The Making of European common security and defence policy (CSDP) : the capability gap and its implications on NATO

Download
2013
Arı, Mehmet Mükerrem
During the Cold War period, NATO has been the primary organization that links the US and Europe on defence and security matters. European and Transatlantic forces have been very content with stable and extraordinarily predictable security environment. Nevertheless, after the demise of common perceived threat and with the emerging unpredictable threats and upheavals the security environment has become unpredictable. Moreover, the crises in Bosnia and Kosovo have provided dramatic confirmation of European weaknesses with regards to adequate military capabilities in the new security environment. The conflicts in Europe’s own backyard sharply manifested that without making an effort to improve its military capabilities, Europe’s influence and responsibility for ensuring its own security and stability would remain to be very restricted. These concerns led respectively to the emergence of the European Security and Defence Identity (ESDI), the European Security and Defence Policy (ESDP) and recently after the Lisbon Treaty the CSDP, parallel to transformation of NATO’s military capabilities. Although Europe’s military capabilities gap, the EU has embarked upon CSDP project. Therefore it is really interesting to see “How is the evolving process of the CSDP affecting itself and NATO in terms of transatlantic air forces’ capability gap?” The thesis argues that the EU has indulged in a path where turning back or turnover is really difficulty and inconvenient. The current CSDP structures seems to be locking-in the EU member states in the process of security and defence integration by continuous collaboration and cooperation. Given the established structures and completed/ongoing missions of CSDP, the CSDP project will continue to evolve although its current shortfalls and its capability gap. Nevertheless, the capability gap will affect to a great extent the operational capability (scope&range) of the EU member states. Moreover, the capability gap will affect the operational capability and harmony of the NATO as well. But the latter effect would not be as much as the first one as long as the US remains and stays in the organization of NATO, since it takes much of the burden.

Suggestions

The Organization for security and co-operation in europe in the post-cold war era: an analysis of its comprehensive approach to security
Karaaslan, Hakan; Bağcı, Hüseyin; Tanrısever, Oktay Fırat; Department of International Relations (2015)
The main objective of the dissertation is to analyze the Organization for Security and Co-operation in Europe’s (OSCE) ‘comprehensive approach to security’ in its region in the new security environment of the post-Cold War era. This dissertation presents an in-depth analysis of the OSCE’s practices over three dimensions of security, namely politico-military, economic-environmental and human dimensions, within the conceptual framework of ‘comprehensive security’. Despite the ongoing debates on the relevancy ...
Changing conceptions of european identitiy and shifting boundaries
Akyürek, Ahmet Engin; Ertuğrul, Kürşad; Department of European Studies (2004)
In the end of the 1980s and in the beginning of the 1990s Europe and the world witnessed the collapse of the Soviet Union. In the mid-1990s the member states of the European Union decided to enlarge the Union towards the Eastern Europe. Thus European integration entered into an unprecedented phase. Integration of the Eastern Europeans with the Western Europe contributed to the debates on the notions of European identity and the idea of Europe. Adherence of the East Europeans to the ideals of the Western Eur...
The Shifting influence of the United States on European Union - Turkey relations: a neoclassical realist approach
Özkan, Duygu; Eralp, Yakup Atila; Department of European Studies (2013)
This thesis explores how and why the United States (U.S.) support for Turkey’s participation in the European Union(EU) shifted from being an asset to a liability for Turkey between the years of l995 and 2005. There have been some earlier studies that analyzed the impact of U.S. support for Turkey’s inclusion in the EU on EU-Turkey relations. The purpose of this study is to contribute further to that literature with a plausible explanation for the shifting influence of the United States on EUTurkey relations...
Comparative analysis of EU foreign policy in Syria with normative power Europe and realist power Europe
Konur, Banu Nesibe; Bağcı, Hüseyin; Department of European Studies (2019)
One of the most important of debates over the role of the EU in post-Cold War period has been the Normative Power Europe which is built on the idea that the EU does not act as traditional actors in terms of foreign policy and has a norm-setter and promoter role in post-Cold War period. The Normative Power Europe concept has been highly embraced by the EU Representatives, as well. However, the anarchic structure of the system can limit the actions of actors and acts as an important determinant in decision-ma...
The Mediterranean and eastern enlargement of the European Union: a comparative study on the evolving EU acquis communautaire /
Kimençe, Duygu; Kahraman, Sevilay; Department of International Relations (2014)
The main focus of this thesis is analyzing the Mediterranean enlargement and the Eastern enlargement of the European Union by utilizing Frank Schimmelfennig's rhetorical entrapment theory. The admission of Greece to the Community in 1981 on political grounds which aimed to support the country's transition to democracy after the regime of the Colonels between 1967-1974 and the Community's own efforts in the same era to transform the integration project into a noble enterprise based on rights and values had s...
Citation Formats
M. M. Arı, “The Making of European common security and defence policy (CSDP) : the capability gap and its implications on NATO,” Ph.D. - Doctoral Program, Middle East Technical University, 2013.