A Critique of world - system inspired historiography of transition to capitalism in the Ottoman Empire

Download

index.pdf

Date

2013

Author

Erkurt, Beyhan

Metadata

Show full item record

Item Usage Stats

249
views

282
downloads

This thesis examines world-system inspired historiography on transition to capitalism in the Ottoman Empire that has been developed as a criticism of the modernization theory that was dominant in the analyses of the Ottoman transformation. It is argued that although the world system inspired analyses overcome the restrictions imposed by the modernization analyses that are based on the deficiencies of Ottoman society compared to the West, they are also crippled with their own restrictions. Considering change as a product of external dynamics, and ignoring internal relations and potentials, it commits the same mistake of regarding the ‘periphery’ as stagnant and shorn of any life, dynamics for creating change and therefore history. In this perspective, the peripheral societies such as the Ottoman society do not have the potential to be the actor of change but can only be subjected to it. Therefore, it is argued that the world-system inspired accounts fall short in understanding the process of change in the Ottoman Empire and the dynamics behind it. On that account, this thesis stresses the importance of studying the uneven but mutual relations between internal and external factors in order to understand social transformations that occur in and through the social relations and contradictions. There is, therefore a need to develop an account of the transition of the Ottoman Empire to capitalism with the help of such an approach.

Subject Keywords

Turkey, Turkey, Turkey, Capitalism, International trade

URI

http://etd.lib.metu.edu.tr/upload/12615599/index.pdf
https://hdl.handle.net/11511/22497

Collections

Graduate School of Social Sciences, Thesis

Suggestions

OpenMETU
Core

Contributions of the Ottoman Empire to the construction of Modern Europe Palabıyık, Mustafa Serdar; Yurdusev, Ahmet Nuri; Department of International Relations (2005) This thesis aims to analyze the contributions of the Ottoman Empire to the construction of modern Europe in the early modern period. Conventional historiography generally argues that the Ottoman Empire contributed to the emergence of the modern European identity only through acting as the ءother̕ of Europe. This thesis, however, aims to show that such an analysis is not enough to understand the Ottoman impact on the European state system. Moreover, it argues that the Ottoman Empire contributed to the constr...
Understanding the reform process of the Ottoman diplomacy : a case of modernization? Erülker, Cem; Kahraman, Sevilay; Department of European Studies (2015) The reasons that forced the Ottoman Empire to change its conventional method of diplomacy starting from late 18th century will be examined in this Thesis. In the first part, the basis of diplomacy and foreign policy will be examined with given political understandings and practices on certain issues drawn mainly from the European diplomatic history. In the second part, history of the Ottoman Empire would be mentioned briefly since it serves as the general contextual framework for understanding the need of r...
The Celali effect in 17th century - Ottoman transformation Cabar, Oğuz; Orbay, Kayhan; Department of History (2018) This thesis aims to examine the effects of the Celali Revolts -a series of rebellions in Anatolia- in the 17th century Ottoman transformation period. The transformation period refers to a period in which the empire experienced important difficulties and changes in military and financial institutions due to the effects of local developments and external events during the transition from the 16th to the 17th century. In this thesis, the effects of Celali Revolts are examined concentrating especially on demogr...
The Evolution and professionalization of economic thought from the late Ottoman empire to the Turkish Republic: the case of İbrahim Fazil Pelin Aslanmirza, Burak; Zorlu Durukan, Şefika Akile; Department of History (2018) The Anglo-Ottoman Trade Convention of 1838 – usually regarded as a milestone in the Ottoman Empire’s integration process to capitalism and the liberal world – also presents a landmark for the germination of Ottoman intellectuals’ interest in European economic thought and the acceleration of intellectual discussions on the subject thanks to the rise of private press. However, the transformation of economic thought from being the object of intellectual interest to being a separate discipline, accordingly its ...
Friedrich List, Ziya Gökalp and the national economy thesis in the Ottoman Empire Ünal, Hüseyin Safa; Özveren, Eyüp; Department of Economics (2013) This study compares the National Economy concept as it is employed in Friedrich List’s works with its theoretical reflections among Ottoman intelligentsia, particularly in Ziya Gökalp. The effects of National Economy on the Ottoman thought is examined by bearing in mind two journals: Türk Yurdu and İktisadiyat Mecmuası. The field of application of National Economy is explicated by an analysis of the first steps towards industrialization, especially after the Young Turk Revolution of 1908. It attempts to fin...

Citation Formats

B. Erkurt, “A Critique of world - system inspired historiography of transition to capitalism in the Ottoman Empire,” M.S. - Master of Science, Middle East Technical University, 2013.