Role of thought experiments in solving conceptual physics problems

Dönertaş, Şule
The purpose of this study was to contribute to the science education literature by describing how thought experiments vary in terms of the nature, purpose of use and reasoning resources behind during the solution of conceptual physics problems. Three groups of participants were selected according to the level of participants’ physics knowledge- low, medium, and high level groups- in order to capture the variation. Methodology of phenomenographic research was adapted for this study. Think aloud and retrospective questioning strategies were used throughout the individually conducted problem solving sessions. The analysis of data showed that thought experiments were frequently used cognitive tools for all level of participants while working on the problems. Four different thought experiment structures were observed which were categorized as limiting case, extreme case, simple case, and familiar case. It was also observed that participants conducted thought experiments for different purposes such as prediction, proof, and explanation. The reasoning resources running behind the thought experiment processes were classified in terms of observed facts, intuitive principles, and scientific concepts. The results of the analysis suggested that, thought experiments used as a creative reasoning instrument for theory formation or hypothesis testing by scientists can also be used by students during the inquiry processes as well as problem solving in instructional settings. It was also argued that, instructional practices can be developed according to the outcomes of thought experiments, which illuminate thinking processes of students and displays hidden or missing components of their reasoning.


The Nature and Role of Thought Experiments in Solving Conceptual Physics Problems
Kosem, Sule Donertas; Özdemir, Ömer Faruk (Springer Science and Business Media LLC, 2014-04-01)
This study describes the possible variations of thought experiments in terms of their nature, purpose, and reasoning resources adopted during the solution of conceptual physics problems. A phenomenographic research approach was adopted for this study. Three groups of participants with varying levels of physics knowledge-low, medium, and high level-were selected in order to capture potential variations. Five participants were selected within each level group and the study was conducted with fifteen participa...
The language-thought relationship on the basis of precedence of thought over language
Arısoy, Elif; Grünberg, David; Department of Philosophy (2021-8)
The aim of this thesis is to examine the relationship between language and thought on the basis of the claim that thought precedes language. The claim is meant that the processes of thought might occasionally be possible without the contribution of language, so the shaping of thought by language has limitations. Firstly, I shall examine the studies on the relationship between language and thought by focusing on issues as language shapes thought, language affects thought partially, and the complex structure ...
Effects of Conceptual Change Text Based Instruction on Ecology Attitudes toward Biology and Environment
Çetin, Gülcan; Ertepınar, Hamide; Geban, Ömer (2015-02-01)
The purpose of this study is to investigate the effects of the conceptual change text based instruction on ninth grade students’ understanding of ecological concepts, and attitudes toward biology and environment. Participants were 82 ninth grade students in a public high school in the Northwestern Turkey. A treatment was employed over a five-week period with quasi-experimental design. While two classes were called control group, two classes were called experimental group. Each teacher had one control group ...
Effects of conceptual assignments and conceptual change discussions on students' misconceptions and achievement regarding force and motion
Eryılmaz, Ali (2002-12-01)
The purpose of this study was to investigate the effects of conceptual assignments and conceptual change discussions on students' achievement and misconceptions about force and motion. The study was conducted with 6 physics teachers and their 18 classes, consisting of 396 high school physics students. The teachers administered the Force Misconception and Force Achievement Tests to their physics classes as a pretest. The results obtained were used to match the 18 classes statistically. Students assigned to t...
Implementation of systems thinking skills module for the context of energy
Can, Hediye; Öztekin, Ceren; Department of Elementary Education (2020)
The aim of this dissertation is to explore how pre-service science teachers develop their systems thinking skills in the context of energy. Qualitative methodology is followed through the research. The study conducted in stages that consist of development of systems thinking module for implementation, development of tools to collect data, implementation of the module, and data collection procedure before, during and after the implementation and data analysis. Nine preservice science teachers at the faculty ...
Citation Formats
Ş. Dönertaş, “Role of thought experiments in solving conceptual physics problems,” Ph.D. - Doctoral Program, Middle East Technical University, 2011.