The Relationship between students' preference for written feedback and improvement in writing : is the preferred one the best one?

Download
2013
Kağıtcı, Burçin
This study aimed to investigate a) which type of written feedback (direct feedback or use of error codes) university prep-school EFL students with elementary level of proficiency prefer to receive on their written texts, b) whether or not the (mis)match between students’ preferences and received feedback affect their level of improvement in writing, and c) to what extent the students’ previous writing experience affect their preference for the type of written feedback. In order to determine the students’ preferences for a specific type of feedback and to find out their previous writing experiences, a questionnaire was designed. Moreover, the participants were given two subsequent writing tasks with the purpose of determining the level of improvement in their linguistic accuracy after receiving their (not) preferred type of feedback. The results show that the majority of the students in the preparatory class with Elementary level prefer to receive use of error codes in their written texts; however, giving them what they ask for may not contribute to their improvement as would be expected. Moreover, some conclusions are made as to the relationship between the students’ previous writing experience and their current practices. .

Suggestions

The impact of teaching practicum on pre-service teachers’ perception of ELT
Arığ, Ayşe; Çopur, Deniz; Department of English Language Teaching (2016)
The purpose of the current study is to explore and identify the effects of practicum on pre-service English teachers’ perceptions of ELT. The study aims to interpret student teachers’ beliefs and perceptions after their first practicum experience during their school visits in FLE 425 School Experience. Five senior pre-service EFL student teachers, who had their first teaching experience in FLE 425 took part in the study. All student teachers were studying in the Department of Foreign Language Education at M...
Effect of a culturalist versus an interculturalist approach in ELT on Turkish EFL teacher candidates‟ proteophilic competence
Tekin, Mustafa; Seferoğlu, Gölge; Department of English Language Teaching (2015)
This thesis reports a quasi-experimental study on the effect of taking a native-speakerist/culturalist versus critical ELF-informed/interculturalist approach in ELT on a group of English as a Foreign Language (EFL) teacher candidates’ proteophilic competence (PC). The quantitative data were collected through the Proteophilic Competence Survey (PCS), English Varieties Attitude Survey (EVAS), ELF Opinion Survey (ELFOS) and a Listening Comprehension Test (LCT). The qualitative data were collected by means of i...
Student and instructor perceptions on feedback to student writing
Vanlı, Gökçe; Seferoğlu, Gölge; Department of English Language Teaching (2012)
Giving written feedback to students’ essays has gained importance by the emergence of the process approach to teaching writing. In the literature, many studies have been conducted to when and how to provide teacher feedback to students’ writing. In contrast, there have been very few studies on the teacher and students’ perceptions of teacher feedback. The aim of the present study is to investigate the EFL students’ expectations of, preferences for and handling of teacher feedback and to investigate the inst...
The Perceptions of pre-service ELT teachers on different modes of peer feedback and its relation to teacher efficacy /
İnce, Burtay Hatice; Aksu, Meral; Department of Curriculum and Instruction (2016)
The purpose of this study was to find out the perceptions of pre-service ELT teachers on different modes of feedback (i.e. written and oral peer feedback) and its relation to teacher efficacy. For this reason, a mixed-method design was used in order to answer different research questions. EFL Teacher Efficacy Scale (ETES) was used in order to find out efficacy levels of pre-service teachers before and after they were given different modes of peer feedback. E-journals and semi-structure group interviews were...
An investigation of learner autonomy and strategies for coping with speaking problems in relation to success in English speaking classes
Gökgöz, Burcu; Seferoğlu, Gölge; Department of English Language Teaching (2008)
The present study was conducted at Dumlupinar University, Department of Foreign Languages Preparatory Classes to investigate the relationship between degrees of learner autonomy, use of strategies for coping with speaking problems and success in speaking class of the participants. To determine the degree of correlation among degree of learner autonomy, use of strategies for coping with speaking problems and success in speaking class, 102 participants were distributed a questionnaire. The questionnaire asked...
Citation Formats
B. Kağıtcı, “The Relationship between students’ preference for written feedback and improvement in writing : is the preferred one the best one?,” M.S. - Master of Science, Middle East Technical University, 2013.