A Comparative analysis of religion-state relations: a case study on Turkey and Iran

Download

index.pdf

Date

2015

Author

Hazır, Agah

Metadata

Show full item record

Item Usage Stats

356
views

387
downloads

This thesis compares religion-state relations in Turkey and Iran by adopting a historical perspective. Mainly, the thesis explores the kinds of historical trajectories, international developments and cultural elements which generated distinct religion-state relations in these two national contexts. It argues that the main determinants of this relation derive from the varying degrees of institutionalization of the religious establishments. The historical analysis reveals that, the Turkish state inherited a type of state tradition in which religion was strongly controlled and incorporated to the state structure. Conversely, in Iran, especially after Safavid period, the state tradition was marked by the relative autonomy of the religious establishments from the state. The thesis also analyses the influence of international factors on religion-state dynamics. It reveals that direct international factors have been more influential in the Iranian case whereas in Turkish case indirect factors played a more decisive role. The thesis also argues that it is misleading to point the differences between Shi’a and Sunni sects in an essentialist manner to explain the different paths these two countries followed.

Subject Keywords

Religion and state, Religion and state

URI

http://etd.lib.metu.edu.tr/upload/12618598/index.pdf
https://hdl.handle.net/11511/24522

Collections

Graduate School of Social Sciences, Thesis

Suggestions

OpenMETU
Core

A Historical Materialist Analysis of Turkish Foreign Policy: Class, State, and Hegemony Yalvaç, Faruk (Uluslararasi Iliskiler Dergisi, 2016-01-01) This article aims to develop a historical materialist analysis to analyse Turkish Foreign Policy (TFP) as part of what I refer to as critical foreign policy studies. The paper utilises a critical political economy approach to TFP based on the Gramscian concept of hegemony and extends it to analyse different foreign policy strategies as hegemonic projects developed by ruling capital classes to sustain their rule. The paper also presents the concept of hegemonic depth to resolve the antinomies involved in und...
A comparative analysis of clientelism in Greece, Spain, and Turkey: the rural-urban divide Çınar, Süleyman Kürşat (2016-01-02) This article examines the evolution of patron-client relationships in Greece, Spain, and Turkey through the prism of the rural-urban divide. It traces which modes of clientelism (rural or urban) are more evident in these countries today, and why. Further, it finds that in rural modes of clientelism, normative bonds of deference and loyalty with a Weberian notion of traditional authority' and affective ties between political patrons and clients are more observable whereas urban modes of clientelism usually y...
Nationalism and religion in the textbooks of the early republican period in Turkey Babahan, Ali; Tokluoğlu, Ayşe Ceylan; Department of Sociology (2014) This study focuses on a detailed analysis of the relationship between nationalism and religion (Islam) in textbooks taught in Turkish education system between 1924 and 1950. It can be regarded as a re-assessment of general assumptions in the literature presuming the dominance of an authoritative secular nationalism in the textbooks of the whole early republican period. In this respect, the textbooks used at primary, middle and high school levels as part of the history, citizenship, sociology, and religion c...
Transformation of Turkish Islamism and the Rise of the Justice and Development Party Şen, Mustafa (2010-01-01) Deviating from the mainstream analyses of the AKP that see the rise of AKP to power as a result of the struggle between ocentero and operiphery,o this study is an attempt to analyze and understand the modalities of inclusion and accommodation of Turkish Islamism into the sociopolitical structure of Turkey. Therefore, it specially focuses on three interwoven processes: the articulation of Turkish Islamism with the Turkish Islamic synthesis; permanent enlargement of the religious field; and articulation betwe...
A Critique of the histories of European and Ottoman States: "from modernization revisionism" and "State tradition" towards an alternative reading Hasdemir, A. Seven; Aytekin, Erden Attila; Department of Political Science and Public Administration (2011) In this thesis two “western modern state” and three Ottoman “state tradition” scholars (Gianfranco Poggi, Christopher Pierson, Şerif Mardin, Metin Heper and Çağlar Keyder) are elaborated in the way how they write the the history for their theorization attempts. The specially emphasized processes in these histories are asserted to be reconstructed as the sources of an “idealized”-type that is assumed to be fulfilled by “the West” and should also be followed by “the rest”. The description of this form of a st...

Citation Formats

A. Hazır, “A Comparative analysis of religion-state relations: a case study on Turkey and Iran,” Ph.D. - Doctoral Program, Middle East Technical University, 2015.