place in history. In this thesis, I attempt to discuss their philosophies to reveal their common suggestion to philosophy, which could be understood as a cure to the misleading formulations of philosophical problems. Their philosophical method begins with giving attention to the pre-theoretical attitude of human beings in ordinary life, in evaluating the philosoph...
Critical analysis on marxist orthodoxies: a contribution of social history of political theory Koçak, Berkay; Birler, Reşide Ömür; Department of Political Science and Public Administration (2017) This thesis aims to identify the different approaches to historical materialism in a way describing the existing controversy between Political Marxism and mainstream (Orthodox) Marxism especially concentrating on their perspectives viewing the history of political thought. As the unique effort to understand the origins of political theory, the discipline namely ‘the social history of political theory’ -which was founded and developed by Ellen Meiksins Wood (1942-2016)- is revisited and reevaluated in compar...
Adam Smith and Karl Polanyi on the division of labor : a comparison and contrast Erkul, Abdullah; Özveren, Eyüp; Department of Economics (2013) The concept of the division of labor is comprehensively discussed in Adam Smith’s classic work, The Wealth of Nations (1776), and it holds a key function in his theory of economic development. As a rigorous reader of Smith, Karl Polanyi does not make use of this concept very much in his works; while he conveys Smith’s general understanding throughout The Great Transformation (1944). This calls for a review of the two authors’ use and perception of the concept of the division of labor. As opposed to Smith's ...
The theory of capitalism and its ontological foundations: comparative study of Marx and Deleuze&Guattari Kocagül, Volkan; Sol, Ayhan; Department of Philosophy (2006) The main objective of this thesis is to examine the theory of capitalism and its ontological foundations through the major works of Marx and Deleuze&Guattari. In his monumental book called Capital, Karl Marx develops an account of capitalism based on his understanding of philosophy of which takes its roots from Hegel and Feuerbach. Additionally, English political economy and French socialism serve as reliable grounds for Marx’s analysis. In light of the writings of these historical precursors, Marx constitu...

Citation Formats

D. Kundakçı, “Ex contingente necessarium or a philosophical analysis of the connection between Weber and Marx,” M.S. - Master of Science, Middle East Technical University, 2010.