The Relationship between upper and lower tier municipalities in urban planning: the case of İstanbul metropolitan municipality and Büyükcekmece municipality

İçyüz, İlke
Spatial planning is one of the most important tools to reach national development targets. Besides, planning is also a key tool to improve the quality of life in cities as well as to achieve urban development targets. However, an effective urban planning system that shapes and guides actual urban development is missing in Turkey. This is mainly due to the structure of current urban planning system which results in clash of authorities and responsibilities among public agencies. The urban planning legislation authorizes several public agencies at both central and local levels to prepare and approve spatial plans at various scales. Such a multicentric structure in urban planning usually ends up with lack of coordination among authorized institutions and organizations. Since the mid-2000s, we have been observing the problems of insufficient coordination and clash of authorities especially in the case of upper and lower tier municipalities in metropolitan cities. In order to overcome the shortcomings of current urban planning system in Turkey, the experience on the relationship between upper and lower tier municipalities should be reevaluated thoroughly. As per the current urban planning system in Turkey, “master development plans” and “implementation development plans” are the basic urban plans that guide urban development pattern. The division of labor and authorities regarding preparation and approval of these plans was for long shared accordingly between upper and lower tier municipalities in metropolitan cities. However, with the enactment of the Municipal Acts (Laws No. 5393 and 5216) in 2004, substantial changes, mostly in favor of upper tier municipalities, were made to the division of authorities regarding conduct of master and implementation development plans. In other words, urban planning system in Turkey has been centralized with the introduction of new laws on municipalities in 2004. One significant result of the recent legislation change has been approval of urban plans that take almost no account of local geographical, socio-economic, and ecological conditions in plan decisions. Contrary to expectations, accumulation of planning authorities in the hands of upper tier municipalities, or in other words centralization of urban planning, did not result in a comprehensive planning approach but rather triggered partial planning implementations and exceptional development rights and arrangements. Moreover, lower tier municipalities have become local authorities which take actions on construction-related issues without a holistic urban development vision. In the light of this background, this study aims at examining the problems emerged out of the relations between Istanbul Metropolitan and Büyükçekmece Municipalities in conduct of urban development plans after 2004 and at developing policy recommendations to reorganize and redefine the share of planning authorities between municipalities in order to facilitate better institutional coordination.


Impact of gender and social-class in usage of municipal services: tuzla municipality case /
Gacal, Kübra; Yavuz, Nilay; Department of Political Science and Public Administration (2017)
Local politics is closer to citizens in both social and spatial sense than central politics. Citizens’ daily lives are directly influenced by local policies so local governments have significant potential to make effective and efficient policies in order to solve local residents’ problems and to meet their expectations. Similarly, importance of local governments in providing gender sensitive public policies has been frequently highlighted. Municipalities as the main carriers of local services have been rega...
The critical analysis of alternative local government experiences in Turkey: the case of Hozat Municipality
Bozkurt, Engin; Ersoy, Melih; Department of Urban Policy Planning and Local Governments (2011)
When analyzed within Marxist theory understandings, local governments can be considered as a body of administrative, political, social and economic relations which are defined in a certain spatial scale based on uneven development of capital accumulation. This definition removes the local governments from the context of a simple organizational-administrative problem and places them into a political context. Hence, as experience and strategies of socialist customs in our country is investigated regarding loc...
The Changing relationship between urban planning and revenue generation in local government banking: the case of İlbank in post 2011 era
Balambar, Şelale; Balaban, Osman; Department of Urban Policy Planning and Local Governments (2019)
As main providers of local services, local governments play crucial roles in development of cities. However, in many countries, local governments are in need of technical and financial support to sustain their activities. To this aim, local government banking system models were established in various parts of the world. These banking systems can take different forms and show variety according to the social, economic and political structure of the countries. Despite all the differences, the main aim of the e...
Monitoring and evaluation systems for urban infrastructure services: a comparison of the systems applied by Turkish authorities and international financing institutions
Yıldız, Canan; Yetiş, Ülkü; Department of Environmental Engineering (2017)
In Turkey, urban infrastructure services are responsibility of the municipalities requiring close communication with the central governmental institutions at different stages of project preparation, design, construction and operation to meet the national standards. Although, significant progress has been recorded in terms of access to services, there is still need for increasing efficiency of service provision in both technical and financial terms. In the world, monitoring and evaluation has increasingly be...
The changing morphology of urban greenways, Ankara, 1923-1960
Burat, Sinan; Aktüre, Sevgi; Department of City and Regional Planning (2008)
Despite the abundance of descriptive studies on the urban development plans of Ankara, analytical studies on specific features of these plans, especially on implementation and modification processes are scarce. This study examines the green space structure brought in Jansen’s 1932 development plan of Ankara, the way it was implemented and the modifications that a component of this structure was subject to. The 1932 Jansen plan is a holistic and comprehensive plan that contained a conceptual green space stru...
Citation Formats
İ. İçyüz, “The Relationship between upper and lower tier municipalities in urban planning: the case of İstanbul metropolitan municipality and Büyükcekmece municipality,” M.S. - Master of Science, Middle East Technical University, 2014.